base talk Post your unpopular pop opinion - will it survive ATRL's new like/dislike feature?

[Specter]

Post ONE of your most controversial or unpopular opinions (per post) related to any of the pop girlies.

 

If people agree with it, they will give it a thumbs up/like. If they don't, your posts may be in for a panning.

 

Might also tell us how many 'unpopular' opinions people actually agree with in general

 

Go  For fun, I'll update OP with the most liked and disliked posts.

Edited May 18, 2023 by Phantom

[ImsoLOUD]

[Katamari]

Lykke Li queen of pop

 

Period! 

[Phaunzie]

No, because my opinions seem to cause many to seethe in anguish or tremble in delight. 

 

But you know what, let's be messy

• Janet is a better performer than both Taylor and Beyonce.
• Katy will always be an a-lister regardless of if she flops obscurity.
• Obsessing over Matt Healy, does nothing and causes nothing, move on. In the words of Talk Talk, it's her life don't you forgot. 
• Pop music is not dead just because the mainstream is not what you like
• Just because Ayesha Erotica is trans does not mean she can use the n-word. (Girl her fanbase is so dense

Somehow my most controversial

Spoiler

Despite the lies of the Britney Army and a small amount of the Lambilily (Most are lovely members), Xtina has impacted pop culture in a much larger way than their deluded stan war obsessions can handle. I mean she is the Voice of the Generation and brought social issues to the forefront in the Y2K era like a true artist would by the word of Nina Simone. 

 

Edited May 18, 2023 by Phaunzie

[Josh]

@Jeremiahwhy the groan?

[Specter]

Y'all are some scared and boring ass people 

 

I'll start us off: Melanie Martinez should not be allowed to have a pop career. Tired schtick, horrific allegations surrounding her (let alone her best friend), very little overall talent, and just overall an unpleasant artist/musician. Has barely any good songs.

[GraceRandolph]

Dance in the Dark’s bridge washed Vogue. Vogue in general is overrated af. 

[Selegend]

Selena Gomez overall career success is understimated by ATRL and stan twitter.

She's more successful than what it looks like by the way ATRL and stan twitter talk about her. 

[GraceRandolph]

Taylor Swift, Katy Perry, and Britney Spears have more dated songs in their discographies than Gaga does. 

[magazine]

No, they can't handle the truth 

[shookspeare]

lady gaga is a bad actress 

[Josh]

3 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

Dance in the Dark’s bridge washed Vogue. Vogue in general is overrated af. 

Vogue is dated and boring possibly Madonna's worst single

[TalkThatRihanna]

Emotion & Melodrama are extremely overrated albums

[GraceRandolph]

Carly Rae Jepsen is the real heir to Madonna’s QOP title. 

[GraceRandolph]

Lorde has no good albums. 

[idontdodrags]

Selena Gomez is a social climber

[Specter]

zsxhjkdfjhsgaz @GraceRandolph 

[Selegend]

Xtina so-called "classic songs" aren't really classics. 

[GraceRandolph]

Stupid Love is a decent lead single. 

[TalkThatRihanna]

Jack Antanoff’s productions are some of the worst things to happen to the girls

[Guest]

Opinions:

 

Cardi was never supposed to make it far in the industry. Labels and the music industry needed someone to tear Nicki down and erase her legacy, and they already tried it with multiple female rappers but never succeeded. Cardi was their last big attempt to accomplish their plan of completely destroying Nicki’s legacy. They thought that they had found the perfect person to end Nicki when Bodak Yellow went #1, but Cardi’s career was not going anywhere after that, and so that’s when Atlantic decided to fake a tweet about Nicki liking a tweet bout Cardi’s parenting in order to paint Nicki as the bad guy.

It was 2018 and Nicki hate train was strong. Atlantic knew people would believe the fake tweet because they were the ones who orchestrated Nicki's hate train back in 2018 and they knew the GP would side with Cardi and Nicki’s career would fall into oblivion.

Cardi’s career was pushed not to become a big artist. It was pushed by labels and the industry to destroy Nicki’s legacy.

 

-------------------------

 

Gaga and Nicki didn’t have the best relationship because they were constantly being compared. I believe Gaga felt threatened when Nicki gave us songs like ‘Super Bass’ and ‘Starships’ which were mega hits. Keep in mind this was back when Gaga was at her peak, so Gaga felt a bit jealous that Nicki was doing great pop records and overshadowing Gaga’s dominance back during her peak. Nicki was eating her up in the fashion department, and when she started doing pop in 2012/2013 she stole Gaga's shine and I feel that's why they didn't have the best relationship. But, it seems like they’re in good terms now, so it’s all good.

 

 

Edited May 18, 2023 by Cool

[Both Sides Now]

Born To Die deserved its mixed response and a lot of the lyrics are Melanie Martinez level of cringe.

 

Lana only became a consistent songwriter with Honeymoon.

 

Blue Banisters is better than BTD. 

[ccfan007]

Camila Cabello is more talented than ATRL wants to admit.

[Laura Palmer]

The hatefulness 

[GraceRandolph]

Adele is a conwoman.