rate This Was Pop 2022 | Part 1 | Charli, Rina, Tove & Carly (Winner Revealed!)

[madonnas]

These albums are all pretty good but I tried to be harsher than usual.  Tbh, I’m gonna be upset if lightning is top3 on crash …

[supaspaz]

5 hours ago, madonnas said:

These albums are all pretty good but I tried to be harsher than usual.  Tbh, I’m gonna be upset if lightning is top3 on crash …

"Lightning" is excellent! It is top three on Crash.

[greento]

1 hour ago, ONOPKA said:

let's boot out Send My Love to John first 

 yup

[halcyonday]

1 hour ago, ONOPKA said:

let's boot out Send My Love to John first 

Let's do it

[greento]

we're officially at 30 ballots!! 

 

I'll probably keep this open over the weekend, but the sooner everyone who wants to, sends their scores, the better

 

only tagging those who confirmed they still want to send:

 

 

Spoiler

 @PopA911  @Love Again @cockatoo @gatito @SLIME  @Born to Run @Quicksand @Suilen @PopKills @Crashed

[Solaria]

21 minutes ago, greento said:

we're officially at 30 ballots!! 

 

I'll probably keep this open over the weekend, but the sooner everyone who wants to, sends their scores, the better

 

only tagging those who confirmed they still want to send:

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 @PopA911  @Love Again @cockatoo @gatito @SLIME  @Born to Run @Quicksand @Suilen @PopKills @Crashed

I’m halfway through my list! I’ll send the full one tonight 

[GraceRandolph]

11 hours ago, ONOPKA said:

let's boot out Send My Love to John first 

I think I gave it a 5.  

[Quicksand]

Sent!

[supaspaz]

On 7/19/2023 at 6:37 AM, ONOPKA said:

let's boot out Send My Love to John first 

I hate to say it, but that one is kind of Good, Actually. “Chosen Family” can’t relate.

[halcyonday]

8 hours ago, supaspaz said:

I hate to say it, but that one is kind of Good, Actually. “Chosen Family” can’t relate.

The disrespect. Chosen Family is one of her best songs and John is easily the worst.

[Suilen]

Sorry for the delay, sent! I think all the albums here are decent at least, so I mostly stuck to the upper half of the scale. Even the songs I dragged weren't that bad, just paled in comparison to the rest.

[supaspaz]

7 hours ago, halcyonday said:

The disrespect. Chosen Family is one of her best songs and John is easily the worst.

“Chosen Family” is an abomination. I didn’t realize it had defenders.

[CBC]

Album averages 

7.8

7.0

5.1

9.2

[greento]

Just doing one final reminderrr

 

I'll keep this open over the weekend and close it to submissions on Monday

 

It is still open to everyone so if you can get scores together by Monday, then you are welcome to join 

 

 

Spoiler

the remaining few

@cockatoo @gatito @SLIME @PopKills

 

[cockatoo]

I'm just finishing up my scores for Rina 

[cockatoo]

Submitted 

 

Rina's album truly is terrible, honestly much worse than I remembered. Half Disney songs and half the songs have production so noisy you can barely make out what's going on 

 

Crash and Dirt Femme are mixed bags but have some pretty enjoyable songs.

 

The Loneliest Time is excellent and has aged like fine wine 

[SLIME]

5 hours ago, greento said:

Just doing one final reminderrr

 

I'll keep this open over the weekend and close it to submissions on Monday

 

It is still open to everyone so if you can get scores together by Monday, then you are welcome to join 

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

the remaining few

@cockatoo @gatito @SLIME @PopKills

 

Tysm for extending. I am almost done!

[gatito]

i just sent mine however one of these girls' album was a real chore 

[halcyonday]

the Rina slander is NOT okay. the album is everything to me. 

[greento]

2 minutes ago, halcyonday said:

the Rina slander is NOT okay. the album is everything to me. 

Yeahhh I don’t really get the hate, it’s not bad. It’s cheesy but the songs are interesting enough for it to work most of the time, and it feels like we get a genuine look into Rina’s mind.

[halcyonday]

2 minutes ago, greento said:

Yeahhh I don’t really get the hate, it’s not bad. It’s cheesy but the songs are interesting enough for it to work most of the time, and it feels like we get a genuine look into Rina’s mind.

I feel like the cheesiness is perfect for it combined with the "disney" vibe when the entire album is basically about her looking inside of herself, connecting with her inner child and facing the troubles that has been there with her since she was a kid.  

 

Minor Feelings just always makes me cry.  What an OPENING.

[greento]

10 minutes ago, halcyonday said:

I feel like the cheesiness is perfect for it combined with the "disney" vibe when the entire album is basically about her looking inside of herself, connecting with her inner child and facing the troubles that has been there with her since she was a kid.  

 

Minor Feelings just always makes me cry.  What an OPENING.

This, exactly

[supaspaz]

5 hours ago, greento said:

Yeahhh I don’t really get the hate, it’s not bad. It’s cheesy but the songs are interesting enough for it to work most of the time, and it feels like we get a genuine look into Rina’s mind.

And we didn’t like what we saw!

 

What happened to our “Cyber Stockholm Syndrome” and “Ordinary Superstar” baddie?

[Virgos Groove]

Sent! Wreck sounded a lot better on re-listen, but I still had to sabotage a couple of songs I just KNOW y'all will overrate to the heavens.

 

[halcyonday]

5 hours ago, supaspaz said:

And we didn’t like what we saw!

 

What happened to our “Cyber Stockholm Syndrome” and “Ordinary Superstar” baddie?

She improved I fear