JayG Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 This could have been PERFECT with some more polishing
nooniebao Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 Love this and miss hearing her voice on something new to my ears. Hope we get an album next year!
Pop Music Aussie Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 i miss this era , where she pretended to vote on the correct side of politics. 1
Mirrorcle Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 I want to give her the benefit of the doubt that she aint that stupid to scrap this song. She probably kept this song for deluxe release like TDCC but Witness flopped so this song would never see a day of light. Please whoever meet her in the Las Vegas show, sing it right to her face. 1
Breathe On Moi Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 omg wait the full is kind of a major ******* bop this actually should have been the follow up to the lead….maybe one of the gays on her team will see this picking up traction have her finish it
slimfem Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 8 hours ago, Khris said: I love that we can finally be mature and say Witness is a phenomenal body of work. I also love that we know there are better choices that could have been made for the era. Apparently there is a Purity Ring collab... a Tinashe collab.. and obviously the more on theme outtakes we know of (Normalize, Save Me Some Tonight).. WITNESS is truly Katy's ARTPOP. A collab with Purity Ring?! What's the tea? I would love to hear that. OT: love the song. love the sound and production she was going for on Witness tbh. 1
Mystical Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 Smile was so terrible that this sounds like a masterpiece Miss her bops
Sweetestsecret Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 This should have been the second single after chained to the rhythm..what was she thinking?
Rodrighost Posted August 13, 2023 Posted August 13, 2023 4 hours ago, slimfem said: A collab with Purity Ring?! What's the tea? I would love to hear that. They produced Mind Maze, Miss You More and Bigger Than Me
Witnessed ET Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 (edited) This makes more sense in the album’s context than 80% of the songs that made the cut. Of course she scrapped it Also that chorus is GOOD. the fact that we could literally make a better Witness from her scrapped demos for this album Edited August 14, 2023 by Witnessed ET
Sexyzinger Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 The chorus is a SERVE I fear. @Walk_Away21 @Reverse Warholian
DuffLavigne Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 wtf this is so good, can't believe songs like Hey Hey Hey were chosen over this 1 1
SchmoodRing Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 On 8/12/2023 at 10:30 PM, nooniebao said: Love this and miss hearing her voice on something new to my ears. Hope we get an album next year! Weren't we supposed to get new music this year? All that teasing then nothing like what happened? On 8/13/2023 at 12:54 AM, Pop Music Aussie said: i miss this era , where she pretended to vote on the correct side of politics. Pretended? Katy isn't a Trump supporter you tried it On 8/13/2023 at 1:19 AM, Mirrorcle said: I want to give her the benefit of the doubt that she aint that stupid to scrap this song. She probably kept this song for deluxe release like TDCC but Witness flopped so this song would never see a day of light. Please whoever meet her in the Las Vegas show, sing it right to her face. It's crazy because even for a backlash era she did very well all things considered to be quite honest. I mean why hasn't she uploaded High Off Your Supply everywhere is an actual crime. On 8/13/2023 at 1:23 AM, Breathe On Moi said: omg wait the full is kind of a major ******* bop this actually should have been the follow up to the lead….maybe one of the gays on her team will see this picking up traction have her finish it This and Method To My Madness deserved to make it to the album over Hey Hey Hey, Power, Mind Maze, Miss You More, Tsunami, Save As Draft, Pendulum, Into Me You See, Dance With The Devil and Act My Age On 8/13/2023 at 3:21 AM, slimfem said: A collab with Purity Ring?! What's the tea? I would love to hear that. OT: love the song. love the sound and production she was going for on Witness tbh. Tinashe writing for Katy would definitely help elevate Katy's songs lyrically to sound mature and evolved without being too cringe, campy or cheesey. 23 hours ago, Mystical said: Smile was so terrible that this sounds like a masterpiece Miss her bops Smile, the song? Yes. The album itself is not bad like at all. 23 hours ago, Sweetestsecret said: This should have been the second single after chained to the rhythm..what was she thinking? Deja Vu and Roulette also should've been singles too 20 hours ago, Rodrighost said: They produced Mind Maze, Miss You More and Bigger Than Me I'm shocked to just learn about this. Bigger Than Me is the only good song out of the 3. 6 hours ago, Witnessed ET said: This makes more sense in the album’s context than 80% of the songs that made the cut. Of course she scrapped it Also that chorus is GOOD. the fact that we could literally make a better Witness from her scrapped demos for this album What other demos do we know of and got?
Mystical Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 3 hours ago, SchmoodRing said: Smile, the song? Yes. The album itself is not bad like at all. It’s Katy’s Lotus
Mystical Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 Yep, still a bop. The verses and pre-chorus are SO good. Katy’s voice over melodic beats makes me so nostalgic wtf. Witness was such a good album honestly. I’ll never understand why it was the beginning of her downfall.
Witnessed ET Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 13 hours ago, SchmoodRing said: What other demos do we know of and got? I know of these although I think Last Laugh was a Prism outtake and I Go to Sleep a Smile outtake. There are many others but most of them were from the OOTB days.
SalvoPK Posted August 14, 2023 Author Posted August 14, 2023 50 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said: I know of these although I think Last Laugh was a Prism outtake and I Go to Sleep a Smile outtake. There are many others but most of them were from the OOTB days. through the fire is from prism 1
Witnessed ET Posted August 14, 2023 Posted August 14, 2023 2 minutes ago, SalvoPK said: through the fire is from prism It could still fit in Witness sonically.
Tistotal Posted August 15, 2023 Posted August 15, 2023 I thought TTW was for Prism too. I go to sleep is better than anything on Smile sans HIH and NRO
Dula Peep Posted August 15, 2023 Posted August 15, 2023 On 8/11/2023 at 8:44 PM, Katamari said: this sounds..too good... is it ai? Probably 1
justlore Posted August 15, 2023 Posted August 15, 2023 Save me some tonight is idk why she changed her mind and decided to not release it
sam.teas Posted August 15, 2023 Posted August 15, 2023 13 hours ago, Witnessed ET said: I know of these although I think Last Laugh was a Prism outtake and I Go to Sleep a Smile outtake. There are many others but most of them were from the OOTB days. My Home (Let's Go Home) [~2017] The Devil That You Know [~2017] Cosmic Love (I Do) [~2019] too are slowly circulating, snippets out in the wild 1
Recommended Posts