base talk Bigger classic: Crazy In Love or Poker Face?

[monster_enriquer]

4 hours ago, zoldyck said:

And just like that spotify charts updated and:

 

188. Poker Face: 1.277M 

 

 

1 hour ago, Pop Art said:

The Hive saying we have to ignore sales and streams.  Fine, then let's look at how each actually charted.

 

Poker Face

  Reveal hidden contents

Hot 100

Weeks at #1: 1

Weeks in Top 10: 18

Charting Weeks: 40

 

UK Charts

Weeks at #1: 3

Weeks in Top 10: 13

Charting Weeks: 84

 

Countries It Went #1: 25

Countries It Went Top 10: 35

 

Year End #1s: 7

Year End Top 10s: 15

 

Crazy In Love

  Reveal hidden contents

Hot 100

Weeks at #1: 8

Weeks in Top 10: 16

Charting Weeks: 27

 

UK Charts

Weeks at #1: 3

Weeks in Top 10: 6

Charting Weeks: 19

 

Countries It Went #1: 5

Countries It Went Top 10: 23

Year End #1s: 0

Year End Top 10s: 1

I'm not sure how much more proof the Hive needs, but the answer is glaringly obvious: they're both career defining smashes, but Poker Face is still notably bigger.

Well, Stats are here. Objectively, PF is bigger. Both are career-defining classics tho

[Funnyfatty]

Isn't hive the only fanbase who uses the term IMPACT on every debate they are about to lose? What kind of an impact does a pop song like CIL have?  

 

its huge and iconic but please pokerface is one of the biggest tracks to exist. 
 

real humans don't even consider CIL as beyonces biggest classic. Halo and Telephone exist  

Spoiler

Which is outstreaming clown in love 

 

[superben]

Globally, it's PF. No competition at all.

[NEUTRON]

Shade... knowing damn well it shouldve been Crazy in Love vs Just Dance or Baby Boy vs Pokerface

 

Anywho.... Crazy in Love

Edited 1 hour ago by NEUTRON

[PerfectCure]

Obviously Poker Face what are you all on. Crazy In Love should be compared with the likes of Just Dance/Pon De Replay

[lillavend3r]

5 hours ago, mxoonlight said:

Upgrade U is the best Bey/Jay collab.

Fixed!

 

OP: PF for all

[longjohn9898]

Crazy in Love is a great song but Poker Face is bigger and better. There hasn't been another song like Poker Face since it was released and probably never will be. The hook is undeniably infectious and it's a global supersmash and one of the biggest selling singles of all time for a reason. Gaga slipping "f your face" into the hook is genius that will never be duplicated and we're not even getting into her acoustic piano versions which completely reinvented the song as she usually does 

[Fleahive]

The one that went #1 for 8 weeks

The one that is played in every public setting since the date of release for over 2 decades

The one that isn't being boosted by autoplay due to hype from a Bruno Mars collab. 

This website is beyond delusional lol. The first 2 seconds of CIL is recognizable. Can't say the same for the other. 

Edited 1 hour ago by Fleahive

[Oktober Knight]

Crazy in Love, there is no question.

[futuresuperstar2023]

Delusional AF. It's crazy in love and always will be. Also it's hilarious that one user said that Crazy in love should be compared to Just dance or pon de replay. UMM that would throw just dance and pon de replay in the river as well. Crazy in love made Bey a solo star and the horns are iconic.

[futuresuperstar2023]

4 minutes ago, Fleahive said:

The one that went #1 for 8 weeks

The one that is played in every public setting since the date of release for over 2 decades

The one that isn't being boosted by autoplay due to hype from a Bruno Mars collab. 

This website is beyond delusional lol. The first 2 seconds of CIL is recognizable. Can't say the same for the other. 

I don't want to say it but it's obvious why they are saying what they are saying. Everybody have different opinions but saying Crazy in love a huge classic song should be more compared to Pon de Replay is proof of that condiment 

[UnderratedVocalist]

Who gives a **** about charts and stats that can be manipulated? The real world is where these things are determined. If you go out and Crazy in Love is on, literally 95% of the people know it and they can actually tell it's the song from the first 5 seconds.

 

Poker Face is NOT a classic.

[dumbsparce]

The ma-ma-ma-mas literally reset the universe. CIL is a classic too but it wasn't anything other than just a big hit.