base talk Gaga vs Taylor - more talents? ATRL decides

[Orsay]

Gaga for everything but branding/writing

 

[Escape]

37 minutes ago, Dula Peep said:

Gaga is a much better pop songwriter than Taylor could ever be, she needs Max Martin for that.

Correct me If I'm wrong but Max Martin have not been attached to Taylor's music in quite a while...

[Cheers]

Gaga is more talented. Singing & musical instruments. Both suck @ dancing but Gaga is better. 

[EmailMySwift]

1 hour ago, rihannafan said:

Gaga has more talent. That songwriting one should have a neither option though.

Why are you discounting female songwriters, rihannafan? Taylor wrote Rihanna's last megahit. Written SOLO by Ms Swift 

[rihannafan]

1 hour ago, EmailMySwift said:

Why are you discounting female songwriters, rihannafan? Taylor wrote Rihanna's last megahit. Written SOLO by Ms Swift 

Ok? Thanks for proving my point since the writing on TIWCF isn't great and it's Rihanna's voice + the production that makes it good. When taylor sings it, it's basically unlistenable.

[Marla Singer]

Gaga for all 3.

[Shelter]

Taylor can’t land a lead role so I guess Gaga wins. 

[JayG]

6 hours ago, Klein said:

Inability to release a good album in 12 years : Lady Gaga 

 

 

The delusion lmfaooooooo

[JayG]

GaGa for all 3 and its not even close

[JayG]

3 hours ago, Avariko said:

Correct me If I'm wrong but Max Martin have not been attached to Taylor's music in quite a while...

And it shows...

[GraceRandolph]

Sound of Music was more vocally impressive than any Taylor vocal, Bad Romance is better written than any Taylor song, and Gaga’s acting in ASIB is better than anything Tay has done. Gaga for all. 

[thetea]

i think that gaga has more talent for different things, but taylor is the best at what she's good at it. 

[littlebodybigheart]

10 hours ago, Klein said:

Inability to release a good album in 12 years : Lady Gaga 

 

 

[Relampago.]

Gaga

Taylor

Gaga

 

Very obvious set up from the OP and anyone voting differently is delusional or just trying to go against the obvious ploys from OP

[Escape]

13 hours ago, JayG said:

And it shows...

Taylor Swift is literally bigger and more acclaimed than ever. She's just fine without Max.

[Escape]

13 hours ago, Shelter said:

Taylor can’t land a lead role so I guess Gaga wins. 

Gaga can't drop a good album anymore. Enjoy those lead roles.

[Bimbo]

Taylor’s talent is very… limited  

[JayG]

4 hours ago, Avariko said:

Taylor Swift is literally bigger and more acclaimed than ever. She's just fine without Max.

She would never have got to where she was without him... stop being delusional.

[JayG]

4 hours ago, Bimbo said:

Taylor’s talent is very… limited  

VERY

[Escape]

32 minutes ago, JayG said:

She would never have got to where she was without him... stop being delusional.

If ATRL user JayG says so! 

[bliaz]

Gaga is a better vocalist, but Taylor's tone is more pleasant. Taylor is a better songwriter, Gaga is mediocre in comparison. Gaga is not a bad actress, but she's not good either. She is average. Acting is more of a whim for Taylor. She doesn't need acting to try to be relevant. Music is her forte.

[JayG]

55 minutes ago, Avariko said:

If ATRL user JayG says so! 

Its objective truth... when did she start smashing widely commerically? When Max got involved... Swifties being delusional and denying the truth as always, nothing new. This can be said for other artists too by the way, not just your fav. The Weeknd had a huge following before Max too, but when did he start smashing on pop radio? When Max got invovled. The same happened with your fav. But go off I guess.

Edited June 9, 2023 by JayG

[WildHeart]

On 6/9/2023 at 9:15 PM, JayG said:

when did she start smashing widely commerically?

In 2008 when she got #1 album album of the year 

[dirrtydiana]

Gaga for all

 

bwing a clever songwriter =/= good.

tay may be a good writer but she’s leagues below Mariah, Madonna, janet, shakira, adele. Heck she hasn’t written a song as timeless as bad romance.

Edited June 14, 2023 by dirrtydiana

[EmailMySwift]

4 minutes ago, dirrtydiana said:

Gaga for all

 

bwing a clever songwriter =/= good.

tay may be a good writer but she’s leagues below Mariah, Madonna, janet, shakira, adele. Heck she hasn’t written a song as timeless as bad romance.

Britney stans please stop diminishing songwriting! The pen is mightier than the sword choreo, that's why Taylor is so mighty. Gaga is for the most part a terrible songwriter (she has her moments here and there, I admit it)