rate Mariah Carey's Discography Rate | Top 246-1 Revealed

[Saddy]

26. Emotions
Score: 8.353

 

High score: 11 (Devin, °ColdFire°, xrosup)
Low score: 0 (sparrowblue)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "the video, the whistles, the emotions tribute (for which she was later unsuccesfuly sued!)"
Jamies_dean: "Multiple eargasms. Out of body eargasms."

[Saddy]

25. Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)
Score: 8.422

 

High score: 11 (Saddy, Kiss It Better, killer_rose, pop culture)
Low score: 5 (SinnerCity, Melancholy)

 

[Saddy]

24. Fourth of July
Score: 8.464

 

High score: 11 (Pecinta Mariah, Reverie, curiosity)
Low score: 1 (sparrowblue, xfreshkidxx)

 

[Saddy]

23. Everything Fades Away
Score: 8.475

 

High score: 11 (Zaynsus, Keter, Bacardo Royale, xrosup)
Low score: 1 (xfreshkidxx)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "BABY!!! One of the greatest of all mariah deep cuts/rarities."

[Saddy]

22. Anytime You Need A Friend
Score: 8.506

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, BenAmuro, Devin, jacklovesyou1, Pikachoo, Bacardo Royale, xrosup)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee)

 

[Saddy]

21. Can't Let Go
Score: 8.517

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Zaynsus, Pecinta Mariah, suburbannature)
Low score: 0 (pop culture)

 

[Saddy]

20. I Still Believe
Score: 8.542

 

High score: 11 (BenAmuro, James_Dean, Bacardo Royale)
Low score: 4 (That Bad Eartha)

 

Opinions:
james_dean: "One of my all time favs. I will never grow tired of this song."

Edited December 28, 2022 by Saddy

[Saddy]

19. #Beautiful
Score: 8.669

 

High score: 11 (sparrowblue)
Low score: 5 (GraceRandolph, xfreshkidxx)

 

[Saddy]

18. It's Like That
Score: 8.714

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Keter, Quicksand)
Low score: 5 (Pikachoo, rocket)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "another odd experiment that paid off. I remember thinking it was so sonically interesting."

[Saddy]

17. 8th Grade
Score: 8.739

 

High score: 11 (Kiss It Better, sparrowblue, James_Dean, Ivory., Pikachoo, xrosup, suburbannature)
Low score: 2 (Keter)

 

Opinions:
pikachoo: "beautiful beautiful song that deserves more love"

[Saddy]

16. Runway
Score: 8.741

 

High score: 11 (Reverie)
Low score: 0 (Melancholy, Bacardo Royale)

 

Edited December 28, 2022 by Saddy

[Saddy]

15. Heartbreaker
Score: 8.839

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, BenAmuro, Nightingale, Keter, °ColdFire°, Quicksand)
Low score: 1 (sparrowblue)

 

[Saddy]

14. Slipping Away
Score: 8.911

 

High score: 11 (Devin, SinnerCity, killer_rose, Reverie, jacklovesyou1, suburbannature)
Low score: 1 (pop culture, Onopka)

 

[Saddy]

13. The Distance
Score: 8.919

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, BenAmuro, GraceRandolph, That Bad Eartha, Quicksand, rocket)
Low score: 3 (Sjane)

 

[KeirGrey]

Wow the taste is jumping

[Saddy]

12. We Belong Together
Score: 8.931

 

High score: 11 (Nightingale, Kiss It Better, Devin, GraceRandolph, sparrowblue, xfreshkidxx, James_Dean, Bacardo Royale)
Low score: 1 (pop culture)

 

Opinions:
pikachoo: "i would normally give this a 10, but i know everyone will give it 10s and 11s and this song will prob win the rate when it shouldn’t"

[Saddy]

11. Always Be My Baby
Score: 8.954

 

High score: 10 (BenAmuro, Nightingale, Kiss It Better, Devin, SinnerCity, Zaynsus, killer_rose, That Bad Eartha, Keter, °ColdFire°,  Quicksand, xfreshkidxx, Pikachoo, Bacardo Royale, curiosity)
Low score: 0 (GraceRandolph, sparrowblue)

 

[Saddy]

10. Honey
Score: 8.958

 

High score: 11 (°ColdFire°, Quicksand, Bacardo Royale)
Low score: 0 (sparrowblue)

 

[Saddy]

9. Butterfly
Score: 9.008

 

High score: 11 (pop culture)
Low score: 6 (Nightingale, Limitless, Sjane)

 

Opinions:
Pop culture: "Her best ballad period"

[Saddy]

8. Vision Of Love
Score: 9.072

 

High score: 11 (Nightingale, Devin, Zaynsus, Bacardo Royale, suburbannature)
Low score: 2 (sparrowblue)

 

Opinions:
Limitless: "whilst it’s legendary, and it is her first #1, but it’s always been boring to me – I still use, though"
Keter: "iconic! the debut!"
Pop culture: "Talented, brilliant, incredible, amazing, cuh-totally unique..."

[Saddy]

7. The Roof (Back In Time)
Score: 9.103

 

High score: 11 (Miss Show Business, Nightingale, Kiss It Better, Devin, SinnerCity, GraceRandolph, killer_rose)
Low score: 0 (pop culture)

 

Opinions:
Killer_rose: "The Roof is Mariah's best song ever. That's a fact and if the song doesn't win the rate, then there are big ugly goats in here."
James_dean: "I never and still don’t get the hype for this one. Truly."

[suburbannature]

Runway higher than GML and 8th Grade  

 

popculture’s troll scores lowkey ruined this ranking 

[suburbannature]

Just now, Saddy said:

7. The Roof (Back In Time)
Score: 9.103

 

High score: 11 (Miss Show Business, Nightingale, Kiss It Better, Devin, SinnerCity, GraceRandolph, killer_rose)
Low score: 0 (pop culture)

 

Opinions:
Killer_rose: "The Roof is Mariah's best song ever. That's a fact and if the song doesn't win the rate, then there are big ugly goats in here."
James_dean: "I never and still don’t get the hype for this one. Truly."

Case in point 

[Saddy]

6. Breakdown
Score: 9.125

 

High score: 11 (That Bad Eartha, Melancholy, jacklovesyou1, suburbannature,  rocket)
Low score: 1 (pop culture, sparrowblue)

 

[Melancholy]

53 minutes ago, Saddy said:

25. Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)
Score: 8.422

 

Low score: 5 (SinnerCity, Melancholy)

Yessss **** this stupid song