Miley Cyrus Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 the way yall want a deluxe album when yall gave up on the album 3 days after its release just call it a day and move on to the next era
Bindi Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 19 hours ago, ariesgroove said: you're questioning the science, cause you don't understand how i'm doing what i'm doing in a f*cking handstand you found it so impressive that i do it again my other one is busy, so i use my left hand we took it kinda fast but you put it in slow i see your mother's calling and you're hitting ignore it's like you saw a unicorn, you don't understand how i'm doin' what i'm doin' in a f*cking handstand A moment
zasderfght Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 6 hours ago, josesuxx said: He found the album very safe, 4/10. Kinda funny that his favourite songs are You and Wonder Woman which are the least liked by fans. That's the exact score I gave it before Fantano reviewed it! Someone can quote me, but I said I'd give it a C- which equates to a 4/10. He liked Handstand but didn't care for the intro. I love the intro but whatever. Also, put me in the camp that found You and Wonder Woman to be snoozefests, but ballads can go either way for Fantano, so I can't say I'm THAT shocked he liked those tracks. I'm glad I'm not the only one who dislikes River. It's just too busy and dated. Great that the Smilers like it, but if they want a pop-bop, Party in the USA is leagues better.
CottageHore Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 (edited) 58 minutes ago, zasderfght said: That's the exact score I gave it before Fantano reviewed it! Someone can quote me, but I said I'd give it a C- which equates to a 4/10. He liked Handstand but didn't care for the intro. I love the intro but whatever. Also, put me in the camp that found You and Wonder Woman to be snoozefests, but ballads can go either way for Fantano, so I can't say I'm THAT shocked he liked those tracks. I'm glad I'm not the only one who dislikes River. It's just too busy and dated. Great that the Smilers like it, but if they want a pop-bop, Party in the USA is leagues better. A 40% is inarguably a D or an F on any grading scales lol. C- would be a 6/10 Fun fact: Fantano’s track record does not warrant anybody giving a **** about his opinion Edited March 16, 2023 by CottageHore
shark_heather Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 Backyard Sessions did wonders at least for me ... Island and Rose Colored Lenses are on repeat the last few days Jaded and Thousand Miles being up there River remains the ultimate gay banger You and Muddy Feet are great tracks Violet Chemistry aged not so well for me . Wonder Woman is the only skip . Wildcard is ok
Scars Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 The album was relesead less than a week ago but the era already feels so dead. Not releasing one more single before the album release was a mistake, they picked the wrong song for the second single and we're completely in the dark about her future move or if there'll even be one. I know some girls will be upset with my impatient self for saying this, but ugh I miss Plastic Hearts era so bad. We didn't have Billboard by our side, but we were fed with all the content and promo.
zasderfght Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 (edited) 2 hours ago, CottageHore said: A 40% is inarguably a D or an F on any grading scales lol. C- would be a 6/10 Fun fact: Fantano’s track record does not warrant anybody giving a **** about his opinion On an American grading system for academic work, sure, a C would be a 70-79. And a C- would look closer to anything above 65 and less than 70. A C and a 5/10 to me are both AVERAGE. A C- and a 4/10 are both BELOW average. To me, a grading scale for music/films is vastly different than a grading scale for academic work. If I didn't use a C-, I would've said 4/10 or a 2/5. I thought the album was below average. To me, a C is average. A C- would then mean below average. And, yes, I am well aware that Fantano will most likely never meet me, and even if he did, he is his own person, with his own intimate circle of friends that I will never be a part of. And that is totally fine. I've disagreed with Fantano before-- hell, I even think You and Wonder Woman are not the best tracks on ESV, but you can agree with a music critic that shares your opinion. That doesn't discredit your opinion. Edited March 16, 2023 by zasderfght
Diet Pepsi Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 miss Miley where is the tour announcement? This “era” (if you could even call it that) is so uneventful
FlyOnTheWall Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 I like the album but this is her worst era yet apart from the cute lil numbers Flowers pulled and the nice visuals. What a snoozefest. How's your album called Endless Summer Vacation but its camapaign lacks any excitement or fun? A mess and a half.
FlyOnTheWall Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 44 minutes ago, zasderfght said: And, yes, I am well aware that Fantano will most likely never meet me, and even if he did, he is his own person, with his own intimate circle of friends that I will never be a part of. And that is totally fine. why does this sound so melodramatic Anyway, who cares about melonhead's opinion. Dead Petz and SIC were too edgy, ESV is not edgy enough yaddayadda, same with pitchfork, she just can't do right to them simply based on a weird personal bias they have against her. Not that it matters but ARTV gave the album a 4/5 so there's that
zasderfght Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 2 hours ago, FlyOnTheWall said: why does this sound so melodramatic Anyway, who cares about melonhead's opinion. Dead Petz and SIC were too edgy, ESV is not edgy enough yaddayadda, same with pitchfork, she just can't do right to them simply based on a weird personal bias they have against her. Not that it matters but ARTV gave the album a 4/5 so there's that I mean, I care about Anthony Fantano's opinion for the same reason people follow certain music/film critics. They typically share opinions of these critics, so if there's a new album coming out a critic they respect praises, they're more likely to check it out. I actually found a lot of great artists like Death Grips and Black Dresses because of Anthony Fantano. I'm sure there's people that need to share Anthony's opinion on everything, but it's great to also discover new music.
Jukebox Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 Rose Colored Lenses could easily blow up on Tik Tok, it has that Bad Habit/Meet Me At Our Spot vibe. That and Jaded should be massive hits, absolute anthems.
Miley Cyrus Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 Dw guys the album will have a resurgence in the summer
biomind101 Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 37 minutes ago, Jukebox said: Rose Colored Lenses could easily blow up on Tik Tok, it has that Bad Habit/Meet Me At Our Spot vibe. That and Jaded should be massive hits, absolute anthems. Agreed
CottageHore Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 3 hours ago, zasderfght said: On an American grading system for academic work, sure, a C would be a 70-79. And a C- would look closer to anything above 65 and less than 70. A C and a 5/10 to me are both AVERAGE. A C- and a 4/10 are both BELOW average. To me, a grading scale for music/films is vastly different than a grading scale for academic work. If I didn't use a C-, I would've said 4/10 or a 2/5. I thought the album was below average. To me, a C is average. A C- would then mean below average. And, yes, I am well aware that Fantano will most likely never meet me, and even if he did, he is his own person, with his own intimate circle of friends that I will never be a part of. And that is totally fine. I've disagreed with Fantano before-- hell, I even think You and Wonder Woman are not the best tracks on ESV, but you can agree with a music critic that shares your opinion. That doesn't discredit your opinion. I never said you can’t agree with him. The latter of my comment was speaking generally to the thread, not you. I don’t care
FlyOnTheWall Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 the absolute lack of content or effort from her and columbia this era is starting to quickly dampen my enjoyment of the album Like her songs just LIVE from live performances and the energy she and her band give them (as proven by the BYS)... But yeah now that the first hype has settled, I'm comfortable ranking this somewhere in the upper middle of her discography after Bangerz, PH and Dead Petz
Cappe2001 Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 hate this era, boring, 0 contents. The album is good btw, not the best she can do but it’s good. i hope she will release more music during the year
leightxn Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 Watching the Disney backyard sessions made the songs that I was unsure of click tbh. Island is so so good
CottageHore Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 I can’t believe she’s done nothing since the album dropped not even a radio interview or a Q&A or something. Sure she got her first #1 in awhile but aside from the playlisting Columbia gave her for Flowers, wtf are they and she doing? So boring!
Ivan_brit Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 Yeah I agree with all of you what a way to kind of kill an era with no Promo Watch her release a deluxe with 3-4 new songs but doing it with an uneventful way something similar to Positions deluxe Keep the Deluxe is she will not even bother to do anything for it Forget about Tour... is not happening The way we all want so bad promo even her Backyard performances doing numbers 2.7 Million views 2.2 Million views Both performances are trending at my country! Also Jaded surpass 1 Million at YouTube
Walk_Away21 Posted March 16, 2023 Posted March 16, 2023 1 hour ago, shark_heather said: WHERE IS THE TOUR ANNOUNCEMENT !!!!
Recommended Posts