charts discussion Longest charting ex-acts projects on Billboard 200

[ariananext]

2 minutes ago, RULES said:

THIS! 
 

Don’t listen to that stan she’s always doing the most!

cute that you know so much about me, who even are you? 

[Leigh]

2 minutes ago, RULES said:

Guilty pleasure made no noise? 

No it did not. Her team sabotaged the entire release. Very unfortunate considering it’s a very good pop-rock album and Tell Me Lies could’ve been a cute little hit.

[Leigh]

5 minutes ago, RULES said:

THIS! 
 

Don’t listen to that stan she’s always doing the most!

Leave my good sis @ariananextalone. She’s nice and probably spent a good 20 minutes finding the data for the OP. There’s no reason why she should put artists like Ashley or Vanessa next to the ones she listed. 

 

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

11 minutes ago, Samsom said:

Ex-acts is referred to the artists that were on a Disney/Nick show. This list has no sense without including Hilary, Lindsay, Vanessa, Ashley that were the blue prints of the term ex-act. The same with Bridgit 

So we should also include Britney, Xtina and Justin and many more lol? then it will be very different.

Edited April 6, 2021 by duybeeGAshantiGA

[ariananext]

2 minutes ago, Leigh said:

Leave my good sis @ariananextalone. She’s nice and probably spent a good 20 minutes finding the data for the OP. There’s no reason why she should put artists like Ashley or Vanessa next to the ones she listed. 

 

 

2 minutes ago, duybeeGAshantiGA said:

So we should also include Britney, Xtina and Justin and many more? then it will be very different.

this, we all know the ex acts we talk of nowadays are them 4

 

 

 

you can make a thread about the club of underdogs or something 

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

1 minute ago, ariananext said:

 

this, we all know the ex acts we talk of nowadays are them 4

 

 

 

 

you can make a thread about the club of underdogs or something 

not underdogs 

Edited April 6, 2021 by duybeeGAshantiGA

[Julia Fox]

2 minutes ago, duybeeGAshantiGA said:

So we should also include Britney, Xtina and Justin and many more? then it will be very different.

We should. The same with Jonas Brothers, Nick Jonas and Joe Jonas. But I guess the term is so missinterpreted in the stan world and the user that made this topic didn't even know what ex-act means so... I can't ask for more

[Leigh]

Just now, ariananext said:

you can make a thread about the club of underdogs or something 

Literally. People are delulu for expecting you to put Ashley and Vanessa there. What’s next, Bridgit Mendler and Miranda Cosgrove?

 

[Robburro]

Wait how tf Kiss&Tell charted for so long

[Julia Fox]

Just now, Leigh said:

Literally. People are delulu for expecting you to put Ashley and Vanessa there. What’s next, Bridgit Mendler and Miranda Cosgrove?

 

They are ex acts but I guess the GP only cares for them. Maybe in the next years Ariana, Selena, Demi and Miley will never be ex acts because their Disney/Nick days are far away and the new Gen will not know them bc of her Disney/Nick shows like its happening with Hilary, Lindsay, Bridgit, Vanessa and Ashley 

[ariananext]

Just now, Samsom said:

We should. The same with Jonas Brothers, Nick Jonas and Joe Jonas. But I guess the term is so missinterpreted in the stan world and the user that made this topic didn't even know what ex-act means so... I can't ask for more

you do realize that there are so many threads about ex acts on ATRL and they never include anybody other than those 4 right? 

 

 

 

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/347538-the-ex-acts-all-came-through-within-the-past-year/

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/347764-hot-100-top-20-biggest-songs-by-ex-acts/

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/345508-is-next-week-demis-time-to-be-the-final-ex-act-to-go-1/

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/342501-402-spotify-ex-acts-singles-with-best-recurrent-streams/

[Leigh]

1 minute ago, Samsom said:

They are ex acts but I guess the GP only cares for them. Maybe in the next years Ariana, Selena, Demi and Miley will never be ex acts because their Disney/Nick days are far away and the new Gen will not know them bc of her Disney/Nick shows like its happening with Hilary, Lindsay, Bridgit, Vanessa and Ashley 

At least Bridgit has the benefit of getting viral tweets for Hurricane and Ready Or Not every month. She won in comparison to the rest if we’re talking music.

 

[Julia Fox]

Just now, ariananext said:

you do realize that there are so many threads about ex acts on ATRL and they never include anybody other than those 4 right? 

 

 

 

 

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/347538-the-ex-acts-all-came-through-within-the-past-year/

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/347764-hot-100-top-20-biggest-songs-by-ex-acts/

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/345508-is-next-week-demis-time-to-be-the-final-ex-act-to-go-1/

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/342501-402-spotify-ex-acts-singles-with-best-recurrent-streams/

Yes I know but having Atrl like a soucre about everything is but well I'm not criticizing. It's not anyone's fault. 

[MatiasCc18]

I don't want to sound like a hater but ... I find it offensive not to play Hilary Duff when she was literally the pioneer of exs-act and has sold more records than Selena and Demi.
I am not talking about Britney and Xtina since they did not have a series (they did not act) and their music was after Disney.
But let's be clear, without Hilary Duff there would be no Hanna, no Wizzard or anything

[Michael196]

Bridgit Mendler’s Hello My Name Is... spent 22 weeks on the chart, and 42 weeks on the album sales chart!

[KetysandGagsSon]

Ariana leading with Miley. The others are NOT close.

[MikeyDuff1D]

The fact that Hilary would still be in the top 10 even after 18 years

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

21 hours ago, Kings. said:

Why is Sweetener here twice with a different number of weeks

It's an Arianator, so not the brightest pea in the pod.

OT: Selena legend!

[ariananext]

On 4/7/2021 at 8:03 PM, ithinkheknowsoutsold said:

It's an Arianator, so not the brightest pea in the pod.

OT: Selena legend!

personal attacks now? 

[SwiftLover]

Y’all need to add “female” to the title because Drake is also an EX-act 

[DaddyIssuesX]

On 4/7/2021 at 4:43 AM, MatiasCc18 said:

I don't want to sound like a hater but ... I find it offensive not to play Hilary Duff when she was literally the pioneer of exs-act and has sold more records than Selena and Demi.
I am not talking about Britney and Xtina since they did not have a series (they did not act) and their music was after Disney.
But let's be clear, without Hilary Duff there would be no Hanna, no Wizzard or anything

Selena and Demi have sold more than hilary 

[MatiasCc18]

Just now, DaddyIssuesX said:

Selena and Demi have sold more than hilary 

hilary sold more than 15m before her 20th birthday

[Dingdong123]

Britney, Xtina and JT are also ex acts where are they?

[ariananext]

4 minutes ago, Dingdong123 said:

Britney, Xtina and JT are also ex acts where are they?

 

39 minutes ago, SwiftLover said:

Y’all need to add “female” to the title because Drake is also an EX-act 

when we talk ex acts on atrl it's always those 4, it was already discussed in this thread 

[Doogle]

Why is everyone acting brand new in this thread  ex-act has always been used here to refer to the 3 00s Disney girls and then in more recent times Ariana too

 

OT cool list OP! Some nice surprises like Yours Truly  

Edited April 13, 2021 by Doogle