Tusk Posted January 4 Posted January 4 Will "Gorgeous (Taylor's Version)[10 Minute Version](From the Vault) win SOTY next year?
Kyle-x Posted January 5 Posted January 5 35 minutes ago, wastedpotential said: OH LETS WAKE THIS UP BIBLE BABY, YOUR TIME HAS COME Do y'all remember when that one girl's headphones glitched and we got to hear the buried Mariah note in full glory The way people pay this smash dust is truly sacrilegious. That's When > Don't You > Bye Bye Baby is a really pretty 3 track run honestly. They all have this breezy melancholic vibe. They remind me of Forever & For Always by Shania Twain in production. 2
hoax Posted January 5 Posted January 5 1 hour ago, Catch22 said: The way she never performed it live She's not seeing heaven for that I'm so serious
hoax Posted January 5 Posted January 5 1 hour ago, Timeless said: Bye Bye Baby is a horrendous vault track, be serious. The original demo version was an excellent acoustic masterpiece, but her and Hack Satantoff totally massacred that song. She sounds like she's bored singing the new version. The new lyrics don't make even sense. The production is too mellow. The acoustic version had more emotion goddamn it. It went from being one of her best unreleased tracks, to one of her worst released songs of her career. This song is everything that's wrong with Hack Satanoff. Sloppy work.
hoax Posted January 5 Posted January 5 1 hour ago, Kyle-x said: The way people pay this smash dust is truly sacrilegious. That's When > Don't You > Bye Bye Baby is a really pretty 3 track run honestly. They all have this breezy melancholic vibe. They remind me of Forever & For Always by Shania Twain in production. Oh well yes, Tithe's When is another all time classic buried with the **** in that vault Spoiler If only Dirge You wasn't in the middle providing plenty of ammo to all the OJAH
Taylor fanboy Posted January 5 Posted January 5 Would've been an epic visual. Why did the industry suddenly pushed for Post Malone's comeback last year? 7
Dear Reader Posted January 5 Posted January 5 3 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said: Would've been an epic visual. Why did the industry suddenly pushed for Post Malone's comeback last year? Truly a Swiftian classic. One of the best songs on TTPD 2
Taylor fanboy Posted January 5 Posted January 5 Just now, Dear Reader said: Truly a Swiftian classic. One of the best songs on TTPD Speaking of, sis @Beyonnaise what are our thoughts on this future emo classic?
Tusk Posted January 5 Posted January 5 7 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said: Would've been an epic visual. Why did the industry suddenly pushed for Post Malone's comeback last year? Post Malone > a Scott Swift video 3
hoax Posted January 5 Posted January 5 14 minutes ago, Taylor fanboy said: Would've been an epic visual. Why did the industry suddenly pushed for Post Malone's comeback last year? The visual potential is immense but She'd absolutely botch it, lets be real 1
IBeMe Posted January 5 Posted January 5 Did NOT expect that reaction from the haters to my Ray of Light thread i thought it was a given at this point that Taylor's transformative abilities and quality song writing were established even on this hater filled site....damn the bitterness is INSANE. I'm always ready for the haters stones amd never let it be a reason to shut us down from creating good conversation but sometimes even I get shocked by how dumb some haters on here are.... 1
Incandescent Glow Posted January 5 Posted January 5 2 hours ago, IBeMe said: Did NOT expect that reaction from the haters to my Ray of Light thread i thought it was a given at this point that Taylor's transformative abilities and quality song writing were established even on this hater filled site....damn the bitterness is INSANE. I'm always ready for the haters stones amd never let it be a reason to shut us down from creating good conversation but sometimes even I get shocked by how dumb some haters on here are.... Oh you made the thread? I thought it was a set-up thread made by OTH and didn't even open it cause I knew how it would go.
IBeMe Posted January 5 Posted January 5 Just now, Klein said: Oh you made the thread? I thought it was a set-up thread made by OTH and didn't even open it cause I knew how it would go. yeah I did I dont think i've made a Tay thread in ages and wanted to discuss the potential of Taylor tapping into a spiritual side of herself and making RoL with others but didn't think it'd go down like THAT I knew it'd have SOME backlash hence the unabashed confidence in which i stated what I said but damn these trolls push it wayyyy too far. Remind me to NEVER make a slightly "controversial" take as a thread anymore and to just post my hot takes here instead cuz i aint got the energy no more ofr this sheisse 1
Beyonnaise Posted January 5 Posted January 5 2 hours ago, Taylor fanboy said: Speaking of, sis @Beyonnaise what are our thoughts on this future emo classic? My Chemical Romance is quaking 1
Cleanromantic Posted January 5 Posted January 5 7 hours ago, Timeless said: Bye Bye Baby is a horrendous vault track, be serious. The original demo version was an excellent acoustic masterpiece, but her and Hack Satantoff totally massacred that song. She sounds like she's bored singing the new version. The new lyrics don't make even sense. The production is too mellow. The acoustic version had more emotion goddamn it. It went from being one of her best unreleased tracks, to one of her worst released songs of her career. This song is everything that's wrong with Hack Satanoff. Sloppy work. "Timeless (Taylor's Version) [From The Vault]" by Taylor Swift was produced by Taylor Swift & Jack Antonoff. 1 4
Cleanromantic Posted January 5 Posted January 5 4 hours ago, IBeMe said: Did NOT expect that reaction from the haters to my Ray of Light thread i thought it was a given at this point that Taylor's transformative abilities and quality song writing were established even on this hater filled site....damn the bitterness is INSANE. I'm always ready for the haters stones amd never let it be a reason to shut us down from creating good conversation but sometimes even I get shocked by how dumb some haters on here are.... Spoiler That madonna album is one of the most overrated albums on this site Spoiler The fact I never see it discussed on any other online space is an other proof of how out of touch people in here are Spoiler And the way Taylor makes them foam at the mouth is very concerning, the whole brigade on atrl that "songwriting is not a real talent and anyone can do it" is because they think saying it is is them admitting Taylor is talented, so they swing in the complete other direction Spoiler And it's funny when you see these members trying to project this objective, music connaisseur image when they absolutely lose it and start acting like dogs with rabies at the mere mention of Taylor's name 1
Buffy Posted January 5 Posted January 5 7 hours ago, Timeless said: Bye Bye Baby is a horrendous vault track, be serious. The original demo version was an excellent acoustic masterpiece, but her and Hack Satantoff totally massacred that song. She sounds like she's bored singing the new version. The new lyrics don't make even sense. The production is too mellow. The acoustic version had more emotion goddamn it. It went from being one of her best unreleased tracks, to one of her worst released songs of her career. This song is everything that's wrong with Hack Satanoff. Sloppy work. I agree with this review. Can we hear your thoughts on We Were Happy og vs Taylor's Version?
1989 Posted January 5 Posted January 5 2 hours ago, Cleanromantic said: Hide contents That madonna album is one of the most overrated albums on this site Hide contents The fact I never see it discussed on any other online space is an other proof of how out of touch people in here are Hide contents And the way Taylor makes them foam at the mouth is very concerning, the whole brigade on atrl that "songwriting is not a real talent and anyone can do it" is because they think saying it is is them admitting Taylor is talented, so they swing in the complete other direction Hide contents And it's funny when you see these members trying to project this objective, music connaisseur image when they absolutely lose it and start acting like dogs with rabies at the mere mention of Taylor's name Nnnn sistren what because ROL is literally one of the top 3 most impactful (and BEST) pop albums of all time I mean, we have nothing to worry about because Taylor has met (and exceeded) this twice now with 1989 and Folklore, but ROL will never be overrated, it's literally a masterclass in pop penmanship and production. Ray Of Light is the standard. 1 2
Timeless Posted January 5 Posted January 5 3 hours ago, Cleanromantic said: "Timeless (Taylor's Version) [From The Vault]" by Taylor Swift was produced by Taylor Swift & Jack Antonoff. I made my ATRL account months before Speak Now (Taylor's Version) even came out, actually.
Cleanromantic Posted January 5 Posted January 5 50 minutes ago, 1989 said: Nnnn sistren what because ROL is literally one of the top 3 most impactful (and BEST) pop albums of all time I mean, we have nothing to worry about because Taylor has met (and exceeded) this twice now with 1989 and Folklore, but ROL will never be overrated, it's literally a masterclass in pop penmanship and production. Ray Of Light is the standard. Spoiler I've never been impressed by madonna's lyrics tbh . They all come off as generic to me. She could be singing about the most profound topic and she always ends up using the most obvious choices, to the point I can guess the word she'll use based on the rhyme scheme .
Timeless Posted January 5 Posted January 5 3 hours ago, Buffy said: I agree with this review. Can we hear your thoughts on We Were Happy og vs Taylor's Version? We Were Happy production was made more sad in TV, but I don't think the change was that offensive tbh. Her vocal delivery is still the same so the emotion isn't lost at all, and the lyrics were kept the same. I think it was mostly faithfully recreated just more sad in tone. This is actually the strongest Fearless vault out of them all.
Timeless Posted January 5 Posted January 5 1 hour ago, 1989 said: Nnnn sistren what because ROL is literally one of the top 3 most impactful (and BEST) pop albums of all time I mean, we have nothing to worry about because Taylor has met (and exceeded) this twice now with 1989 and Folklore, but ROL will never be overrated, it's literally a masterclass in pop penmanship and production. Ray Of Light is the standard. One of us needs to change pfps I fear
Enrique523 Posted January 5 Posted January 5 12 hours ago, Timeless said: Life is so dull without a Taylor announcement. I feel so lethargic. I need my serotonin boost NOW. HELP ME TAYLOR PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Taylor has really spoiled us too much these last 5 years, we can't function normaly anymore 12 hours ago, Catch22 said: The way she never performed it live Wait that's true, i can't believe i never realized it
Recommended Posts