reputation vs Renaissance

[Don]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

[JawBreaker]

Both for Reputation

 

Are people seriously believing that Renaissance is bigger than Reputation??? Its not even bigger in 2023 let alone overall 

When Taylor released Rep she was top 3 on IFPI global artist list when Bey released Ren she wasnt even top 20 like make it make sense 

[Aethereal]

Renaissance is better, Reputation is bigger. 

[ariesgroove]

[Marioland]

Reputation is better and bigger. Lemonade is better than Reputation though!

[KanMap]

reputation

[Eternium]

Reputation for both, easily. Alien Superstar needs some reworking but it has potential to be a classic.

[Brooklyn Baby]

Better: RENAISSANCE

Bigger: reputation

[Pepo]

6 hours ago, byzantium said:

LWYMMD is more iconic, impactful, successful, and better than anything on Renaissance.  Overall Reputation has the higher highs but also lower lows so it really just depends on what you latch onto.  For me, I’ll take the highs and sift through the lows.  

Bullshit aren't opinions, but I don't expect an Olivia Rodrigo stan to posses any musical knowledge, let alone a refined taste... and it clearly shows.

What an embarrassment. 

[Taylor fanboy]

Puta for both.

[byzantium]

20 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Bullshit aren't opinions, but I don't expect an Olivia Rodrigo stan to posses any musical knowledge, let alone a refined taste... and it clearly shows.

 

What an embarrassment. 

The hive show respect to other fanbases challenge: impossible. 

[Alldeezy]

My favourite Taylor album so that

 

 

It only be hard if it was between Rep & IASF 

(My fav albums from both these artists)

[Soda Pop Queen]

lol why no poll?

 

 

[unclefloprry]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

REPUT4

[Axelios]

11 hours ago, Century said:

Bey getting a smash hit and still breaking new sonic ground decades into her career and doing it after coming off of 2 flop albums is an enormously bigger achievement than following up 1989 with another good albiet less successful pop album.

Renaissance being a success for Bey low current standards doesn't make it bigger than Reputation.

[Diet Pepsi]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

 

Both incredible albums but I think Renny takes it for me

[Homebrand]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

 

Close... I might have to give Rep the edge for better album for now, but I don't feel there are any tracks on it that compare to AHAP, Virgos Groove and Cozy. 

[Theshigo Washidu]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

PURE/HONEY

[Pepo]

16 hours ago, byzantium said:

The hive show respect to other fanbases challenge: impossible. 

Trolls like you deserve none.

[Katamari]

 

[McNulty]

 ...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

[byzantium]

1 hour ago, Pepo said:

Trolls like you deserve none.

Lol. Ok boy.  

[FolkLover1989]

The fact hives actually think Renaissance is bigger than Reputation 

 

It's not bigger than Reputation even in 2023 

 

DBM itself is bigger than Cuff It and let's not compare everything else. 

[Broken]

reputation. Bigger and better.

[EnigmaticAndroid]

Reputation is obviously bigger. Significantly bigger album sales, more hits, and more Spotify streams despite being withheld from the platform. It's not even a discussion 

 

Renaissance is the better album though. Higher highs and more consistent.