Jump to content

Diversity 5: Let's Celebrate! | Winner revealed (pg.154)


thecptz

Recommended Posts

Belated critiques from last round since last round went much quicker than I anticipated! :bird:
 

Björk - Hidden Place (from Vespertine)

Do I like it? Okay, this song is my vibe. Kind of like Digital Daggers but not??? Feeling it.

 

Christina Aguilera - Still Dirrty (from Back to Basics)

Do I like it? I like it! Though I wish the instrumental was a little lower compared to her voice.

 

Demi Lovato - Every Time You Lie (from Here We Go Again)

Do I like it? It’s kind of like Natasha Bedingfield. I’m not a huge fan.

 

Miley Cyrus - WTF Do I Know (from Plastic Hearts)

Do I like it? This was enjoyable!

 

Solange - Don't You Wait (from A Seat at the Table)

Do I like it? It’s okay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 3.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • thecptz

    1168

  • Ttoki

    303

  • Dessy

    198

  • Not Like The Movies

    198

NPrewYs.png

CRITIQUES

ROUND 13

 

Spoiler
On 4/10/2023 at 10:35 AM, Sanguine said:

ROUND THIRTEEN CRITIQUES
 

Björk - Hidden Place (from Vespertine): So intricate and gorgeous. One of her very best! Definitely the entry here that really “brought it” the most so kudos for that

Christina Aguilera - Still Dirrty (from Back to Basics): The instrumental to this sounds like you left your car running at the circus and everything else is all over the place so I am just… not a fan at all

Demi Lovato - Every Time You Lie (from Here We Go Again): Such a bop! Jazz Pop queen, ate this man up at only sixteen

Miley Cyrus - WTF Do I Know (from Plastic Hearts): Haven’t listened to this one in a while, it’s different and more punky than I remembered? Pretty good, but hoped it would hit harder

Solange - Don't You Wait (from A Seat at the Table): One of my faves on ASATT!! True EP vibes. The production is so punchy and I love the pre-/chorus melody and harmonies 

 

@CBC @Auburn @Noah @wish @Not Like The Movies

 

On 4/10/2023 at 11:16 AM, Tom Vercetti said:

 

2AopB7c.png

 

Björk - Hidden Place (from Vespertine): The only classic song here. You will be rewarded for this. 

 

Christina Aguilera - Still Dirrty (from Back to Basics): A bit disappointing. Like where are the hits? This is not even close as good as its prequel i'm afraid.

 

Demi Lovato - Every Time You Lie (from Here We Go Again): Similar to Xtina, I feel there were stronger opportunities available. This just sounds like random filler to me and not as appealing as Got Dynamite from this same album. 

 

Miley Cyrus - WTF Do I Know (from Plastic Hearts): It's okay. Not really into how shouty she sounds with her current voice. Song does get better as it goes on so there's that. 

 

Solange - Don't You Wait (from A Seat at the Table): It's good enough. Not amazing but it has interesting enough production to stand out compared to some of her competition. 

 

@CBC @Auburn @Noah @wish @Not Like The Movies

 

On 4/10/2023 at 11:38 AM, Hikari said:

h』『i』『k』『a』『r』『i』 『h』『a』『s』 『s』『h』『*』『t』 『t』『o』 『s』『a』『y』

@CBC @Auburn @Noah @wish @Not Like The Movies

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Björk - Hidden Place (from Vespertine)

The song's melody is like a combination of uplifting and melancholic tunes that create a mysterious and almost dreamlike atmosphere. We live for the top-notch production of the song. 

 

Christina Aguilera - Still Dirrty (from Back to Basics)

I guess they were trying to do a more polished and refined version of Dirrty. The sultry/seductive tone of the song is still there but the song lacks the punch that the former song had. 

 

Demi Lovato - Every Time You Lie (from Here We Go Again)

I love how the song started with a somber piano melody but it got lighter as the song progressed. There were some cute moments but there were also some meh moments.

 

Miley Cyrus - WTF Do I Know (from Plastic Hearts)

The song was very energetic and very confident. Her vocals were strong and assertive enough to match the song's playful tone. I like this now more than I remembered.

 

Solange - Don't You Wait (from A Seat at the Table)

The beats were very hypnotic, the gradual build-up really drawing me in more to the song. Is it better than Cranes? Maybe not, but I still enjoyed the song regardless.

 

On 4/10/2023 at 11:44 AM, Element said:

giphy.gif

ELEMENT'S CRITIQUES
 

Björk - Hidden Place (from Vespertine)

Wow, this is stunning!! It feels like such a raw and tribal journey. I want to watch the movie of this song.

 

Christina Aguilera - Still Dirrty (from Back to Basics)

I definitely am surprised to not see Hurt here tbh. I also feel like some of Lotus could have done well for me personally but it's been awhile since I've listened. The intro definitely. Still Dirrty is a bit fun at times, but it doesn't stick with me. I wish that there was some more variation in the bridge or final chorus.

 

Demi Lovato - Every Time You Lie (from Here We Go Again)

I'm extremely perplexed by this choice. This is not an entry for the final 5 imo... maybe it would have done okay early on. I am also an Unbroken truther and would have LOVED to see All Night Long, Unbroken, Fix a Heart, Skyscaper, In Real Life, FTLOAD... like this is cute but pretty corny idk

 

Miley Cyrus - WTF Do I Know (from Plastic Hearts)

Smash!! A good choice from a great album. Surprised it wasn't Gimme, but I'll take this.

 

Solange - Don't You Wait (from A Seat at the Table)

This was really nice! I liked the layered production. Beautiful delivery as well.

 

@CBC @Auburn @Noah @wish @Not Like The Movies

8 hours ago, Euterpe said:

Belated critiques from last round since last round went much quicker than I anticipated! :bird:
 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Björk - Hidden Place (from Vespertine)

Do I like it? Okay, this song is my vibe. Kind of like Digital Daggers but not??? Feeling it.

 

Christina Aguilera - Still Dirrty (from Back to Basics)

Do I like it? I like it! Though I wish the instrumental was a little lower compared to her voice.

 

Demi Lovato - Every Time You Lie (from Here We Go Again)

Do I like it? It’s kind of like Natasha Bedingfield. I’m not a huge fan.

 

Miley Cyrus - WTF Do I Know (from Plastic Hearts)

Do I like it? This was enjoyable!

 

Solange - Don't You Wait (from A Seat at the Table)

Do I like it? It’s okay

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 NPrewYs.png 

RESULTS

 

Spoiler
On 4/11/2023 at 10:21 AM, thecptz said:

NPrewYs.png

in 2nd place...

with the average of 9.2

.

.

.

.

.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Solange with Don't You Wait from A Seat at the Table!

@Not Like The Movies

 

 

congrats!!!

On 4/11/2023 at 10:24 AM, thecptz said:

NPrewYs.png

in 1st place...

with the average of 9.9

.

.

.

.

.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Björk with Hidden Place from Vespertine!

@CBC

 

 

after being near the bottoms a lot, finally its your time, congrats!!!

On 4/11/2023 at 10:29 AM, thecptz said:

NPrewYs.png

in 5th place...and SINGING OFF

with the average of 7.9

.

.

.

.

.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Christina Aguilera with Still Dirrty from Back To Basics!

@Auburn

 

 

good luck in your first sing-off :emofish:

 

On 4/11/2023 at 10:34 AM, thecptz said:

 

 NPrewYs.png

in 4th place...and SINGING OFF

with the average of 8.06

.

.

.

.

.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Demi Lovato with Every Time You Lie from Here We Go Again!

@Noah

 

good luck in your third sing-off :emofish:

in 3rd place...and SAFE

with the average of 8.84

.

.

.

.

.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Miley Cyrus with WTF Do I Know from Plastic Hearts!

@wish

 

 

congrats!! from wild card to the semi-finalist, yup!

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NPrewYs.png

SING-OFF ENTRIES

 

welcome to our thirteenth sing-off and this is our LAST sing-off of the season! no more singing-off, yay.

ofc we're gonna finish off with the loudest sing-off ever! christina aguilera or demi lovato who will win...

who will take that last spot in the semi-final??????

 

#ButFirst, let's see what they performed

(since both of the performances are not on YT, im not gonna bother post a YT link giggles)

 

first to the stage, it's Christina Aguilera with a performance of Ain't No Other Man!

and finishing it off with Demi Lovato who performed Cool For The Summer!

SO TRUE! we stan the research :clap3:

who's gonna stay??? leave ur guess down below!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 NPrewYs.png

SING-OFF RESULTS

 

first off to the judges table again, it's her, miss Ally Brooke!

jD33T3G.png

here's what she had to say:

Quote

-

SHE DRAGGED YALL SO HARD!!! jk she said nothing

but she did say who she wanted to vote for and it's.....

Christina Aguilera!

 

next up please welcome to the stage, judge Lexie Liu!

igAkZZE.png

here's what she had to say:

Quote

-

AGAIN? welp, at least it's better than not giving us our vote...

she ended up picking one person and that is....

Christina Aguilera!

 

that makes it 2-0 with christina leading... gasps!

 

walking in, it's miss just-release-a-least-personal-album Ellie Goulding!

OUp3m9e.png

here's what she had to say:

Quote

- Christina: Excellent display of her vocal prowess! The other accoutrements of the performance were engaging and entertaining too.

 

- Demi: I really loved the staging, colors, and energy of this performance! She commanded things like the song deserved, with strong vocals to match. This brought me a lot of nostalgia for summers gone by!

a praise, a praise all around :eek:  so yea i feel like both of u gave a great performance!!!

but anyways, it's not about ME, its about miss ellie goulding

and the person she saved is..... Demi Lovato!

 

2-1.. with Sean Paul and Caroline Polachek left, ooooh what's gonna happen?

hope you guys are SEATED #SeatedGame

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

just watched Demi's performance :jonnycat:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 NPrewYs.png

SING-OFF RESULTS

 

WELCOME BACK :hug: i know yall are so ready to know who will make it to the semi-final

i mean I AM TOO even though i know already, gasps... to recap, christina leading w 2-1

two more judges left.

 

we're gonna start with, judge Sean Paul!

QcWpL1m.png

here's what he had to say:

Quote

Idk

Even for me

OH WOW..... so yes he did choose based on his small preference on staging/presence

but i will keep that hush hush for now, giggles

 

let's hear it from her, miss Caroline Polachek!

RHZIIxk.png

here's what she had to say:

Quote

I really liked both

Christina: This was super dynamic and her vocals were on point the whole time

Demi: Throughout this game I’ve been skeptical of performances to crowds as noisy as this one so I was really impressed by her still demanding so much attention with her stage presence (edited)

oh queen of (edited), so TRUE.

bbz: caroline, it's time to vote.

caroline: no, idk gimme a minute.

 

GASPS okay that is fine

 

caroline: i'm ready now.

 

that's right...

 

 

 

 

 

the act going through to the semi final and one step closer to the finale is....

.

.

 

 

 

 

Spoiler

Christina Aguilera

@Auburn

 

congrats!!! with the vote of 4-1, you're one of our semi-finalists!

Spoiler

which means i'm sorry, Demi Lovato.. your time in Diversity 5 is up.

thank you so much for applying :hug: YOU DID SO WELL.

like literally from the audition, i didn't expect you to make it this far. no shades giggles. i like demi lovato!!

you showcased them very well and you should be proud of how you played in this season

winning TWO sing-offs, thats our sing-off assassin whoaaaaaa... i hope u had fun

 

love you! hope to see you again next season :heart2:

Round 14 (semi-final) will be posted in the morning :heart2:

please say your goodbye to our eliminated act.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks y'all :jonnycat:

 

I love you @Noah and happy Demi made it to the top 5 because she's too underrated here :crown: :heart:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But yessss Xtina ate and so did Demi, should’ve been a double shantay  or whatever that term is!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

congrats Xtina, sorry to see you go Demi!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1444

Link to comment
Share on other sites

144p

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hello

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i

Link to comment
Share on other sites

wow

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.