MusicLoverDude Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 MLD's Critiques   Music Video Looks:  @Hey Dude -  Madonna: I actually really like this look. She looks elegant and pretty. Not something you normally expect with Madonna so it was a nice surprise. Good job.  @Kylie Verzosa - Rosalia: If you have to put a question mark next to your comment then it's clearly not a SLAY. This outfit is very...dull for a vampire music video. It just looks like a cheap outfit you could put together with items from the dollar store. Not impressed at all.  @blackoutbaby - CHEF'S KISS! Absolute slay   @Overprotected - Honey, this isn't the serve you thought it would be. I hate to be a heartbreaker to your average but when you have SO many iconic Mariah looks to go for...you go for a look that is serving inflatable life jacket . Sounds like you were obsessed with some Titanic type of fantasy if you thought this look was good. You have to be your own hero this late in the game and this ain't cutting it.  @Dessy - Ciara - Yes, this was one of the few good things about that boring Ciara video. Her dress was stunning and so was she.  @ZORBIT - Tinashe. This look is serving Helga Pataki in a wedding dress and that is a MAJOR compliment from me. Absolute SLAY. Some contestants still in this game deserve that axe slaying tbh.  @Julia Fox - Shakira. This dress is fine, and Shakira looks fine, but this isn't her best. The dress's color is too bold, Shakira's hair is too brunette-ish here to really match the turquoise and she's basically just sitting here looking bland. You have the audacity to say that I have "favoritism" in this game and then you send this basic ass look.  @Legend E - Kelly Clarkson. And speaking of basic looks, this is also very basic. Kelly looks fine, but that's it. Nothing exciting, nothing interesting. She's calm, that's all I can really say.  @Invisibility - FKA Twigs. Yes, this outfit combination is OFF the charts. Slay, slay, SLAY! Show these basic twix bars right above you how its done.  ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  RED CARPET LOOKS  Madonna - Is this the same dress I praised in the 2gate round? If so, it aged like milk. If not, this is still very basic for Madonna and very forgettable. Next.  Rosalia - Ugh...every damn judge and every damn contestant here wants me to say good things about you but these outfits are NOT going to do that. The color scheme is like Lady gaga decided to vomit up a creamsicle and wear it as a dress. And I don't mean classic Gaga, I mean Artpoop Gaga. This is literally just artpoop creamsicle. Next.  Rihanna - Not my personal favorite but still very much a good look for Rihanna. Serving classic and elegant woman of the 1920s.  Mariah - Much better. The black dress works pretty well with her hair.  Ciara - Not bad. Not her best compared to past rounds but this is presentable.  Tinashe - Hi Barbie. The pink is cute on you.  Shakira - This is much better. Simple, but elegant. Red is a much better color on her.  Kelly - This is her best look of the game I think. I think something is missing though.  FKA - Serving Gaga in the best possible way. Nice job.  ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  Madonna - This is ok. Madonna is known for out of this world editiorial shoots so this is good, but could have been better.  Rosalia - FINALLY a good entry from you. This is like the Little Mermaid meets Tina Turner and it actually works this time.  Rihanna - I'm sorry but I didn't even realize this was Rihanna's shoot. That's not a good thing when I can't figure out whose shoot I'm looking at.  Mariah - Love the pink hello kitty bedroom setup. It gives Mariah an innocent edge that I love and as an adult we TOTALLY deserve a bedroom we feel happy in.  Ciara - Ooh Medusa you are slaying honey!  Tinashe - This is ok. I'm kinda missing the point of this editorial shoot.  Shakira - Yeah this is the best Shakira entry of the round. She's serving everything here.  Kelly - This is serving poor man's Speak Now...Kelly does not have the charisma that Taylor has. Bye.  FKA - And we end with yet another slay from FKA. Good job.  @Yvess @stupidjock @EriKills @gardendreams @CBC @Hey Dude  Will turn in my scores now!      2
poki Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 Yeah that's a different outfit It did remind me of the previous fashion round but everything else Madonna wore seems bad or too simple to me.Â
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 WILL DO THE RESULTS NOW  @Overprotected @Hey Dude @blackoutbaby @Kylie Verzosa @Dessy @ZORBIT @Legend E @Julia Fox @Invisibility
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 1st Category:                             @Overprotected @Hey Dude @blackoutbaby @Kylie Verzosa @Dessy @ZORBIT @Legend E @Julia Fox @Invisibility  @stupidjock @MusicLoverDude @CBC @EriKillsÂ
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 @ZORBIT IS THE #1 FOR THIS CATEGORY  THE ELIMINATED GIRLS FROM THE NEXT CATEGORY Spoiler       @Overprotected @Julia Fox @Legend E   Â
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 2nd Category: Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 1 minute ago, Julia Fox said: omg SHAKIRA Â
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 Just now, Julia Fox said: oh wow this sucks so sorry legend
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 @blackoutbaby wins this round!  CHOP CHOP GIRLS Spoiler        @Hey Dude @Kylie Verzosa @Dessy Â
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 3rd Category: Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 @Dessy WINS THIS ROUND but since she got the boot from the 2nd category, the highest scoring player between RIHANNA, FKA and TINASHE will be considered the VICTOR of this round
ATRL Moderator Legend E Posted December 2, 2023 ATRL Moderator Posted December 2, 2023 @gardendreams you're such a legend 1
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 (edited) @Invisibility YOU WON THE ROUND!  you get a tiara you get to also decide if you will keep the extra for yourself or give it to someone else and also you get to block one of your fellow legends from winning a SPECIFIC category from THE BATTLE OF THE ERAS round       @ZORBIT AND @blackoutbaby YOU GIRLS ALSO GET A TIARA EACH!  Edited December 2, 2023 by Yvess
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023    B L O C K I N G  C E R E M O N Y   @Invisibility decided to Spoiler @Dessy you are blocked from winning a tabs tiara on only one of the 3 categories for the next round Invisibility will decide which category from BATTLE OF ERAS she wants you to be blocked from winning The other two categories that she won't pick will be up for you to also win a tiara if you land within the top 2 of those categories  @Overprotected@Kylie Verzosa @Dessy  @blackoutbaby @ZORBIT@Legend E  @Invisibility @Julia Fox  @Hey Dude  @stupidjock @MusicLoverDude @CBC@EriKills
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023  Now, we are entering the second to the last round of our game and it is just fitting to have this round where we get to see who among you has the most well-rounded ERA!  Welcome to the "Battle of the Eras" Round  In this round, we will be having three categories, BEST AESTHETICS - BEST SINGLE - BEST LIVE PERFORMANCE for each category - you need to choose a different era from your artist  WHAT TO DO:  1st Category: SEND IN THE OFFICIAL ALBUM COVER + 1 PROMOTIONAL PHOTO FROM THAT ERA        BEYONCE - RENAISSANCE ERA (2022) THE TOP TWO RANKING PLAYERS IN THIS CATEGORY AUTOMATICALLY GETS A TABS TIARA  2nd Category: SEND IN THE MUSIC VIDEO FOR THE SINGLE FROM YOUR ARTIST'S BEST ERA click the gif for video BEYONCE - SINGLE LADIES - I AM SASHA FIERCE ERA (2009) THE TOP TWO RANKING PLAYERS IN THIS CATEGORY AUTOMATICALLY GETS A TABS TIARA  3rd Category: SEND IN THE BEST LIVE PERFORMANCE DONE BY YOUR ARTIST note: the live performance should be in the same timeline of that era you've chosen. click the gif for video BEYONCE - RUN THE WORLD (GIRLS) LIVE AT THE BBMA 2011 - 4 ERA (2011) THE TOP TWO RANKING PLAYERS IN THIS CATEGORY AUTOMATICALLY GETS A TABS TIARA  HOW THE JUDGING WORKS: The judges will rank each category submission from 1-9 1 - 11 2 - 10 3 - 9.5 4 - 9 5 - 8.5 6 - 8 7 - 7.5 8 - 7 9 - 6.5  DEADLINE: DECEMBER 5TH, 12:00 AM EDT  @Overprotected @Hey Dude @blackoutbaby @Kylie Verzosa @Dessy @ZORBIT @Legend E @Julia Fox @Invisibility
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 @Invisibility has decided to keep the extra tiara for herself so which means she gets two tiaras added to her stats
Yvess Posted December 2, 2023 Author Posted December 2, 2023 Once again, thank you to the adorable @gardendreams for the efficiency in guest judging! LOVE YA! 1
Invisibility Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 57 minutes ago, Yvess said: @Invisibility YOU WON THE ROUND! My reaction to this information: Â Ty judges!
Dessy Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 2 hours ago, Yvess said:    B L O C K I N G  C E R E M O N Y   @Invisibility decided to  Hide contents @Dessy you are blocked from winning a tabs tiara on only one of the 3 categories for the next round Invisibility will decide which category from BATTLE OF ERAS she wants you to be blocked from winning The other two categories that she won't pick will be up for you to also win a tiara if you land within the top 2 of those categories  @Overprotected@Kylie Verzosa @Dessy  @blackoutbaby @ZORBIT@Legend E  @Invisibility @Julia Fox  @Hey Dude  @stupidjock @MusicLoverDude @CBC@EriKills Booooo
.thumb.gif.018912544cc5638eccd695a87c978b14.gif)
Recommended Posts