base talk Gaga/Taylor/Katy: Most to Least Classics?

[Aren]

All three pop girls debuted around the same time. But which pop girl has the most number of classics that are known by all walks of life? Meaning it excludes local classics, we’re talking about global classics.

 

[besaid]

Gaga > Taylor >>>>>> Katy

 

Edited March 22, 2023 by besaid

[vuelve88]

Taylor > Katy > Gaga. 
 

This is the only correct answer.  

[Axelios]

Taylor > Katy > Gaga

[Devin]

KATY PERRY

1. I Kissed A Girl

2. Hot N Cold

3. California Gurls

4. Teenage Dream

5. Firework

6. E.T.

7. Roar (meh)

8. Dark Horse

 

LADY GAGA

1. Just Dance

2. Poker Face 

3. Bad Romance

4. Born This Way

5. Shallow

6. ARUTW (pending)
 

TAYLOR SWIFT 

1. Love Story

2. You Belong With Me

3. We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

4. Shake It Off

5. Blank Space

6. cardigan (pending) 

[Jjang]

Taylor > Katy > Gaga

[Mordecai]

All of you people saying Taylor, please be serious.

 

Katy > Gaga > Taylor

[k4rmabutterfly]

Real classics:

 

Katy - IKAG, Firework, Dark Horse

Gaga - Just Dance, Poker Face, Bad Romance

Taylor - Love Story, YBWM, Blank Space

I fear it’s a tie. Katy has the most hits but Gaga has a classic in the making (Shallow) so she wins.

[byzantium]

37 minutes ago, vuelve88 said:

Taylor > Katy > Gaga. 
 

This is the only correct answer.  

This

[Big Bad Wolf]

How can people say Taylor? I don't think her hits are bigger or more recognizable than Katy's. Katy >> Taylor >>>> Gaga

[Proseductice]

Katy > Gaga > Taylor

 

edit: the poll 

Edited March 23, 2023 by Proseductice

[littlebodybigheart]

taylor > katy > gaga

[manuelalex9810]

Katy >> Taylor > GaGa 

 

[Cheers]

I feel like the three of them are tied in terms of their personal "classics" tbh

[shyboi]

Taylor > Katy > Guga

[VOSS]

Taylor has a lot of fan favorites that are generally well known but are they classics? Idk

They seem about equal to me

[Danny789]

I voted T>K>G

 

but now that I think about it, it’s probably K>G>T

[Dystopian]

I think Taylor and Katy are tied

T: You Belong With Me, WANEGBT, IKYWT, Shake It Off, Blank Space
K: I Kissed a Girl, Hot N Cold, Firework, Roar, Dark Horse
G: Just Dance, Poker Face, Bad Romance, Shallow

[DoubleRainbow!]

The only right answer is

Katy > Gaga > Taylor

[UseYourIllusion2002]

well Katy has all the Teenage Dream singles plus two from Prism and her debut, so she has the most IMO. Taylor is definitely catching up. 
Katy>Tay>>>Gaga.

[BGKC]

8 minutes ago, DoubleRainbow! said:

The only right answer is

Katy > Gaga > Taylor

This

[naval23]

Global classics? Gaga > Katy >>>>> Tay easily

 

Gaga: PF, BR, Shallow = holy trinity of global classics 
Katy: IKAG, Hot N Cold, Dark Horse
Taylor: Shake It Off...Blank Space...I Knew You Were Trouble?
 

[Sazare]

Gaga has probably 3 classics, Katy has 2-ish, and taylor has 0. So.

 

People keep saying I Kissed a Girl is a classic when it’s really more of a meme than an actually replayed or beloved hit. “I [x]ed a [y] and I liked it.” is about where that song’s enduring appeal begins and ends.

[Sazare]

1 hour ago, Proseductice said:

edit: the poll 

The way the two most popular answers are direct inverses of one another 

[LiamVillain]

2 hours ago, Devin said:

KATY PERRY

1. I Kissed A Girl

2. Hot N Cold

3. California Gurls

4. Teenage Dream

5. Firework

6. E.T.

7. Roar 

8. Dark Horse

9. The One That Got Away

=> 5

 

LADY GAGA

1. Just Dance

2. Poker Face 

3. Bad Romance

4. Born This Way

5. Shallow

6. ARUTW (pending)
=> 4

 

TAYLOR SWIFT 

1. Love Story

2. You Belong With Me

3. We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

4. Shake It Off

5. Blank Space

6. cardigan (pending) 

7. I Knew You Were Trouble

=> 5