reputation vs Renaissance

[FolkLover1989]

How is Renaissance bigger?

 

Some people really 

[WokeEqualist]

54 minutes ago, Safe&Sound said:

Hailed by the fandom as their best works

 

 

No one sees reputation as Taylor's best if anything most stans have it at the bottom of their lists

 

Plus, the albums literally sound nothing alike or have the same themes or aesthetics  come up with something more creative next time

[Queen Of Slay]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

[Jon Snow]

22 minutes ago, byzantium said:

LWYMMD is more iconic, impactful, successful, and better than anything on Renaissance

well if you're talking about meme and mockery material than you're right

[ugo]

1 hour ago, Safe&Sound said:

2 albums started with r letter, hailed by the fandom as their best works

Both albums are heavily produced with layered beats and vocals

 

 

The set up that's folklore 

[suneclipse121]

25 minutes ago, greento said:

Renaissance better

reputation bigger

This 

[Sheep]

7 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

ST and Lemonade were flops but Renaissance is that smash? 

How were 2 of the biggest albums of their respective years flops? Like somebody else said you know exactly which flop projects I'm talking about. 

[Badgalbriel]

Ren is of course better. The only Taylor albums that are better than Renaissance are Folklore, Evermore, Speak Now and 1989. Renaissance is better than the rest. 

Reputation is of course bigger 

[Badgalbriel]

And NO ONE thinks Reputation is Taylor's best album. 

[WildHeart]

9 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

they are obviously not talking about ST or Lemonade use your brain 

 

2 minutes ago, Century said:

How were 2 of the biggest albums of their respective years flops? Like somebody else said you know exactly which flop projects I'm talking about. 

They were indeed huge flops that i didn't even remember their existence but... 

 

Releasing Renaissance after 2 side projects which were not even supposed to perform like new studio albums is impressive but releasing 14M selling album after a hate train is somehow not impressive at all 

[Chromatica]

RENAISSANCE

[HausofArtpopII]

if you're gonna compare albums at least to idk Lemonade vs Folklore or smthn 

[Pheromosa]

RENNY >>>

Do swifties even like reputa? 

[Sheep]

4 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Releasing Renaissance after 2 side projects which were not even supposed to perform like new studio albums is impressive but releasing 14M selling album after a hate train is somehow not impressive at all 

I never said Reputation was unimpressive or bad. What Beyonce did with renaissance however, is almost unprecedented in the scope of the industry. I can think of a dozen blockbuster follow ups to career peak pop albums, it doesn't make Reputation any less impressive but we're comparing an expected smash to somebody breaking every rule and expectation and I feel like that needed mentioning. 

 

I think you confused your hating every other female artist swiftie mentality with the way other bases operate because there wasn't any shade in my posts.

Edited June 30, 2023 by Century

[yourfaveisaflop]

this was so hard i love both albums 

 

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I DId Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated  tie

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem  tie

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

[suneclipse121]

6 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

Ren is of course better. The only Taylor albums that are better than Renaissance are Folklore, Evermore, Speak Now and 1989. Renaissance is better than the rest. 

Reputation is of course bigger 

The way none of those albums are better than Renaissance  Maybe you should have used I Am Sashs Fierce. You might have an argument there.

[ugo]

3 minutes ago, Century said:

I never said Reputation was unimpressive or bad. What Beyonce did with renaissance however, is almost unprecedented in the scope of the industry. I can think of a dozen blockbuster follow ups to career peak pop albums, it doesn't make Reputation any less impressive but we're comparing an expected smash to somebody breaking every rule and expectation and I feel like that needed mentioning. 

 

I think you confused your hating every other female artist swiftie mentality with the way other bases operate because there wasn't any shade in my posts.

She just rehashed old sounds 

[ScorpiosGroove]

12 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

 

They were indeed huge flops that i didn't even remember their existence but... 

 

Releasing Renaissance after 2 side projects which were not even supposed to perform like new studio albums is impressive but releasing 14M selling album after a hate train is somehow not impressive at all 

no, following up a HUGELY successful generic pop album with an even more generic but still successful pop album isn’t impressive and a hit tweet calling your fave boring isn’t a hate train either, time to come up with something other than 24/7 self-victimization  

[Goaty]

1 hour ago, Safe&Sound said:

2 albums started with r letter

 

[Sheep]

16 minutes ago, ugo said:

She just rehashed old sounds 

Beyonce went nearly 10 years without a big domestic hit, longer if we look for one the size of Cuff It. She also had 2 flop albums in a row before Ren which she's always been an albums artist so it was looking bad for her. She also debuted 25 years before renaissance released. She's also black and a woman in America making mildly politically charged dance music(there are several layers of disadvantage here even without the greater context of her career).

 

She had every chance to drop the ball or not reach her audience with Renaissance and defied all odds by releasing a project so successful and so good it still has stans of the biggest star in the world fuming. That's the unprecedented part. If you don't think that success is special you're just biased against Beyonce.

Edited June 30, 2023 by Century

[Feanor]

...Ready for It? vs I'm That Girl

End Game vs Cozy

I Did Something Bad vs Alien Superstar

Don't Blame Me vs Cuff It

Delicate vs Energy

Look What You Made Me Do vs Break My Soul

...So It Goes vs Church Girl

Gorgeous vs Plastic off The Sofa

Getaway Car vs Virgo's Groove

King of My Heart vs Move

Dancing with Our Hands Tied vs Heated

Dress vs Thique

TIWWCHNT vs All Up In Your Mind

Call It What You Want vs America Has A Problem

New Year's Day vs Summer Renaissance

 

'RENAISSANCE' is better. 'reputation' is (much) bigger.

[Badgalbriel]

11 minutes ago, suneclipse121 said:

The way none of those albums are better than Renaissance  Maybe you should have used I Am Sashs Fierce. You might have an argument there.

Of course they are

[JonginBey]

Reputa is not that girl. All these years later and y’all are still pushing that lie.

[ScorpiosGroove]

3 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

Of course they are

- not

[FolkLover1989]

Imagine thinking Renaissance is bigger than Reputation in any sense

 

Ig time will tell the truth again