Alldeezy Posted June 6, 2023 Posted June 6, 2023 okay i'm back home, I slept once I got back so doing it now
Raphy23 Posted June 6, 2023 Posted June 6, 2023 ugh I think I will have some time to listen+rate when I'm at the gym.
poki Posted June 8, 2023 Author Posted June 8, 2023 I'll (finally) post the results today. Came up with some wacky ideas for the future rounds. 2
poki Posted June 8, 2023 Author Posted June 8, 2023 #11 - Halsey - Without Me (ILLENIUM Remix) by @MusicLoverDude ! SCORE: 4.375 6.75 2 COMMENTS: - Worse than the original which isn't good at all. - love to hear Halsey's best song in this light! Illenium gives me some PTSD when I used to go to raves but the remix is overall cute! #10 - Ace of Base - Waiting for Magic (Total Remix 7" Version) by @khalyan ! SCORE: 4.86 7 6 5 4 2.3 COMMENTS: - This piano motive brings that song to another dimension. It sounds more modern than 90s, surprisingly Good. - I don’t specifically dislike this, but there’s also nothing in particular about it that draws me in. On a subjective level I guess it just isn’t for me but I can see why others would enjoy it. #9 - Say Lou Lou - Julian (The Chainsmokers Remix) by @dejmieeen ! AND SONIKKU - Sweat ft. LIZ (SOPHIE Remix) by @CBC ! SCORE: 5.5 Julian: 6 5 Sweat: 8 3 COMMENTS (Julian): - Generic. - this is cute even if it's rather dated sounding, I might add this to my playlist! COMMENTS (Sweat): - SOPHIE cooked. - I can barely hear the vocals? Like the production isn't balanced well. Love Sophie but her production was always better on her original music IMO #7 - Caroline Polachek - Welcome To My Island (George Daniel & Charli XCX Remix) by @Julia Fox ! SCORE: 5.76 10 9 4 3 2.8 COMMENTS: - I am not into this hyper-pop stuff, but at least it wasn’t that bad - i don't like this one sadly - Yeah this is a 10. She took the original and totally reworked it and made it her own. A real transformation and bop. #6 - Sylver - Turn The Tide (CJ Stone Remix) by @Technicolor ! SCORE: 5.82 7.5 7 6.5 5 3.1 COMMENTS: - When a song sounds like this it brings me some childhood memories, when Eurodance was IT GIRL. - Miss the late 90s early 00s sound - this is fine but I felt like it didn’t really go anywhere? #5 - Sabrina Carpenter - Almost Love (Stargate Warehouse Mix) by @Allday ! SCORE: 6 6.5 5.5 COMMENTS: - Kinda generic. Didn't blow my mind. - it's inoffensive but it doesn't really go anyway, if it came on the radio I probably wouldn't turn the station but I wouldn't actively seek it out #4 - Mr. Brightside (Jacques Lu Cont's Thin White Duke Radio Remix) by @prézli ! SCORE: 6.68 10 9 6 5 3.5 COMMENTS: - Okay, this is Good. I was afraid at first, but this is Good. - the original is such a signature song that remixing it makes it sound kinda odd. It’s kinda like those adele remixes that turn her ballads into dance songs, it just sounds a bit bizarre and doesn’t totally fit no matter how well it’s remixed. That said I think this is okay but still a bit uncanny. - this is one of my favourite songs of all time and this remix actually didn't ruin it so im impressed #3 - La Roux - Bulletproof (Tiborg Remix) by @Raphy23 ! SCORE: 7.12 9 7.7 7.5 7.4 4 COMMENTS: - I prefer this version more than original, it was played in my country as radio version. More Euphoric and catchy. - fantastic song, great remix. I don’t know if I would necessarily listen to this over the original, though. #2 - Starley - Call On Me (Ryan Riback Remix) by @fiercE ! SCORE: 7.25 8.5 6 COMMENT: - retail workers are QUAKING Congratulations to @fountain ! #1 - Whitney Houston - It's Not Right But It's Okay (Thunderpuss Remix) SCORE: 9.5 10 9 COMMENTS: - Heard this before. SLAY. Love the chorus. - It's Not Right But It's Okay - a perfect remix for Pride month! -------------------------------------------------------- Welp, this is quite a turn of events. While Head Radio has seen 5/6 scores sent, Lips 106 has seen 2/5. I'll try to see if I can get more members to join us or else I will have to do only 1 radio station for round 3 1
fiercE Posted June 9, 2023 Posted June 9, 2023 Got 2nd because only 2 persons ranked my song . You should start penalizing those who don't send their rating.
fountain Posted June 9, 2023 Posted June 9, 2023 OOP thank you for the #1 (even if it’s not from two scores )
ATRL Moderator khalyan Posted June 9, 2023 ATRL Moderator Posted June 9, 2023 Not the demand to join only for members to not submit scores. This game is literally so chill, why join if you can’t dedicate 10 minutes to listen to a handful of songs?
Alldeezy Posted June 9, 2023 Posted June 9, 2023 Top 5 not bad, it's a remix I always seem to go back to. hope you can get more people to join, however I don't mind If i have to listen to more songs
Alldeezy Posted June 9, 2023 Posted June 9, 2023 was almost going to send this! still my favourite remix of all time, but I feel everyone would get annoyed at the BELEVEEE BELIEVEEE BELIEEVE x210
dejmieeen Posted June 10, 2023 Posted June 10, 2023 (edited) I am sorry, but this is a mess. First of all, are you serious guys? Why do you declare to participate, if you have a problem with listening and rating 5 ***** songs? Secondly - When it comes to organisation, I think there’s no idea, how should it look like. The rules were changed during the game, I feel confused. I am sorry sweeties, but I give up. Maybe next time I would make it - This time get me outta here, please Edited June 10, 2023 by dejmieeen
fountain Posted June 10, 2023 Posted June 10, 2023 People not participating is definitely on them solely and not on the host. This is a phenomenon not exclusive to this game but to the sub forum in general. I don’t know why people go into the games section, join a game, and then proceed to not take part in said game, but yes it is annoying… and so is quitting. It seems a bit nonsensical to want and expect a game to be run smoothly but then to not support the game by posting and engaging in the thread and fully participating. The truth is the games section needs more promotion in general if it strives to be active and lively and that unfortunately isn’t reliant on the hosts who already put countless hours upon hours into these games voluntarily on their own behalf… we definitely don’t like it either but if you want it to work then you have to support, not drop out. As for the changes made to the game we were asked about those in the thread and we made our suggestions at the time and agreed that a change would be beneficial. It was a nice thing for the host to do in accommodating everybody who wanted to play and was definitely a good change. This is only the first iteration of this game so of course things will be figured out and altered along the way, that’s normal and good adaptable hosting. Poki has done a great job so far and has already put forward a solution here by combining the two radio stations, so I don’t really see what the issue is or the need to quit when that has already been resolved. Looking forward to the next round! 1
prézli Posted June 10, 2023 Posted June 10, 2023 34 minutes ago, fountain said: People not participating is definitely on them solely and not on the host. True, but disagreed at the same time. The host should remind them to send.
poki Posted June 11, 2023 Author Posted June 11, 2023 Okay, I will do more @s for the upcoming rounds Will post R3 tomorrow in about 10 hours, it's too hard on mobile to do it. If we can have 10 entries, I think we can keep the 2 radio stations. 1
poki Posted June 11, 2023 Author Posted June 11, 2023 Round 3 - Non 90's Disney (However, 90's Pixar is okay) Hi everyone, for this round we will do Disney + their abandoned pet Pixar! I feel that the obvious choice would be to send 90's bops so I've set a few restrictions: 1. No 90's! 2. No The Little Mermaid (since it is also part of the Renaissance) 3. No live action HOWEVER: Pixar is allowed, including their 90's movies. Deadline is 48 hours from now! I will do more notices of it as requested. will also do nice visuals I couldn't do them for round 2. And I have to update the op. And try to find more members to join. Whew, busy busy busy! @prézli @Technicolor @khalyan @Julia Fox @Raphy23 @MusicLoverDude @CBC @fountain @fiercE @Allday 1
poki Posted June 11, 2023 Author Posted June 11, 2023 When I sent Part of Your World in ATRL 2017 Song Contest I was eliminated
ATRL Moderator khalyan Posted June 11, 2023 ATRL Moderator Posted June 11, 2023 Sent! Hope my song is eligible
Recommended Posts