Staryu Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 A. P!nk - Try A quality song, but still a P!nk song, it's good though B. Doja Cat - Say So Amazing, catchy song C. Rihanna - Man Down Not one of my Rih faves but I like its vibe D. Beyoncé - Countdown One of Bey's best tbh E. Tove Lo - Disco **** A bop F. Dua Lipa - Physical Song of the decade so far G. Mariah Carey - My All Yas vocals but kinda boring
shelven Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 A. P!nk - Try This is definitely one of P!nk's better singles and I loved it back in 2013, but like... there's a LOT of strong competition this round and I'm not sure this competes. B. Doja Cat - Say So It's a cute and fun song, although I will say I think this has been massively overhyped by ATRL and the GP. C. Rihanna - Man Down One of my favourite Rih singles EVER, ahhh. Love this song, the way the GP paid it dust is disgusting. D. Beyoncé - Countdown ANOTHER song that's one of my fav from the artist and that the GP disgustingly paid dust. So good. E. Tove Lo - Disco **** This is honestly one of Tove's best songs despite the weirdness. The hook is INSANELY catchy. F. Dua Lipa - Physical We love it. We stan it. 2020 AOTY artist did that. G. Mariah Carey - My All This is pretty but it's not doing much for me, especially after I was slayed by like the previous 4 entries in a row.
Touch It Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 A. P!nk - Try i’ll listen later B. Doja Cat - Say So bop C. Rihanna - Man Down I like it D. Beyoncé - Countdown winner E. Tove Lo - Disco **** i wish i took it when i had the opportunity to hm F. Dua Lipa - Physical bop G. Mariah Carey - My All she’s toast
miguel Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 CRITIQUES P!nk - Try ahhhhh, yup yup. one of Pink's best for sure and such a beautiful ****ing song overall. The lyrics >>>>> Doja Cat - Say So Honestly, i just don't care for this song. The only part i enjoy is the rapped part. The rest is mediocre at best. MV is great tho. Rihanna - Man Down yup yup yup, a BOP. love the vibe! Beyoncé - Countdown AHHHHHHH, this CLASSIC, YUP YUP Great ****ing entry Tove Lo - Disco **** this issa bop but it's also one of Tove's weaker singles and is also weak in comparison to most entries this round. Still love it tho Dua Lipa - Physical okay, i see you this issa BOP, whew Mariah Carey - My All very cute, really pretty ballad. P!nk outsold and outtalented tho! ---- Overall REALLY strong round and definitely the best so far. Great job y'all Spoiler @Element @rl231 @Staryu @Clueless @thecptz @Touch It @shelven
clue Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 A. P!nk - Try Yuck ma. B. Doja Cat - Say So Very overrated. The definition of basic. It's not bad at all, though. C. Rihanna - Man Down Never cared for this that much. D. Beyoncé - Countdown Yup yup yup. A classic. E. Tove Lo - Disco **** It's okay. Never was a fan. F. Dua Lipa - Physical One of the best songs of the year. G. Mariah Carey - My All So ****ing good. Maybe my favorite Mariah song.
Touch It Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 Just now, shelven said: I think we should ALL ignore clueless okay man down sender
shelven Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 Just now, Touch It said: okay man down sender What are you talking about, I sent P!nk, my critique was meant to be a misdirection
ATRL Moderator Element Posted March 23, 2020 ATRL Moderator Posted March 23, 2020 A. P!nk - Try - I enjoyed this song enough back when it was released but it's not really something I'd listen to in the modern day B. Doja Cat - Say So - Such a strategic choice given the Doja hype rn... this is such a spring/summer feel-good anthem! love C. Rihanna - Man Down - I feel like you had a lot of other Rihanna choices that could have been more impactful. It's an inch resting song D. Beyoncé - Countdown - Absolute classic that has stood the test of time a decade later! E. Tove Lo - Disco **** - Tove is so freaking weird but this is a bop that is for sure x F. Dua Lipa - Physical - I mean it's my #1 most played song of 2020 sooooo G. Mariah Carey - My All - cute, got me ready for bed time
Navyofbadgals Posted March 23, 2020 Author Posted March 23, 2020 Bagels' Critiques re: judges; please send A. P!nk - Try chile.. anways. Don't like pink and this song, whilst not awful, really isn't doing a lot for me either B. Doja Cat - Say So Really nice! I know ms. Miguel didn't just say that he only found the rapping parts good, when that chorus is heavenly C. Rihanna - Man Down I was surprised by the mixed reaction and then i wasn't.. kinda blame the muricans! Us Europeans appreciate this D. Beyoncé - Countdown very good song obvs, i got kinda tired of it overtime but yes it's still great, and great vocal delivery E. Tove Lo - Disco **** A bop, one of her best F. Dua Lipa - Physical SOTD FROM AOTD!! G. Mariah Carey - My All eh whatever. Not bad, not amazing Spoiler @Element @rl231 @Staryu @Clueless @thecptz @Touch It @shelven @Astronomy @touya kinomoto
touya kinomoto Posted March 23, 2020 Posted March 23, 2020 scores sent. will send critiques begote i hit the sack
touya kinomoto Posted March 24, 2020 Posted March 24, 2020 TOUYA'S CRITIQUES A. P!nk - Try i don't have negative to say about this song and i still prefer blow me (one last kiss) as the better single from this album but the round is so stacked that i don't see this even in the middle of the pack. B. Doja Cat - Say So ignore miguel. she drinks. but srsly, this is a great song. miss doja cat is really giving the gays what they want huh? C. Rihanna - Man Down those who are giving this a bad critique are plain tasteless. there i've said it. this is one of rih's best songs. top 5 in ha discography if we are being tasteful here. D. Beyoncé - Countdown if man down is one of rih's best, this song is definitely one of bey's best. a highlight in a great album and bey's immaculate discography. bow down to the queen! E. Tove Lo - Disco **** ahh, miss love to. at least this season did not end with disappointing track from ha. remember when they sent tracks from sunshine kitty? me neither. this is the tove that i love. F. Dua Lipa - Physical that 1-2-3-4-5 from doja to dua. loves it. anyhow, i prefer don't start now over this but this is still such a strong song. future nostalgia should have been zula lapeep's teenage dream. too bad america is tasteless. see: man down, countdown and disco **** for further proof. G. Mariah Carey - My All this round is kinda weird because it's bookended by okay songs with amazing songs in between. this song suffers the same fate as try. it's not a bad song but there are such strong songs in this round that it falls behind. Spoiler @Element @rl231 @Staryu @Clueless @thecptz @Touch It @shelven @Astronomy @touya kinomoto
touya kinomoto Posted March 24, 2020 Posted March 24, 2020 not me and astro posting almost at the same time with almost the same critiques sksksk
touya kinomoto Posted March 24, 2020 Posted March 24, 2020 Just now, Astronomy said: our minds, honestly we've got the minds of masterminds kjsdfnhksjf for real plus our taste is
ATRL Moderator Element Posted March 24, 2020 ATRL Moderator Posted March 24, 2020 the way p!nk and mariah got universally panned
Navyofbadgals Posted March 24, 2020 Author Posted March 24, 2020 Live results in 12 minutes from now, and a new round after that if the winner is quick, so get in xxx Spoiler @Element @rl231 @Staryu @Clueless @thecptz @Touch It @shelven @Navyofbadgals @touya kinomoto @Disruptive @prézli @Astronomy
Navyofbadgals Posted March 24, 2020 Author Posted March 24, 2020 START POSTING!! WE'RE STARTING THE RIHSULTS Spoiler @Element @rl231 @Staryu @Clueless @thecptz @Touch It @shelven @Navyofbadgals @touya kinomoto @Disruptive @prézli @Astronomy
Recommended Posts