Adama Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 1 minute ago, Take Me Apart said: that's starship money Yeah sure, they also paid paid YouTube SK, circle and the others streaming app
SandyJeans Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 ya'll can keep the Melon ULs who tf cares NewLegends about to have a #1 album on the Billboard 200 & 4 tracks charting simultaneously on the Hot 100 4 2
Adama Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 4 minutes ago, SandyJeans said: ya'll can keep the Melon ULs who tf cares NewLegends about to have a #1 album on the Billboard 200 & 4 tracks charting simultaneously on the Hot 100 Good for them! But no needs to pretend that IVE numbers are fake either 1
Dialamba Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 34 minutes ago, Epi.oxy. said: ditto got the same point same week. i am only got higher because of playtlisting the first few weeks It’s melon not Spotify. Stop playing dense
Epi.oxy. Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 27 minutes ago, Adama said: No one said that But saying that IVE got big uls just because of the 24charts is def not true. And Same for G idle. i am got big uls because of 24h chart, otherwise it would chart the same as ditto. love dive got high uls because it was a hit.
SandyJeans Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 6 minutes ago, Adama said: Good for them! But no needs to pretend that IVE numbers are fake either I never said IVE numbers were fake what I can say is that Melon is a dying platform that keeps losing users to YouTube Music I could also say that it's suspicious that Melon's New Releases TTH-like chart suddenly vanished right before NJ's comeback
Adama Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 (edited) 9 minutes ago, Epi.oxy. said: i am got big uls because of 24h chart, otherwise it would chart the same as ditto. love dive got high uls because it was a hit. This chart don’t have a big impact on big acts like IVE and G idle. They get big uls with or without the 24h hits playlist. It would have been the same for Super shy. SS uls were impacted bc of the time release 9 minutes ago, SandyJeans said: I never said IVE numbers were fake what I can say is that Melon is a dying platform that keeps losing users to YouTube Music I could also say that it's suspicious that Melon's New Releases TTH-like chart suddenly vanished right before NJ's comeback Well I AM still hold the biggest streaming week of 2023 on YouTube SK! But I guess it’s also suspicious Edited July 27, 2023 by Adama 1
Sorecer Posted July 27, 2023 Posted July 27, 2023 Omg 1.6m at the end wow this is really huge . I can see NJ1 doing 2m
Epi.oxy. Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 7 minutes ago, Adama said: This chart don’t have a big impact on big acts like IVE and G idle. They get big uls with or without the 24h hits playlist. It would have been the same for Super shy. SS uls were impacted bc of the time release Well I AM still hold the biggest streaming week of 2023 on YouTube SK! But I guess it’s also suspicious nmixx can chart top 10 with the playlist then drop to 40s after the playlist. its impact every act inc ive and gidle.
LuneMon Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 Yoy guys really took the bait from that aespa stan I don't mind IVE and NJ sharing the first place 3
Adama Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 (edited) 12 minutes ago, smates said: He’s hot but his para social relationships/ fanservice with his fans is weird. No wonder most of armys aren’t normal 7 minutes ago, Epi.oxy. said: nmixx can chart top 10 with the playlist then drop to 40s after the playlist. its impact every act inc ive and gidle. It does not impact big acts. Once again they would have charted high with or without the playlist. Last time I checked neither I AM, Queencard, Spicy, Flower or Unforgiven dropped 40 spots after they left the playlist? It was only the case for fraudmixx, I think for StayC too? Flower literally peaked a few days before leaving the playlist, almost 1 month since the release. If that playlist was that impactful the song wouldn’t have took weeks to peak Edited July 28, 2023 by Adama
VelvetCrush Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 1 hour ago, FACT said: ? Minji serving Sana Cheer Up era idk why groups don't do this more often (as in actual performances, not just encores). The fancam probably makes it sounds better than it actually is because it's a lower quality than what's aired on TV but the other 4 members did well. I hate kpop's obsession with perfection Also idk why @Gaia got downvoted, he made some points. Back in peak 3rd gen we'd get many live vocal stages, even SM acts which were known for lipsyncing just did it the first week and then the rest was live. At this point the only thing making the performances different is the outfit cuz the dancing and vocal track is always the same and the fans support it because "they're dancing so it's hard to sing and dance at the same time!!!1!!1 why don't you try to sing and dance at the same time and see how well you do!!1!!1" 1
Epi.oxy. Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 1 minute ago, Adama said: He’s hot but his para social relationships/ fanservice with his fans is weird. No wonder most of armys aren’t normal It does not impact big acts. Once again they would have charted high with or without the playlist. Last time I checked neither I AM, Queencard, Spicy, Flower or Unforgiven dropped 40 spots after they left the playlist? they all drop 100k uls after playlisting and which week i am was biggest streaming on youtube korea? ss got 10m while iam biggest was 6m
Adama Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 5 minutes ago, LuneMon said: Yoy guys really took the bait from that aespa stan I don't mind IVE and NJ sharing the first place NJ are obviously #1
SandyJeans Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 15 minutes ago, Adama said: This chart don’t have a big impact on big acts like IVE and G idle. They get big uls with or without the 24h hits playlist. It would have been the same for Super shy. SS uls were impacted bc of the time release Well I AM still hold the biggest streaming week of 2023 on YouTube SK! But I guess it’s also suspicious Super Shy had the bigger debut tho! NewJeans's achievements don't take away from IVE and vice-versa they're both successful! 1
smates Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 1 minute ago, Adama said: He’s hot but his para social relationships/ fanservice with his fans is weird. No wonder most of armys aren’t normal I'd like to think he just knows he is hot and showing off as any other attractive person does on social media It's the fans' fault taking things too far, I just enjoy what I'm seeing like a normal person
OrgVisual Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 5 minutes ago, Adama said: He’s hot but his para social relationships/ fanservice with his fans is weird. No wonder most of armys aren’t normal It does not impact big acts. Once again they would have charted high with or without the playlist. Last time I checked neither I AM, Queencard, Spicy, Flower or Unforgiven dropped 40 spots after they left the playlist? From what I heard they just changed the playlist from "New Releases" to "Top Hits", so it doesn't impact the ones who would chart high normally at all. The previous playlist favored new releases that couldn't chart high at the beginning (like NMIXX)
Panda17 Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 1 hour ago, Gaia said: Wut I AM peaked at almost 600k UL while Super Shy hasn't peaked past 500k yet. This week Super Shy was at 32M on Gaon/Circle while I AM had weeks at 39M, 38M, 38M, 36M, 33M. I AM will at least reach #2 by yearend only behind Ditto unless it remains as stable as it is. Could compete for #1. I AM is insanely popular but IVE was promoting it everywhere. The way Starship even booked a Calm Down Man interview right before Newjeans' collaboration. I don't think IVE could pull off the same numbers without their massive promo. That's why I posted here yesterday that I wanted to see Newjeans on at least one variety show. Objectively speaking I AM is bigger than Super Shy that's a fact but IVE worked hard for that to happen.
OrgVisual Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 And NMIXX's charting is not purely because of that playlist It remains a mystery just like their 1M album sales
Dialamba Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 29 minutes ago, SandyJeans said: I never said IVE numbers were fake what I can say is that Melon is a dying platform that keeps losing users to YouTube Music I could also say that it's suspicious that Melon's New Releases TTH-like chart suddenly vanished right before NJ's comeback What’s this conspiracy theory. Melon always reforms its charts since 2020. Nothing has to with NJ. some of y’all just say whatever you want when google is free 1
Adama Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 2 minutes ago, Epi.oxy. said: they all drop 100k uls after playlisting and which week i am was biggest streaming on youtube korea? ss got 10m while iam biggest was 6m During the week 2 . I AM debuted with almost 6 millions but peaked the week after with 11.4 million streams.
OrgVisual Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 2 minutes ago, Dialamba said: What’s this conspiracy theory. Melon always reforms its charts since 2020. Nothing has to with NJ. some of y’all just say whatever you want when google is free Why are these stats different?
Dialamba Posted July 28, 2023 Posted July 28, 2023 Just now, Sept said: Why are these stats different? Debut ≠ biggest streaming week 6 minutes ago, Panda17 said: I AM is insanely popular but IVE was promoting it everywhere. The way Starship even booked a Calm Down Man interview right before Newjeans' collaboration. I don't think IVE could pull off the same numbers without their massive promo. That's why I posted here yesterday that I wanted to see Newjeans on at least one variety show. Objectively speaking I AM is bigger than Super Shy that's a fact but IVE worked hard for that to happen. Considering IVE promo internationally is inexistant. I guess SS has to promote them somewhere
Recommended Posts