rate SOFT LANDINGS of '23/'24 Rate | Deadline: May 10th

[Saddy]

Welcome to the "Soft Landings of '23/'24" where we gonna rate sofunique albums by sounique girls - Doja Cat, Kacey Musgraves, Dua Lipa and Megan Thee Stallion.

We gonna rate only standard version of the studio albums, so I apologize if you hoped to see and rate deluxe songs (maybe next time).

If you have any questions, feel free to ask!

 

 

Rules

Rate each song from 1 to 10. Decimals are allowed but only to 1 decimal place (7.8 is fine, but 7.82 is not).

You can give each album 11 but only ONCE (example, if u gave 'Attention' from 'Scarlet' 11, u can't give other song from this album another 11).

You can give ONE 0 but only ONCE (example, if u gave 'Attention' from 'Scarlet' 0, u can't give any other album 0).

Rate only songs that are on the list.

Comments are optional.

Send your ballot to me via DM (pls copy and paste the list below).

 

Song List

Spoiler

Scarlet
Paint the Town Red
Demons
Wet ******
**** the Girls (FTG)
Ouchies
97
Gun
Go Off
Agora Hills
Can't Wait
Often
Love Life
Skull and Bones
Attention
Balut
Shutcho
WYM Freestyle

 

Deeper Well
Cardinal
Deeper Well
Too Good to Be True
Moving Out
Giver / Taker
Sway
Dinner with Friends
Heart of the Woods
Jade Green
The Architect
Lonely Millionaire
Heaven Is
Anime Eyes
Nothing to Be Scared Of

 

Radical Optimism
End of an Era
Houdini
Training Season
These Walls
Whatcha Doing
French Exit
Illusion
Falling Forever
Anything for Love
Maria
Happy for You

 

Megan
Hiss
Rattle
Figueroa
Where Them Girls At
Broke His Heart
B.A.S.
Otaku Hot Girl
Find Out
Boa
Mamushi
Accent
Paper Together 
Spin

Down Stairs DJ

Miami Blue

Worthy

Moody Girl

Cobra

Deadline: May 10th

[Saddy]

Participants

Spoiler

1. @Saddy

Results

Spoiler

What was that? Emm... James?

 

Edited Tuesday at 11:53 PM by Saddy

[makeawish]

i'm in, i think the only one i don't know at all is megan and i can give that a listen.

 

is the concept a nice way of saying that they were all big artists who flopped a bit?

[Saddy]

8 minutes ago, makeawish said:

is the concept a nice way of saying that they were all big artists who flopped a bit?

Maybe 

[Suilen]

I'll do this once I'm back from my break in about 2 weeks.

[Saddy]

6 minutes ago, Suilen said:

I'll do this once I'm back from my break in about 2 weeks.

Do it when you can, no rush 

[PokiTails]

Hey  Ooh, Unexpected rate! Deadline Is Nice. I'll Inject Some Mellow "Yawn", "Zzz" comments and Entirely Round scores. Okay, will send soon!

[MP2K]

I'm a Down Stairs DJ advocate! 

[Quicksand]

Count me in!

[Relampago.]

I've listened to all these so it should be easy to rate! I'm in  

 

Spoiler

deeper well was like a feather of a soft landing compared to scarlet/megan/radical optimism that were like golf balls and baseball sized landings dd

 

[Saddy]

12 hours ago, PokiTails said:

Hey  Ooh, Unexpected rate! Deadline Is Nice. I'll Inject Some Mellow "Yawn", "Zzz" comments and Entirely Round scores. Okay, will send soon!

Everyone are against you when it's related to the rates, but I welcome you with the open arms 

[Ace Reject]

14 hours ago, makeawish said:

i'm in, i think the only one i don't know at all is megan and i can give that a listen.

 

is the concept a nice way of saying that they were all big artists who flopped a bit?

Yes! "A bit" - but not 143 or whatever that Shawn Mendes album will be!

[makeawish]

3 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Yes! "A bit" - but not 143 or whatever that Shawn Mendes album will be!

had honestly thought about whether we could have an actual 23/24 flops rate with 143, diamonds and dancefloor, c,xoxo, this is me...now and yeah we can throw shawn in as well. not sure it's wise to unleash atrl on that tho, just relentless savagery for weeks, the servers wouldn't stand up to it

[Ace Reject]

1 minute ago, makeawish said:

had honestly thought about whether we could have an actual 23/24 flops rate with 143, diamonds and dancefloor, c,xoxo, this is me...now and yeah we can throw shawn in as well. not sure it's wise to unleash atrl on that tho, just relentless savagery for weeks, the servers wouldn't stand up to it

This is Me... Now v. c, xoxo v. Dopamine v. 143? Sounds like hell (and a hit) to me!

[Saddy]

6 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

This is Me... Now v. c, xoxo v. Dopamine v. 143? Sounds like hell (and a hit) to me!

It is a hit, but the real question is if ppl actually will participate in it? 

[makeawish]

2 hours ago, Saddy said:

It is a hit, but the real question is if ppl actually will participate in it? 

you have to tag the stanbases in, they'll come to defend their girls and tear everyone else to shreds, it'll be brutal but it'll do numbers

[Saddy]

14 minutes ago, makeawish said:

you have to tag the stanbases in, they'll come to defend their girls and tear everyone else to shreds, it'll be brutal but it'll do numbers

Okay, maybe we should do this if Ace approves it 

[Ewan Chaos]

You know I'm in, even though I think I hate 2 of these albums and am lukewarm about the other 2!

[Saddy]

[MP2K]

I don't have a distaste for any of these, really.

[PokiTails]

On 4/2/2025 at 10:21 AM, Saddy said:

It is a hit, but the real question is if ppl actually will participate in it? 

I would 

[makeawish]

i'd be forced to defend camila, at least in the scores (i have a weak constitution and would have to opt out of the stan battles, would expect plenty of blood and hair tho)