poll Which is the better album: B'Day, Beyonce or 4?

[Popboi.]

BEYONCÉ > 4 > B’Day

 

 

Glad everyone can agree her bottom tier are Sasha and DIL.

[Pepo]

4 > B'Day > ST

[AxelFox]

ST is on a different league, idk why it is included here. That's her magnum opus. 
 

As for the other 2, I used to switch between them a lot as I consider them very similar and of comparable quality, but lately I've been feeling that 4 has the edge. 
 

Maybe because I'ce grown older and 4 is the more mature album but yeah.

 

ST

 

--

4>B'Day

[HEAVYONIT]

Beyonce

4

 

 

B'Day

[Starkboy]

Selftitled is Bey's best album so that.

 

but the other two are also fantastic. 

 

 

BEYONCE' > 4 >> B'Day.

[Tsareena]

4 is my personal favorite of the 3, ST is impressive and I'd consider it the best of the 3. B'Day is super underrated but it has some of her best songs like kitty kat 

[SlowGinFizzzz]

Beyoncé 

4

B'Day

[Ron Ng]

BEYONCÉ > B'Day >>>> 4

[Stallo]

 

1 hour ago, swissman said:

It goes:

B'Day
>
Beyoncé
>
>

>

4

 

B'Day is just that girl, she was the first visual album in her discography, has a crazy energy maintained basically till the end, has so many fan-favourites and is basically the blueprint of the Beyoncé sonic DNA: sassy, brassy, feminist, crazy in love, crazy out of love. And the fact that it's a concept album about what she wished Deena Jones would have said in the film... it's a yes.

This though

Edited August 29, 2023 by Stallo

[QueenBeyoncé]

ST>>>>> 4 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bday

Edited August 29, 2023 by QueenBeyoncé

[Unreachable101]

B'Day > Beyoncé >4

[swissman]

also, anyone NOT using the standard edition of B'Day in their assessment is doing it wrong... B'Day (standard) is a no-skips album!!

[FSXP]

BEYONCÉ is the best album of the 3 as an album, but the B’Day slander need to leave. The standard edition knocks TOP to BOTTOM. 4 can’t do that. 

[Mtjjproducer]

4 hours ago, Jai said:

Beyonce > B'Day (Standard) > 4

 

Beyonce > 4 > B'day (Deluxe)

This. I HATE the deluxe version of bday. I hate the standard isn’t on AM

[Jai]

1 hour ago, Mtjjproducer said:

This. I HATE the deluxe version of bday. I hate the standard isn’t on AM

It’s SO clunky! 

[suneclipse121]

1 hour ago, Mtjjproducer said:

This. I HATE the deluxe version of bday. I hate the standard isn’t on AM

I literally made a playlist with the og tracklist. The deluxe ain’t it. 

[Veckatimest]

These all alternate as my favorite albums of hers so this is hard, but I think it's 4 > ST > B'day, all separated by a hair.

 

B'day deserves no slander though, it was the first era where she struck that impossible balance between engaging in opulence and genuinely letting that be a liberatory path and means of control as opposed to yet another vague reinforcement of materialism, a trap that so many popstars of the same era fell into. I feel that it defined her career to come and her public image arguably more than any other era even if it didn't have nearly the same thematic heft as Renny, Lemonade, or ST. That is to say, it did what DIL and IASF couldn't lol

[Weld_E]

The one that has one of her best songs ever aka Partition.

[DamianSolo]

The best out of the three is the self-titled album. B'Day is still my personal favorite, though, out of the three; I love how uptempo and full of life it is.

[Mitsouko]

ST > Bidet > 4closure

[popularmoonlight]

Beyoncé > B’Day > 4

 

[flower moon]

4 >Bey > Bday

[Britney Is Fierce]

BEYONCÉ is objectively the better album and 4 is my favorite. 

[orange22]

Y’all give Bianca: The Album too much and 4 too little!

[KiiKii_Muppisha]

9 hours ago, Glamthony said:

 

Periodt.