base talk Is Xtina the artist who sang with the most legends?

[Jay07]

Just now, brainmaniac said:

The usual lack of logic from you  Singing a tribute for someone isn’t the same as a recording with that artists vocals.

 

You don’t see anyone listing the artists that Christina tribute to but doesn’t have a recording for. Christina has done tributes to Nina Simone And Tina Turner, but obviously that’s not listed as her singing with them, the way you’re Trying to say Gaga sang with Bowie because she did a tribute for him 

Actually the post that YOU QUOTED said sang with and FOR. Reading comprehension is key, my love 

[brainmaniac]

Just now, Jay07 said:

Sampling someone's vocals =/= singing with them. Unless you count performing with a hologram as collaborating. 

Posthumous collaboration are still considered singing with them. Celine Dion did duets with old samples of Frank Sinatra and Elvis because they’re obviously dead and they’re still considered duets

[Jay07]

Just now, brainmaniac said:

Posthumous collaboration are still considered singing with them. Celine Dion did duets with old samples of Frank Sinatra and Elvis because they’re obviously dead and they’re still considered duets

Is sampling the word Maria from an old Jackson 5 song considered a duet? Kanye has sampled hundreds of old songs in his career, are they all duets? Is this like Moves Like Jagger being a solo Xtina song again?

[brainmaniac]

1 minute ago, Jay07 said:

Is sampling the word Maria from an old Jackson 5 song considered a duet? Kanye has sampled hundreds of old songs in his career, are they all duets? Is this like Moves Like Jagger being a solo Xtina song again?

No, it’s not one word sampled Clearly you don’t know what you’re talking about. You can hear him actually singing the song in the same pitch. It’s not even like one of those pitch and screwed sample. 

 

And you can even be credited for way less than that. Mario Winians And P Didddy credit a sample of Enya and she’s just humming 

[Jeremiah]

Rolling Stones

Tony Bennett

Madonna

Britney Spears

Sting

etc...

 

Impressive the amount of legends she's sung with 

[brainmaniac]

6 minutes ago, Jay07 said:

Actually the post that YOU QUOTED said sang with and FOR. Reading comprehension is key, my love 

The backtracking The point is you tried to claim Gaga sang with Bowie and Julie Andrews whether live or on a recording and it never happened and tried to pivot, acting like singing a tribute for them was the same thing

[Jay07]

Of course you credit a sample, otherwise it's stealing. Is sampling the same as doing a duet though? Hmm, something to ponder 

[Jay07]

Just now, brainmaniac said:

The backtracking The point is you tried to claim Gaga sang with Bowie and Julie Andrews whether live or on a recording and it never happened and tried to pivot, acting like singing a tribute for them was the same thing

Backtracking? It's literally in the post you quoted in black and white. Don't blame me if you can't read 

[brainmaniac]

Just now, Jay07 said:

Backtracking? It's literally in the post you quoted in black and white. Don't blame me if you can't read 

The topic said singing with legends not for, so if you have to include tributes for, then you already knew you didn’t have a case  

[NausAllien]

I'm an Xtina fan, but I wouldn't count her sampling a Jackson 5 song as a collab with MJ.

 

She has enough actual, physical collabs that there shouldn't be a need to count those.

And no, you can't count TRIBUTES as collabs like other users are doing with their faves. 

 

OP forgot to mention Tony Bennett:

 

Andrea Bocelli:

 

 

Edited May 8, 2022 by NausAllien

[suburbannature]

Sampling a dead MJ is not singing with him

 

 

[suburbannature]

Just now, NausAllien said:

I'm an Xtina fan, but I wouldn't count her sampling a Jackson 5 song as a collab with MJ.

 

She has enough actual, physical collabs that there shouldn't be a need to count those. The same you can't count TRIBUTES as collabs like other users are doing.

 

OP forgot to mention Tony Bennett:

 

Andrea Bocelli:

 

 

I didn’t count anything that wasn’t singing live on stage with the artist if you mean me. Except Tony but they were in the studio together.

[Jay07]

Just now, brainmaniac said:

The topic said singing with legends not for, so if you have to include tributes for, then you already knew you didn’t have a case  

Surely being asked to honor a legend in their presence or the presence of their family is a higher honor than paying to sample a song from the 70s 

[NausAllien]

Just now, suburbannature said:

I didn’t count anything that wasn’t singing live on stage with the artist if you mean me. Except Tony but they were in the studio together.

No, I was referring to that Gaga fan who counted her singing a tribute for Bowie as her singing WITH Bowie, which is what this post is about.

 

And Mariah probably has more collabs, but it's no suprise since she's a living legend.

[suburbannature]

Just now, NausAllien said:

 

 

And Mariah probably has more collabs, but it's no suprise since she's a living legend.

Yes and with an unmatched voice - who wouldn't want to sing with that  

[brainmaniac]

1 minute ago, Jay07 said:

Surely being asked to honor a legend in their presence or the presence of their family is a higher honor than paying to sample a song from the 70s 

Then looks like Christina got that “higher honor” too since she  was asked to honor Michael Jackson in the company of his family too 

 

And even getting a sample of Michael Jackson on record is an honor too. Christina has talked about how it was very difficult to get a sample of him but because Kanye West was affiliated with the song he was able to make it happen. 

[Xtianlofbritney]

This thread 

[gerardsuxx]

 

 

 

[Jay07]

1 minute ago, brainmaniac said:

Then looks like Christina got that “higher honor” too since she  was asked to honor Michael Jackson in the company of his family too 

 

And even getting a sample of Michael Jackson on record is an honor too. Christina has talked about how it was very difficult to get a sample of him but because Kanye West was affiliated with the song he was able to make it happen. 

She was? When did she sing for the family?

[dirrtydiana]

Idk but Britney has sang with more legends than xtina:

 

MJ, Madonna, DC, Beyoncé, jlo, U2, bono, MJB, Aerosmith, Shakira (during a photo shoot), Mariah, Pink, herself on everytime, etc, etc, etc. Honestly there’s too many to count.

 

[Jay07]

Don't forget Xtina singing with the ultimate legend, herself, as mentioned in the OP. Surely that trumps all.

[suburbannature]

2 minutes ago, dirrtydiana said:

Idk but Britney has sang with more legends than xtina:

 

MJ, Madonna, DC, Beyoncé, jlo, U2, bono, MJB, Aerosmith, Shakira (during a photo shoot), Mariah, Pink, herself on everytime, etc, etc, etc. Honestly there’s too many to count.

 

Wait, when did Britney and Mariah sing together?

[Julia Fox]

No, it’s Cindy Lauper

[NausAllien]

2 minutes ago, Jay07 said:

She was? When did she sing for the family?

I think it was this one:

[brainmaniac]

4 minutes ago, Jay07 said:

She was? When did she sing for the family?

She was and sang at the Michael Forever concert in 2011 where his family was in attendance