poll Does GUTS deserve its 91 MC score?

[Treason]

 

Does it deserve?

Edited September 19, 2023 by Taeyong

[Virgos Groove]

No. A ~75 would've been more appropriate.

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Yes. It's a masterpiece.

[Zolanski.]

No, Sour >

[Space Cowboy]

This would hace gotten a 76 a decade ago.

[Blue Rose]

not really but good for her. it’s not hurting anyone 

[Baby Judas]

It's what the album deserves. Haters can keep fuming though..  

 

[KKW]

Yeah it’s really good sans lacy

[BuzzCharts]

Lol at the fumes already.  Old asses 

[BlackoutZone]

This 90 is more deserving than 83 than SOUR got so

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

Not even close to what it deserves (deserves less)

[whitehotforever]

yes, stay pressed

[shookspeare]

I like the album but no. But most albums that get 85+ these days really have no business getting those scores, MC is so inflated these days

[JoJo]

Oh wow, it’s her sophomore album and she already has a 90 on Metacritic. She’s a critic darling now and ATRLers can seethe 

[Ichinaru19]

Sour is much better so no maybe something in the 70s

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Yes, deserves 90

[Roberto]

No. Deserved 95.

[gatito]

deserves at least 95 best sophomore album since melodrama 

[Jjang]

68 in a normal world

[Miss Show Business]

It made me a fan. Deserved. Really great album.

[TheDreamer]

It deserves 91 because it's the Melodrama of this decade

[Matthew4815]

No, way overrated 

[Rotunda]

It’s a cute teen pop album, nothing makes nothing less. 75-85 would be appropriate.

Edited September 18, 2023 by Rotunda

[Big Bad Wolf]

Hell no. The critics are insane. They literally just don’t want her stans to get online and attack them. That’s the case for most of these overestimated scores. 
 

It’s 70 or lower tbh. Poptimism was truly a mistake. 

[Jude]

Too low. Deserves 99 at least.