rate Mariah Carey's Discography Rate | Top 246-1 Revealed

[Keter]

Thanks @Saddy! I had fun too. 

[Pecinta Mariah]

10 hours ago, Saddy said:

32. Crybaby
Score: 8.261

 

High score: 11 (Pecinta Mariah, rocket)
Low score: 1 (xfreshkidxx)

 

Top 20 material

[Pecinta Mariah]

8 hours ago, Saddy said:

2. Fantasy
Score: 9.214

 

High score: 11 (BenAmuro, Nightingale, Devin, James_Dean, Bacardo Royale)
Low score: 5 (Saddy, xfreshkidxx)

 

 

 

1. Underneath The Stars
Score: 9.264

 

High score: 11 (That Bad Eartha, Reverie, sparrowblue, Ivory., Pikachoo, suburbannature)
Low score: 3 (Nightingale)

 

 

 

Daydream aka her best album RULES 

 

Thank you @Saddy for hosting this rate

[Quicksand]

10 hours ago, Saddy said:

4. Melt Away
Score: 9.189

 

High score: 11 (killer_rose, Ken Lee, jacklovesyou1, Quicksand, xrosup, rocket)
Low score: 4 (GraceRandolph)

 

 

WAIT 

[Quicksand]

10 hours ago, Saddy said:

1. Underneath The Stars
Score: 9.264

 

High score: 11 (That Bad Eartha, Reverie, sparrowblue, Ivory., Pikachoo, suburbannature)
Low score: 3 (Nightingale)

 

 

 

An amazing winner 

[Quicksand]

Thank you @Saddy for hosting! I always love revisiting her entire discog 

[Ken Lee]

13 hours ago, Saddy said:

22. Anytime You Need A Friend
Score: 8.506

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, BenAmuro, Devin, jacklovesyou1, Pikachoo, Bacardo Royale, xrosup)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee)

 

Anytime You Need to End Your Top 10 Streak sitting safely outside of the top 20 I smiled so big 

12 hours ago, Saddy said:

4. Melt Away
Score: 9.189

 

High score: 11 (killer_rose, Ken Lee, jacklovesyou1, Quicksand, xrosup, rocket)
Low score: 4 (GraceRandolph)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "Mariah classic deep cut. It’s giving I just met Derek Jeter."

This random but deserved slay 

 

Thank you @Saddy and participants! It was an honour to be ranked #55

[GraceRandolph]

Thank you @Saddy

[BenAmuro]

You did amazing @Saddy! Thank you 

[xrosup]

Thank you for hosting the rate @Saddy  

[Saddy]

[Stuart]

I know UTS is a huge fan favourite but I didn't except it to win, especially against the big singles like WBT, Fantasy or ABMB. I'm so glad it won. 

 

Thank you for hosting the rate @Saddy. 

[Kool_Aid_King]

It's always embarrassing seeing die hard lambs sabotage her actual classic, and songs they genuinely enjoy just to "fix" a rate. These averages are incredibly low for fans. 

 

Like why does the winner have a 9.23 when this was stan voted... If y'all were the grammy committee she'd be just as snubbed as she has been 

 

UTS is a fantastic song, but I see the Butterfly sabotage pulled through. The winner realistically should've been WBT, The Roof or Breakdown. WBT hasn't won a rate in like over a decade, it's time to give up the "IT ALWAYS WINS" narrative 

[downtown]

melt away is beautiful!

[naval23]

Wait, not All I Want For Christmas being #1 if it wasn't for the good sis @Saddy 

Just went through everything and loved the messy results 

[suburbannature]

On 1/2/2023 at 1:31 PM, Kool_Aid_King said:

It's always embarrassing seeing die hard lambs sabotage her actual classic, and songs they genuinely enjoy just to "fix" a rate. These averages are incredibly low for fans. 

 

Like why does the winner have a 9.23 when this was stan voted... If y'all were the grammy committee she'd be just as snubbed as she has been 

 

UTS is a fantastic song, but I see the Butterfly sabotage pulled through. The winner realistically should've been WBT, The Roof or Breakdown. WBT hasn't won a rate in like over a decade, it's time to give up the "IT ALWAYS WINS" narrative 

Have you met Lambs? Eternally negative and contrarian.  

[Saddy]

1 hour ago, naval23 said:

Wait, not All I Want For Christmas being #1 if it wasn't for the good sis @Saddy 

Just went through everything and loved the messy results 

I know, I'm just tired of this song 

[Quicksand]

Just remembered that I never actually posted my averages 

 

Mariah Carey - 5.41

Emotions - 6.3

Music Box - 7.9

Merry Christmas - 6.6

Daydream - 8.71

Butterfly - 8.79 (8.32 w/bonus tracks)

Rainbow - 6.5

Glitter - 6.67

Charmbracelet - 6

Emancipation - 7.39 (6.5 w/bonus tracks)

E=MC2 - 5.39 (5.66 w/bonus tracks)

Memoirs - 5.65

MCIIY - 5

The Elusive Chanteuse - 6.21 (5.97 w/bonus tracks)

Caution - 8 (7.45 w/bonus tracks)

The Rarities - 6.97

 

[ImpressMeMuch]

I'm so late to this party but I checked the discog thread to make sure y'all treated runway right and its higher than i even expected! Go off with it lambs! <3 

 

On 12/28/2022 at 8:01 AM, Saddy said:

16. Runway
Score: 8.741

 

High score: 11 (Reverie)
Low score: 0 (Melancholy, Bacardo Royale)

 

 

[Saddy]

It's been 2 years already? Mariah better release a new album next year so we can re-do this rate again