ZORBIT Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 Because the rules specifically state contestants will submit a photo of their celebrity wearing an outfit that best matches the theme of the round. Thank you for your comments judges
touya kinomoto Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 1 hour ago, Anvarie said: The judges critiques don’t make sense to me, this round’s concept was fun but clearly the explanation was not understood well. People submitted beautiful gowns (except Jlo, you did amazing sweetie) that someone would never guess is for their specific sin and they get great remarks. Meanwhile someone like Bella (while yes you can’t see the full look) gets seemingly worse critiques for embodying their chosen sin it's embodying the sin through the clothes, not the overall photo.
DevonRoars Posted May 23, 2022 Author Posted May 23, 2022 @Anvarie This is a fashion competition. We need to see the looks. For example: @Invisibility sends looks that may be modeled by someone else along side their looks that may be obscured by editing.
Douglas Booth Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 14 minutes ago, D e v o n said: @Anvarie This is a fashion competition. We need to see the looks. For example: @Invisibility sends looks that may be modeled by someone else along side their looks that may be obscured by editing. i need to be a judge next szn, also PTR
Invisibility Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 We haven't seen critiques from half the judges though dd
Douglas Booth Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 1 hour ago, Invisibility said: We haven't seen critiques from half the judges though dd Me to @Yvess @CBC @D e v o n @Jai @kipperskipper:
DevonRoars Posted May 23, 2022 Author Posted May 23, 2022 7 Deadly Sins Critiques P R I D E @CBC @kipperskipper @Yvess @Jai Envy @ZORBIT Shea Couleé This is full of drama and beauty.. and for envy I can see the vision.. not necessairly this Nicki song, but the sadness side of envy with her loss to Sasha. It's very sad in a beautiful way. My only issue are the shoes. They seem like an afterthought. @Opulent Eiza Gonzalez This is a cute look. Not the most exciting, but servicable. The tear drops and jewlry (that don't really match) sell it for me. Greed @Ryan BTE Jennifer Lopez This is simply perfection. No notes. @Speezy Belcalis Marlenis Almánzar Definitely a great look and tough competition for JLo. Wrath @99sandthe2000s Janelle Monáe It's very Colonel Sanders, but also a well dressed devil. I'm truly seeing both fantasies. Well done. @WestHaven Bella Hadid Sadly this is a miss all around from the three different looks in one entry to this lack of look. It is a great photo and it does convey wrath. Lust @touya kinomoto Coco Rocha This garment is great and she looks alluring. Like a sex demon. @Douglas Booth Lady Gaga Hmmm... I don't like this. For such an easy category I expected more. I also just don't find this sexy. Gluttony @Thanatos Leonie Hanne Very unique write up that definitely added to this entry. I'll take your vision. Well done. @Anvarie Nicki Minaj You're getting flack for this, but I like it. It's pink which represents gluttony as a color. I like the sandwiches everywhere especially in the bag. Pride @dweebz Raja Very regal. Love it. @Not Like The Movies Beyoncé Off the back nit-pick.. I don't like this black corset on top of this. She has enough money get a matching corset. I'm also seeing religious imgagery -- more than the queen kind of thing you were going for. Sloth @Rotunda Symone This is more than just t-shirt and jeans. This is a scultped breast plate that has the appearance of a wet t-shirt. The pants are crystalized in a gradient. This is fabulous and it fits the sin, but is much deeper than what's on the surface. Love it. @Invisibility Issa Lish This is great and it looks comfortable. Vivienne Westwood is also just amazing.
Not Like The Movies Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 (edited) yikes, I feel like there is way too much cleavage for it to be fully religious but okay. And even if you see that, religious people are full of pride and are judgmental/condescending so it fits. Edited May 23, 2022 by Not Like The Movies
DevonRoars Posted May 23, 2022 Author Posted May 23, 2022 27 minutes ago, Not Like The Movies said: yikes, I feel like there is way too much cleavage for it to be fully religious but okay. And even if you see that, religious people are full of pride and are judgmental/condescending so it fits. Yes I agree it fits pride. Just not a huge fan of the look.
Thanatos Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 7 hours ago, kipperskipper said: Envy @ZORBIT Shea- NEVER was a big fan of this look. It's like a culmination of A LOT of shapes/things/textures etc (the weird blue hair color, the odd pink choice for the dress, the cut-outs, the sleeve, the backless back, the giant bow in the back etc), and it's TOO much. HOWEVER, I think this is such a GREAT look to send for this theme. I think it's better suited than Eiza's. @Opulent Eiza- I actually LIKE this look. You are right that "envy" is dark, brooding, and dramatic, just like this look! However, there is SOMETHING about his look that just feels underdone. Greed @Ryan BTEJLO- PERFECTION @Speezy- REALLY love this look and concept. It really is a WORK of art. However, I do think JLO's more literal approach paid of more than this. Wrath @99sandthe2000s I am 100% SOLD on this look. Everything you said about this look just makes SENSE. @WestHaven This is NOT ANTM. Lust @touya kinomoto I think the patters REALLY takeaway the sexiness of the cut of the dress. Sure there are cut-outs, but it's not exuding lust or sexiness. I'm getting more of an aquatic/futuristic vibe. @Douglas Booth It's VERY ok and teetering to NOT good. The top is interesting, but that's IT. I find it HARD to believe this was Gaga's best 'lust' look. Gluttony @Thanatos- Leonnie-STELLAR! another STOMP! I was EXHAUSTED by this tulle trend. But this one is done RIGHT. @Anvarie This is NOT ANTM. Pride @dweebz @Not Like The Movies Beyonce- I MEAN... Is there even anything to say?? PERFECT! Sloth @Rotunda Symone- I 100% UNDERSTAND your reasoning and WHY you chose this look, because it is a LAZY look, but at the same time, the LAZINESS hurts you in a game about fashion. It's a white tee with jeans. IDC how many think pieces people wrote, this look is NOT revolutionary high FASHION. It did NOT meet the standards of a good drag look, and does NOT meet the standards for this game. @Invisibility- FLOORED! EVERYTHING i WANTED and NEEDED from this round. #1 by MILES for me. @kipperskipper @D e v o n @CBC @Jai @Yvess Stop the Symone panning or ATRL‘s #1 Symone fan TheOnlyOne will make an appearence in this thread
Not Like The Movies Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 32 minutes ago, D e v o n said: Yes I agree it fits pride. Just not a huge fan of the look. ok got it.
Yvess Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 3 hours ago, Douglas Booth said: Me to @Yvess @CBC @D e v o n @Jai @kipperskipper: bish i was the first one to send in my critique? ranking u down rn
WestHaven Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 I decided to take a break from ATRL this weekend for mental health reasons but if the judges would still like to reconsider their rankings here’s the outfit I misunderstood what was asked of use
CBC Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 8 hours ago, Douglas Booth said: Me to @Yvess @CBC @D e v o n @Jai @kipperskipper:
kipperskipper Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 8 hours ago, Thanatos said: Stop the Symone panning or ATRL‘s #1 Symone fan TheOnlyOne will make an appearence in this thread maybe if she sent in a good look?
Thanatos Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 11 minutes ago, kipperskipper said: maybe if she sent in a good look?
Rotunda Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 30 minutes ago, kipperskipper said: maybe if she sent in a good look? I get that you’re still not over losing ANTM for being boring, but let’s not take it out on the girl that had your back
kipperskipper Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 1 hour ago, Rotunda said: I get that you’re still not over losing ANTM for being boring, but let’s not take it out on the girl that had your back I love you my rotunda but i do not love miss symones fashions (at least some of the onse sent so far)
Anvarie Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 15 hours ago, D e v o n said: @Anvarie This is a fashion competition. We need to see the looks. For example: @Invisibility sends looks that may be modeled by someone else along side their looks that may be obscured by editing. Why did I get read for submitting an ANTM picture (I’ve never played that game)? My outfit is clearly visible. Why is it less gluttonous than Thantos submitting a tulle dress?
CBC Posted May 23, 2022 Posted May 23, 2022 8 hours ago, WestHaven said: I decided to take a break from ATRL this weekend for mental health reasons but if the judges would still like to reconsider their rankings here’s the outfit I misunderstood what was asked of use I hope you're feeling better now
DevonRoars Posted May 23, 2022 Author Posted May 23, 2022 2 hours ago, Anvarie said: Why did I get read for submitting an ANTM picture (I’ve never played that game)? My outfit is clearly visible. Why is it less gluttonous than Thantos submitting a tulle dress? @ that judge I liked your entry also America's Next Top Model is just a modeling show.
DevonRoars Posted May 23, 2022 Author Posted May 23, 2022 15 minutes @Speezy @ZORBIT @Rotunda @Douglas Booth @99sandthe2000s @Invisibility @WestHaven @Ryan BTE @Thanatos @Anvarie @Not Like The Movies @touya kinomoto @Opulent @dweebz @kipperskipper @D e v o n @Jai @Yvess @CBC
Recommended Posts