tournament Vanishing Letters 10 | WINNER REVEALED (pg. 118) | #ATRL'sNextTopVanisher

[Overprotected]

[Overprotected]

BOYS WILL BE GIRLS

 

Rank the entries and send them to Overprotected through Discord

 

Excluding your own entries, rank from 1-6:

 

1. ex: Diablo [BEST SONG]

2. ex: Saoko [2ND BEST SONG]

…

6. ex: Bulerías [WORST SONG]

 

Quote

CIX - Cinema

SWV - Weak

The Cheetah Girls - Strut

Soul For Real - Candy Rain

Hi-Five - I Like The Way

Spice Girls - Holler

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart

Everglow - La di da

SPOTIFY

 

DEADLINE: THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 29TH 7PM EST 

 

@wish @Element @brycehooha @Touch It

 

 

 

 

 

[Overprotected]

I forgot to mention, since we're heading towards a top 3... If there's more than a point difference between 3th and 4th place then 4th place is auto OUT 

[Seffers]

rooting for everglow

smash, iconic, their best song

[Touch It]

men & women round critiques

 

CIX - Cinema: this was pretty cute, it has nice production

SWV - Weak: nostalgic beautiful and just IDEK how else to describe this song it's just so good

The Cheetah Girls - Strut: no like you COMPLETELY ate... YOU GOTTA STRUT LIKE YOU MEAN IT FREE YOUR MIND AHHHH best entry of the season I fear

Soul For Real - Candy Rain: this was nice, they sound good on it!

Hi-Five - I Like The Way: this was also very nice and pretty

Spice Girls - Holler: tbh I don't like the verses but I really like chorus! so idk how to feel about the song fully

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart: cute & catchy song

Everglow - La di da: excellence I don't have to say anything else besides that

 

[Touch It]

also I lied la di da is the best entry of all time i just got too excited about the cheetah girls

[Staryu]

 

CIX - Cinema

I remember this song from the kpop rate, it was the best male song tbh, smart choice

 

SWV - Weak

R&B classic, beautiful harmonies

 

The Cheetah Girls - Strut

I've actually never seen this movie but this song is a BOP 

 

Soul For Real - Candy Rain

I'm shocked I've never heard of this song, seems to be a 90s classic, I liked it

 

Hi-Five - I Like The Way

It's cute, giving New Kids on the Block

 

Spice Girls - Holler

I stan this song, been a fave since I was a kid when I found it on Limewire

 

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart

One of the best boy band songs tbqh

 

Everglow - La di da

This BOP, Alena's impact  one of my fave kpop songs 

[Alena]

 

CIX - Cinema - CIX are icons!!! lovely song <3 i know Ron is smiling!! Stan Hyunsuks and Seunghunty!

SWV - Weak - it's pretty! not exactly my vibe sadly but it's fine UwU.

The Cheetah Girls - Strut - i'm sure some people will like this but it's not for me! there were so many good options for this theme and you go with... Cheetah girls? Maybe i'm missing something here!

Soul For Real - Candy Rain - also very 90s rnb, which is fine but just not that exciting to me :(

Hi-Five - I Like The Way - another 90s song! groundbreaking!!! i'm just repeating myself here ik but idk, it's been pretty underwhelming so far!

Spice Girls - Holler - this is a nice bop! propably one of the best Spice girls i know of! Victoria is an icon. Also Baby spice !! <3

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart - this is pretty cute. very 90s also but more pop than the other 90s songs, so it's catchier!

Everglow - La di da - LEGENDARY, AMAZING!!!! Lives were literally changed... Doesn't get much better than this!

 

[brycehooha]

brycehooha's critiques

 

 

CIX - Cinema: this is what boy group music should be. no more noise. just pretty sounds pls

SWV - Weak: kind of the best song of all time like the chorus needs to be studied

The Cheetah Girls - Strut: like im on the streets of barcelona when this came on

Soul For Real - Candy Rain: this sounds vaguely familiar and its such a bop 

Hi-Five - I Like The Way: ooh their voices are rly pretty this is good

Spice Girls - Holler: i havent listened to much spice girls rly but this is not the sound i was expecting! pleasantly surprised! with the chorus at least

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart: this was very much fine. i like the wub wub noises 

Everglow - La di da: like this song singlehandedly made me even know who everglow was. i think it might be one of the best kpop songs ever made truly

[Sanguine]

 

CIX - Cinema: Oh pls I thought of this but didn’t think anyone would send it. I’m sure Ron is proud! Anyways, it’s catchy, the chorus is good, a little generic but nice

SWV - Weak: it's pretty! not exactly my vibe sadly but it's fine UwU. [2]

The Cheetah Girls - Strut: Pretty obnoxious, I usually like these Disney songs cuz they have good melodies and are simple/catchy but found this quite annoying

Soul For Real - Candy Rain: Cute! Kind of a throwback to the weather round

Hi-Five - I Like The Way: Love this, reminds me of Janet

Spice Girls - Holler: Liked this more than I expected! Really catchy

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart: Sounds exactly like every other Y2K pop song ever but that's not a bad thing! 

Everglow - LA DI DA: HUGE BOP… The Weeknd was ended

[wish]

wishtie's critiques ?♡?

 

CIX - Cinema

this is a cute lil bop, i like the chorus! their vocals sound pretty and smooth. definitely generic but i enjoyed this

 

SWV - Weak

oh yup I ADORE this song. Such a sweet and iconic love song One of favorite 90s R&B singles without a doubt.

 

The Cheetah Girls - Strut

omfg i haven’t heard this in forEVERRR  yet somehow the melody is etched in the back of my brain. yeah this is a CLASSIC… you ate. 

 

Soul For Real - Candy Rain

okay this is def something i heard as a kid bc i remember the chorus so much despite not rly knowing the song? anyway it’s very pretty, i enjoyed!

 

Hi-Five - I Like The Way

the ancient tracks for this round  this one is less nostalgic for me, and it’s cute but not really standing out. a bit generic

 

Spice Girls - Holler

ou we love 00s Darkchild however the vocals are distracting for me... they’re robotic but not in an interesting stylized way. not my fave here sorry :/

 

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart

definitely generic but it’s actually enjoyable… the chorus kinda slaps?  honestly better than i expected from nsync. yeah this is a cute lil bop ngl!

 

EVERGLOW - LA DI DA

the serve was saved for last i see  MAJOR bop, one of my fave kpop songs ever like whew this is an undeniable smash

[Element]

CIX - Cinema

This was pleasant enough! It didn't really move me one way or another though.

 

SWV - Weak

Another nice choice! I think this one definitely had some elements that dated it, whereas a few of the other older songs held up over time? IDK.

 

The Cheetah Girls - Strut

This brings up some major major nostalgia. A big bop within the context of the movie... I guess we'll see if it stands up next to some of these other girl groups??

 

Soul For Real - Candy Rain

Enjoyed the chorus melody and their harmonizations! Could have been shorter [1]

 

Hi-Five - I Like The Way

The overall vibe was cute. It's an enjoyable throwback hit! Could have been shorter [2]

 

Spice Girls - Holler

Definitely catchy and one of the better songs I've heard from them tbh

 

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart

A mega boy bop I fear

 

Everglow - La di da

A mega girl bop I fear like wtf!!

[Not Like The Movies]

 

CIX - Cinema - Great song, I remember it from the rate. I like it, one of the better kpop boyband songs. 

 

SWV - Weak - You already know im bouta stan this huge classic!! Really happy to see that it got sent, an amazing song!! They sound so good too! R&B excellence!! 

 

The Cheetah Girls - Strut - lol yes at this childhood classic! A bop tbh! I'm not mad at this submission! 

 

Soul For Real - Candy Rain - This black classic!! I am living! You said this one is for the culture! Here for it! Lovely submission! 

 

Hi-Five - I Like The Way - Another black classic!! This is such a great song. Unexpected yet strong pick! 

 

Spice Girls - Holler - Definitely one of their best songs imo, it's very R&B and I love it! ofc I hear Darkchild! Well done bestie! 

 

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart - This is objectively a fine song but I wasn't a big fan of this. It got a little cheesy. One of the men have a good voice though, I can't tell who though nnn. 

 

Everglow - La di da - This is very catchy, sometimes it gets a bit too loud but it's a bop! 

 

 

@wish @Element @brycehooha @Touch It

[Auburn]

 

CIX - Cinema: this was nice but I don't feel like it captured me beyond being very nice, I don't find it memorable and I forgot it immediately after I heard it, lovely production tho so points for that

SWV - Weak: irrelevant to the critique but this needs to be remastered so badly it's a decent choice for me

The Cheetah Girls - Strut: classic… I really love this song and I feel like it's aged really well for me, so good

Soul For Real - Candy Rain: I really love the instrumental here, much more than the vocals, which at times are kinda offputting cuz he is/sounds like a kid, still a really strong entry for me tho

Hi-Five - I Like The Way: another fine groove we got here yeah

Spice Girls - Holler: I think this entry was specifically pandered to me so… amazing amazing song although after the sender of this is revealed I would love to know your reasoning to send a song from their worst album. The harmonies

NSYNC - Tearing Up My Heart: JC leads this song instead of JT so I have to stan it a bit, it's a moderate classic for me (because it was performed on PCD Presents: Girlicious, a group which one of you should have sent btw!)

Everglow - La Di Da: it's a bop but I kinda hate it tbh… this BL ripoff trend is tragic, and this is not really my cup of tea, the rapping is cringey too

 

@wish @Element @brycehooha @Touch It

[Element]

post my demise

[Element]

next

[Element]

next

[Element]

next

[Element]

next

[Element]

PTR

[Element]

heyyy

[Element]

save me winner yup

[Element]

oh wow still old page

[Element]

hello??

[Element]

omg...