rate Mariah Carey's Discography Rate | Top 246-1 Revealed

[James_Dean]

@Saddy are you posting all the results today?

[killer_rose]

53 minutes ago, suburbannature said:

Sunflowers was a little too early…

 

and DiDT is overhated, but there aren’t a ton of worse songs. 

DiDT is cute and inoffensive. Definitely didn't deserve to go out so early.

[Saddy]

221. Skydiving
Score: 5.665

High score: 11 (Keter)
Low score: 1 (Miss Show Business, That Bad Eartha, Limitless, jacklovesyou1)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "will the HQ of this ever ever see the light of day?"
pichachoo: "the bop that got away"
 

[Saddy]

1 minute ago, James_Dean said:

@Saddy are you posting all the results today?

Nope

[Saddy]

220. Makin' It Last All Night (What It Do)
Score: 5.669

High score: 10 (Keter, jacklovesyou1)
Low score: 1 (pop culture, xfreshkidxx, Sjane)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "idk why I love this ****"

[Saddy]

219. One More Try
Score: 5.692

High score: 10 (Saddy, JoAddams, Melancholy, xrosup)
Low score: 0 (Limitless, pop culture) 

 

Opinions:
pop culture: "Absolutely disrespectful to GM and it should've never been released"
james_dean: "I know it’s not everyone’s cup of tea, but I love the lyrics and it being sung by Mariah is what makes it for me."
 

[Saddy]

218. Charlie Brown Christmas
Score: 5.700

High score: 11 (BenAmuro, Devin, Melancholy)
Low score: 1 (Keter, Onopka, xfreshkidxx)

 

[Saddy]

217. How much
Score: 5.717

High score: 10 (JoAddams)
Low score: 0 (Quicksand, Pikachoo)

 

Opinions:
Pop Culture: "I don't want no scrubs"
Pikachoo: "loud, shouty, usher adds nothing, and a straight up copy of No Scrubs. come on now, Mariah"

[Saddy]

216. Portrait
Score: 5.719

High score: 10 (JoAddams, Pikachoo, curiosity)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee, Limitless, xrosup)

 

[suburbannature]

50 minutes ago, Saddy said:

229. The Beautiful Ones ft. Dru Hill
Score: 5.319

High score: 10 (BenAmuro, Keter, Melancholy, xrosup, rocket)
Low score: 0 (Miss Show Business, Limitless, Pikachoo)

 

Opinions:
Pop Culture: "RIP Prince (Demi Lovato, 2016)"
Pikachoo: "overrated boring mess that goes on and on without end."

Y’all aren’t seeing Heaven 

[GraceRandolph]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

216. Portrait
Score: 5.719

High score: 10 (JoAddams, Pikachoo, curiosity)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee, Limitless, xrosup)

 

 

[Saddy]

215. U Make Me Wanna
Score: 5.753

High score: 10 (Melancholy, sparrowblue)
Low score: 1 (That Bad Eartha)

 

[Saddy]

214. O Come All Ye Faithful/Hallelujah Chorus ft. Patricia Carey
Score: 5.767

High score: 11 (Keter, sparrowblue)
Low score: 0 (killer_rose, Pikachoo)

 

Opinions:
Pikachoo: "Patricia Carey is an evil witch and deserves to rot for the way she treated Mariah as a child because she was jealous of her daughter's talent"

[suburbannature]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

214. O Come All Ye Faithful/Hallelujah Chorus ft. Patricia Carey
Score: 5.767

High score: 11 (Keter, sparrowblue)
Low score: 0 (killer_rose, Pikachoo)

 

Opinions:
Pikachoo: "Patricia Carey is an evil witch and deserves to rot for the way she treated Mariah as a child because she was jealous of her daughter's talent"

Should have been out first.

[killer_rose]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

214. O Come All Ye Faithful/Hallelujah Chorus ft. Patricia Carey
Score: 5.767

High score: 11 (Keter, sparrowblue)
Low score: 0 (killer_rose, Pikachoo)

 

Opinions:
Pikachoo: "Patricia Carey is an evil witch and deserves to rot for the way she treated Mariah as a child because she was jealous of her daughter's talent"

This **** is finally out, phew. Literally a screamfest. 

[Saddy]

213. Last Kiss
Score: 5.800

High score: 11 (Reverie)
Low score: 0 (sparrowblue, rocket)

 

[Saddy]

212. Lullaby of Birdland
Score: 5.822

High score: 10 (killer_rose, Melancholy)
Low score: 0 (Rocket)

 

[Saddy]

211. I Don't ft. YG
Score: 5.828

High score: 10 (killer_rose, Melancholy, jacklovesyou1, Ivory.)
Low score: 0 (Quicksand, xrosup)

 

[Saddy]

210. Infinity
Score: 5.829

High score: 11 (Ken Lee)
Low score: 0 (Bacardo Royale)

 

[Saddy]

209. Whenever You Call ft. Brian McKnight
Score: 5.850

High score: 10 (Keter, Onopka)
Low score: 0 (JoAddams, Melancholy)

 

Opinions:
Killer_rose: "i dont know her"
Pop culture: "Didn't need to exist"

[That Bad Eartha]

No huge losses so far. Will be interesting to see how it shakes out. Less participants than the last one means everyone’s individual scores carry more weight so sabotages might actually be somewhat effective. Plus the last rate wasn’t that long ago so about half the participants are aware of what “needs” to be sabotaged

[suburbannature]

2 minutes ago, ONOPKA said:

goodbye last piss  we need more einstein exits tho

Like - how does it have so much left in?

[Saddy]

208. Angels Cry
Score: 5.881

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Nightingale)
Low score: 0 (pop culture)

 

[suburbannature]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

208. Angels Cry
Score: 5.881

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Nightingale)
Low score: 0 (pop culture)

 

Corny af song.

[suburbannature]

4 minutes ago, That Bad Eartha said:

No huge losses so far. Will be interesting to see how it shakes out. Less participants than the last one means everyone’s individual scores carry more weight so sabotages might actually be somewhat effective. Plus the last rate wasn’t that long ago so about half the participants are aware of what “needs” to be sabotaged

And the participant list this time is comprised mainly of hardcore Lambs with more intricate discography knowledge. We should do a side-by-side comparison of both rankings when this is completed. 

 

@Saddy When an album is eliminated could you rank standard editions by average as well?