Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 (edited) but hope u guys see our point tbh it 's not coz im lazy af i even had the spreadsheet (the master sheet that's only viewable by me) updated with the critiques lol me too, im waiting for the critiques and i think waiting til Wednesday is fair enough for the panel xoxo Edited May 15, 2019 by Yvess
thecptz Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 2 minutes ago, Yvess said: but hope u guys see our point tbh it 's not coz im lazy af i even had the spreadsheet updated with the critiques lol me too, im waiting for the critiques and i think waiting til Wednesday is fair enough for the panel xoxo we understand you xoxo
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 15 hours ago, thecptz said: we understand you xoxo i'll post my critiques without the scores rn... plz bear with me as I format it.
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 YVESS' CRITIQUES ON note: I really intend to have all of the judges' critiques be posted all at once but since you guys wanted me to PTC, i'll post mine. I removed my scores so that it will be revealed by the time I do formal results. thanks. @KatyCatPH @Guero @PoKiTaurus @kiiwii @thecptz @Solarie @EriKills @Overprotected KatyCatPH - Taylor Swift Taylor Swift reputation Stadium Tour | Official Trailer Spoiler Kudos for going in a different direction in interpreting this round. I like that you used a clip that shows Taylor as a powerful touring artist. My only concern though is since it is a trailer, it gives me a half-empty,half full experience in getting to know your artist. Guero - Ariana Grande Ariana Grande - Imagine (LIVE) Spoiler This performance really showed us her vocal range! The only thing that I noticed is that she looks shy at some parts, she's killing it so I wanted to see a more confident Ariana. PoKiTaurus - Mariah Carey Mariah Carey - Emotions (From Mariah Carey (Live)) Spoiler SLAY! You had a rough first choice but your final choice for this round is totally one of the best! The way Mariah sings it effortlessly and her audience being so engaged with her presence is something that not every girls can have. The whistles made me forget Ariana's performance. kiiwii- Katy Perry Katy Perry- California Gurls (Super Bowl 2015) Spoiler This is absolutely a smart choice. Katy is not the vocal powerhouse legend like Mimi or Adele but what she has is the TOTAL STAGE PRESENCE. Her command on stage in this performance is phenomenal, she gave it her 100% and the fans loved it. thecptz - Kacey Musgraves Kacey Musgraves - High Horse - Live at Coachella 2019 Spoiler I love High Horse and I love Kacey's beauty. I pointed out her beauty because in this performance, I can't stop but appreciate how beautiful this yeehaw queen is. My only problem in this performance is that I don't see her fully enjoying the moment. IDK maybe it's just me but the moment the granny steps in, she stole the spotlight. Solarie - Avril Lavigne Avril Lavigne - Girlfriend (LIVE) Spoiler Avril is my fave and I know she is not the pop goddess when she performs so I give you points for sending an actual video of her enjoying Girlfriend live. What I just noticed is that she's not 100% giving her all in this performance, there are parts wherein she's a 10, sometimes a 7. Overprotected - Björk Björk - Human Behaviour(Live at Royal Opera House) Spoiler I think this is a decent choice for an edgy artist like Bjork. She is a good storyteller in this performance, it is engaging to her audience so it is a great thing to notice. I don't see myself watching this video again coz this video made me feel that I'd rather listen to her than watch her. EriKills - Tinashe Tinashe - All Hands on Deck (Live at CONAN) Spoiler She looks so promising in this video. Gives me a Britney+Beyonce baby we did not deserve. Her dancing is more highlighted in this video than her vocal range and that's a great thing. If I don't know her, I will think that she can become a Beyonce heir to the throne.
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 sorry for the rushed formatting. hopefully i can collect all of the critiques tom.
Guero Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 I really wanted to showcase her vocal ability rather than all-around performing ability. I'll save the full performance video for when that round arrives.
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 YVESS' CRITIQUES ON note: I really intend to have all of the judges' critiques be posted all at once but since you guys wanted me to PTC, i'll post mine. I removed my scores so that it will be revealed by the time I do formal results. thanks. @Psycho @Queen Conchita @rooby.booby @lhdang2000 @Moonlightbae @Invisibility @Loyalty @Alena Psycho - Lady Gaga Lady Gaga - Paparazzi (Live At VMAs) Spoiler Shock factor is Lady Gaga's middle name.I love this iconic performance! Her vocals, choreo and styling are all on point. It was a moment to remember. My only concern is for your future rounds, you brought this out so early, it makes me fear that you set the bar high on yourself already. Queen Conchita - Conchita Wurst Conchita Wurst - Rise Like A Phoenix (LIVE) Spoiler There's something about Conchita that makes casual viewers like me stop for a second and see what she can bring to the table. This is a great choice to start your journey in representing your fave. rooby.booby - Kesha Kesha - Praying (Live) Spoiler I think you went with this entry coz of the vocal power about to ensue in this round. I like this song but I find this specific performance a bit lacking. I sense a disconnect with her as a viewer. This is an ok choice though. lhdang2000 - Adele Adele - I Found A Boy Spoiler The raw talent jumped out! I love her vocals in this and you made us remember that she can play musical instruments too. SLAY! Moonlightbae - Demi Lovato Demi Lovato - Stone Cold (BB Women of Music LIVE) Spoiler This is a good song to showcase her vocal range, love the styling and the emotional look on her face. James Charles learn!!! Invisibility - Madonna Madonna - Live To Tell (Confessions Tour) Spoiler Madonna is someone that can wow us with her visuals that sometimes we forget her vocals. Showcasing her vocals might be the direction you chose and I give you points for that but this performance has no replay value in it. Loyalty - Christina Aguilera Christina Aguilera - It's A Man's World [live] Spoiler It is one of the performances from her that you either love it or hate it. Xtina sometimes overdoes her vocals that I find it as an utter noise. Good thing, your video showed restraint in her vocals. She is indeed a voice of a generation.. Alena - Selena Gomez The many talents of Selena Gomez Spoiler A for Effort! I like that you went on a different direction same with KatyCatPH. The only thing that I find concerning is I found myself laughing at the unnecessary showcase of other talents. I based my score for the singing parts and I guess she has the potential to change my mind that she's just a whispering goddess.
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 YVESS' CRITIQUES ON note: I really intend to have all of the judges' critiques be posted all at once but since you guys wanted me to PTC, i'll post mine. I removed my scores so that it will be revealed by the time I do formal results. thanks. @fiercE@Boys @Touch It @Lukey@Not Like The Movies@Bawdee @Pendulum @PinkBox fiercE - Måns Zelmerlöw Opening revue with Petra Mede | Semifinal Spoiler This is a risky choice at first glance coz it is a duet but as I watched it, it highlightened your artist's expertise in the theatrical genre. And im ngl, I dunno him before this game so it is a great start to introduce me to this daddy. Boys - Britney Spears Britney Spears - Toxic (Best Performance!) HD Spoiler I actually stan Britney's ITZ era and this video made me wonder if she's singing live or not. I gave ha the benefit of the doubt. I love her total stage presence, she's indeed a performer. Her dancing skills can hold a candle to Janet's. I also love her acapella teaser of Everytime. Touch It - Beyonce Beyoncé - Crazy In Love Live at the Super Bowl Spoiler ICONIQUE. Mama delivered and obliterated our faves with this bombshell performance. Lukey - Ciara Ciara - Level Up W/ Missy Elliott (Live At The AMAs '18) Spoiler When I first watched it before, I knew CiCi was done poorly by the music industry. She didnt deserve to flop with her TABS, now judging this entry - I love the energy! The thing that somehow made me not fully love it is that Missy somehow took the spotlight on some parts. But nonetheless, you're in to a good start. Not Like The Movies - Janelle Monae Janelle Monae - Make Me Feel (The Voice) Spoiler This video made me love her more as a performer. Always found her amazing in the way she serves visuals and vocals and this video embodies that brand of her. Bawdee - Rihanna Rihanna - Love on the Brain (BBMA Performance) Spoiler VOCALS on point! Attitude on point! Her stage presence in this video is not the typical RiRi that graviates you to be asking for more though. Pendulum - Grimes Grimes - Genesis (Live at Lollapalooza 2016) Spoiler It was interesting but I think Grimes is known for her artistic visuals and unique sound but that video didn't embodies that so well. I liked how the crowd responded to her in this performance. PinkBox - Celine DionCeline Dion - All By Myself (Billboard Awards 1997) Spoiler This video is old but that's something I expected from you ofc. JK! She served vocals as usual, i live. Celine has a strong stage presence usually, I'm not quite sure if this video captured it though.
Lukey Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 3 minutes ago, Yvess said: Missy somehow took the spotlight on some parts. a 30 second verse which barely did anything stealing the spotlight eye-
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 15 hours ago, Lukey said: a 30 second verse which barely did anything stealing the spotlight eye- when u see my score on ur entry, let's talk xoxo
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 i came to realize that @Lukey was Luke? from Queen of the Flops S2 who represented Ciara too I guess?
Lukey Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 5 minutes ago, Yvess said: i came to realize that @Lukey was Luke? from Queen of the Flops S2 who represented Ciara too I guess? nope
boys Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 Anything other than complete and utter stanning for that STUN performance will not be tolerated @Yvess I will be removing myself from the competition! If the rest of the critiques are not 100% stanning
Yvess Posted May 15, 2019 Author Posted May 15, 2019 7 minutes ago, Lukey said: nope I see. 2 minutes ago, Boys said: Anything other than complete and utter stanning for that STUN performance will not be tolerated @Yvess I will be removing myself from the competition! If the rest of the critiques are not 100% stanning Don't worry im a generous judge xoxo
PinkBox Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 Just now, Invisibility said: Welp a mixed critique It's what she deserves
Invisibility Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 Just now, PinkBox said: It's what she deserves I thot you were supposed to support Madge/me, hag
PinkBox Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 3 minutes ago, Invisibility said: I thot you were supposed to support Madge/me, hag I support Madge, but dragging whales is more important
Invisibility Posted May 15, 2019 Posted May 15, 2019 1 minute ago, PinkBox said: I support Madge, but dragging whales is more important @Navyofbadgals isn't in this though?
.thumb.gif.018912544cc5638eccd695a87c978b14.gif)
Recommended Posts