base talk Most dated 2008 pop girl album?

[dirrtydiana]

I hope that the omission of Janet’s 2008 Discipline album was because it’s the least dated 

 

 

ot: Katy’s tbh

 

[Chris]

Hard Candy gave us Candy Shop.

[Solaria]

The Fame is the BEST aged album out of these

[Scandalous]

none of them exactly sound fresh  

[Escape]

The Fame.

[JoeAg]

Hard Candy

and from a lyrical standpoint, One of the Boys (though I'll still bop to I Kissed a Girl here and there lol, and Mannequin and Thinking of You are bangers too)

[Ricardo1993]

I Am Sasha fierce aged the best.

[Jooj]

Surprisingly, HC is the least dated record of the bunch 

 

Circus isn't that dated

The Fame is dated in a good way

One Of The Boys would low-key still smash nowadays

 

Sasha Fierce "wins" this one.

[tiagol88]

2 hours ago, suburbannature said:

please  

If the Pharrell sound from hard candy is dated then poor Ariana's sweetener, Blurred Lines, Happy, get lucky etc 

[Rev8]

2 hours ago, CandyCoatedClouds said:

Appreciate what? That cover is terrible.

 

2 hours ago, GraceRandolph said:

It’s literally the worst of the 5 though?

The mad tasteless souls quoting someone who is spreading love Tasting those tears!

[CandyCoatedClouds]

28 minutes ago, Rev8 said:

 

The mad tasteless souls quoting someone who is spreading love Tasting those tears!

I like Circus as an album and I am a Britney fan but let's be real, half of her covers are just garbage head shots and Circus is one of them.

[Trash]

The Fame but it doesn't mean that we can't enjoy it, idk why stans act so defensive about it. 

[Devin]

They are all dated/nostalgia albums.

[4Real]

IASF is the most dated one. Unlistenable.

[reymiu]

5 hours ago, Jooj said:

Surprisingly, HC is the least dated record of the bunch 

 

Circus isn't that dated

The Fame is dated in a good way

One Of The Boys would low-key still smash nowadays

 

Sasha Fierce "wins" this one.

I kinda agree w this

 

HC is still enjoyable for me ... beat Goes on, she's not me, give it 2 me stood the test of time very well

 

The Fame is very representative of it's time. Like u said, it's dated but when u hear it, u feel nostalgic tbh, it's good dated ... Poker Face, Paparazzi are iconic

 

IASF had the iconic Single Ladies and Halo, but I rarely hear it. The Beyhive and fanbase moved from it too. if we want a good dated B album, we have BDay. If we want quality, we have 4. Sasha Fierce is neither.

 

Circus is pretty fun, but at the same level as Sasha Fierce for me

[sourtwink]

people saying the fame when the reason it sounds “dated” is because it was so trendsetting that everyone copied it for the next few years  anyways, the answer is circus or hard candy

[Dystopian]

they’re all incredibly dated, but ootb sounds the best rn because pop rock is having a resurgence. good 4 u by olivia is very reminiscent of hot n cold.

[FOCK]

In order of dated-ness

• The Fame
• Hard Candy
• One of the Boys
• I Am = Circus

The production on I Am and Circus is quite varied and not limited to "one" particular trend, which helps. 

 

 

[Protocol]

I have to say it's The Fame, it really sounds of its time. Some of those RedOne synths are just  One of the Boys has aged better especially now pop-rock is current again. IASF has some really dated production on the Sasha side, but the I Am... folk soul production is pretty timeless. Circus is the second most dated after The Fame or a tie with it. The title track aged really well and still hits hard but the rest is a mixed bag, some really late 00s sounds there. "If U Seek Amy" sounds so cheap today. Hard Candy aged shockingly well, a lot of it still sounds very fresh, "Dance 2Night" could be a Future Nostalgia song.

[Protocol]

9 hours ago, Fnooky said:

The Fame album tracks are practically unlistenable in 2022.

This Garage Band'd percussion and those sawtooth synths in the chorus  Still a bop of course but the production screams 2008. This is the 00s equivalent of a Cyndi Lauper album track from the 80s. Aggressively of its time.

 

 

 

[Reverse Warholian]

9 hours ago, Hot Volcano said:

it's April 2022 and ATRL still doesn't know the meaning of the word "dated"

 

The term is used for an album released for example this year and it sounds like an album from 2012. That makes it dated. 

 

ATRL is always claiming this for The Fame when it reality it sounded so fresh back in 2008 and it set so many trends, that doesn't make it dated, it makes it a trendsetter and an iconic album

 

 

THIS!!!

[HïFidelity]

Circus… it sounded like 2005 even in 2008.

Edited April 17, 2022 by HïFidelity

[Protocol]

8 hours ago, Lady Claire said:

Considering it's still charting and pulling numbers on streaming i'm not sure of what kind of dust you're talking about, Kesha stan.

 

I literally stan Gaga, but no tea no shade, "Tik Tok" and "Your Love Is My Drug" have aged a lot better than The Fame singles. Whatever drum kick Dr Luke used in those still hits just as hard whereas those RedOne and Rob Fusari production sound like tins and pots nowadays. Her budget obviously increased with Fame Monster though because that album has aged super well.

[BGXKB]

NOT this

 

 

[Lover]

gagas fame