reputation vs Renaissance

[Kimi]

Ren is much better come on now

[WitnessOblivia]

I prefer Renaissance (but Delicate and CIWYW are so good). Reputation is definitely bigger.

[QueenB]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

 

 If CIWYW or Getaway car didn't face off against the best tracks on Renaissance I'd probably choose them over some tracks. Renaissance is the clear winner for me though but reputation was clearly more successful 

[AvadaKedavra]

My opinion 

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl (This one bores me)

End Game (Fun son) vs Cozy (Too Sex club)

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar (Woah)

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It (Woah)

Delicate  vs Energy (Bee has better afropop songs)

Look What You Made Me Do (Iconic) vs Break My Soul

So It Goes vs Church Girl (This one bores mel like im that girl)

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa (So Smooth)

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove (Both masterpieces but this one is very special)

King of My Heart vs Move. Both are mid

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated  (lIKE BOTH equally)

Dress vs Thique. Both are mid

TIWWCHNT (Too childish) vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem (Love both equally)

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance 

Hmm looks like i enjoy both equally  Theyre good albums in general
Bey would have probably won with Lemonade. Thats my fave album from her

[Red Velvet]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

 

 

Renaissance wins

[WildHeart]

37 minutes ago, Century said:

I think you confused your hating every other female artist swiftie mentality with the way other bases operate 

Maybe, or maybe not 

 

 

26 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

a hit tweet calling your fave boring isn’t a hate train either, time to come up with something other than 24/7 self-victimization  

Miss me with that bs of rewriting history

 

The Depressingly Predictable Downfall of Taylor Swift-Elle

 

Taylor Swift's 'downfall': what the online celebrations really say - Guardian

 

How Taylor Swift Played The Victim For A Decade And Made Her Entire Career - Buzzfeed

 

A unified theory of Taylor Swift’s reputation

 

Is America Turning on Taylor Swift? BAD BLOOD

 

When Did the Media Turn Against Taylor Swift? - Vulture

 

But yes, Reputation will end up bigger than any Beyonce album but IASF because unlike Beyonce albums, people listen Taylor's albums more than few years and they have longevity 

Edited June 30, 2023 by Artistofthedecade

[ugo]

24 minutes ago, Century said:

Beyonce went nearly 10 years without a big domestic hit, longer if we look for one the size of Cuff It. She also had 2 flop albums in a row before Ren which she's always been an albums artist so it was looking bad for her. She also debuted 25 years before renaissance released. She's also black and a woman in America making mildly politically charged dance music(there are several layers of disadvantage here even without the greater context of her career).

 

She had every chance to drop the ball or not reach her audience with Renaissance and defied all odds by releasing a project so successful and so good it still has stans of the biggest star in the world fuming. That's the unprecedented part. If you don't think that success is special you're just biased against Beyonce.

umm I was talking about the music not about her career 

[ScorpiosGroove]

3 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Maybe, or maybe not 

 

 

Miss me with that bs of rewriting history

 

The Depressingly Predictable Downfall of Taylor Swift-Elle

 

Taylor Swift's 'downfall': what the online celebrations really say - Guardian

 

How Taylor Swift Played The Victim For A Decade And Made Her Entire Career - Buzzfeed

 

A unified theory of Taylor Swift’s reputation

 

Is America Turning on Taylor Swift? BAD BLOOD

 

When Did the Media Turn Against Taylor Swift? - Vulture

 

But yes, Reputation will end up bigger than any Beyonce album but IASF because unlike Beyonce albums, people listen Taylor's albums more than few years 

oh boohoo poor thing, 5 articles and a buzzfeed thread omg how will she ever recover from this much hate 

 

 

actually the buzzfeed article is a kii and spot on, they should’ve included her whiny fanbase who spends just as much time victimizing themselves 

Edited June 30, 2023 by ScorpiosGroove

[Kimmo]

1 hour ago, CaptainMusic said:

Reputation was clearly the bigger album, especially now with Cruel Summer

You mean “Lover”? 

[Sheep]

5 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Maybe, or maybe not 

I also skulldragged Beyonce on more than one occasion for being the most egregious capitalist out of all the main pop acts. The bias you're looking for isn't there I had a VIP ticket to the opening night of the Rep tour. I've also been bemoaning my own fav's makeup brand since it launched. Having a problem with hypocrisy isn't the same as being personally threatened by others' success and how it affects somebody who I don't know personally.

Edited June 30, 2023 by Century

[CaptainMusic]

58 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Nnn  

 

1 minute ago, Kimmo said:

You mean “Lover”? 

Mess  

 

The answer still remains the same anyway 

[WildHeart]

10 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

oh boohoo poor thing, 5 articles and a buzzfeed thread omg how will she ever recover from this much hate 

She did and we moved on unlike Hive who still has endless excuses with how controversial figure Beyonce is when it comes to relevance of her catalogue 

Edited June 30, 2023 by Artistofthedecade

[Popboi.]

Enough with these threads

[suneclipse121]

37 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

Of course they are

Critics don't think so... I think Renaissance is more acclaimed than all of those albums you listed. So basing it off sales means nothing in a quality discussion.Putting that aside Renaissance is a well seasoned entree to Taylor’s pick an album salt and pepper dry chicken. 

[ScorpiosGroove]

23 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

She did and we moved on unlike Hive who still has endless excuses with how controversial figure Beyonce is when it comes to relevance of her catalogue 

you’ve just spend an hour mentioning a non-existent hate train while looking up multiple articles, is the moving on in the room with us 

[deal dough]

puta sweetie I am SO sorry

[WildHeart]

19 hours ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

you’ve just spend an hour mentioning a non-existent hate train while looking up multiple articles, is the moving on in the room with us 

Considering that 3 of your posts about the non-existence of any hate train, you may have a bigger problem about something that doesn’t exist. 

 

OT : Reputation will end up bigger than 6/7 of Beyonce albums, with or without hate trains. 

Edited July 1, 2023 by Artistofthedecade

[ScorpiosGroove]

1 minute ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Considering that 3 of your posts about the non-existence of hate any train, you may have a bigger problem about something that doesn’t exist. 

 

OT : Reputation will end up bigger than 6/7 of Beyonce albums, with or without hate trains. 

cry some more 

[Shelter]

23 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

you’ve just spend an hour mentioning a non-existent hate train while looking up multiple articles, is the moving on in the room with us 

The hate Taylor got was mild, and they think it’s huge. The other big pop girls get way more hate and cry less about it. Taylor and her fans can’t handle a bit of criticism. 

[WildHeart]

3 minutes ago, Shelter said:

The hate Taylor got was mild, and they think it’s huge. The other big pop girls get way more hate and cry less about it. Taylor and her fans can’t handle a bit of criticism. 

Calling an artist nazi, white supremacist and snake = criticism 

 

Edited June 30, 2023 by Artistofthedecade

[ScorpiosGroove]

5 minutes ago, Shelter said:

The hate Taylor got was mild, and they think it’s huge. The other big pop girls get way more hate and cry less about it. Taylor and her fans can’t handle a bit of criticism. 

didn’t you know ? calling someone a snake is THE worst experience anyone could ever go through 

 

 

 

[Shelter]

4 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Calling an artist nazi, white supremacist and snake = criticism 

 

Now go look what they call others. Tay fans are literally attacking Lizzo right now calling her all sorts 

[WildHeart]

2 minutes ago, Shelter said:

Now go look what they call others. Tay fans are literally attacking Lizzo right now calling her all sorts 

Are you seriously comparing what few teenager in stan twitter saying to biggest publications in the world 

[Selegend]

I only like listening to Renaissance in a certain mood. For example in a Friday night with my friends doing pre-drinks before going out. 

Or working out at the gym, etc. It's so noisy for me to listen on a Wednesday while working at the office or driving on a tuesday morning. 

 

Reputation i can listen anytime anywhere i want and i just BOP to it. Driving on a morning, or while i'm working at the office and ALSO at the gym or with my friends doing pre-drinks. So i like it better, it's the better album for me. 

 

About which one is bigger, facts are facts. Reputation too. 

Edited June 30, 2023 by Selegend

[Illuminati]

I thoroughly enjoy both and they're both very replayable from start to finish so it's a hard pick

 

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance