base talk Where do you rank Bey, Gaga, Ari as vocalists?

[Riverbank]

Putting Gaga above Ariana is like admitting u lack any sort of musicality and u think theatrics = better vocalist   Most stans are so out of touch. Ariana is leagues above Gaga as a vocalist and her voice is much stronger. Gaga's voice is kinda unpleasant and offputting. She is still amazing, but nowhere near Ariana or Bey.

[landof0oo]

40 minutes ago, Lovett said:

Sorry, now you're moving on to pretending one of the highest selling female artists in history isn't popular?  Whose mediocre dupe account are you?  This is tragic trolling.

I'm sure cowboy carter is undeniable proof of her global pop status today. 😂

 

Anyway, enjoy her bagpipe sounding belts. 

 

 

[Mariano]

16 minutes ago, Riverbank said:

Putting Gaga above Ariana is like admitting u lack any sort of musicality and u think theatrics = better vocalist   Most stans are so out of touch. Ariana is leagues above Gaga as a vocalist and her voice is much stronger. Gaga's voice is kinda unpleasant and offputting. She is still amazing, but nowhere near Ariana or Bey.

Awhh hit a nerve? Okay how about your early 2000s relic'd fav? Where would u put her? Or you prefer to hide behind others? Are you ashamed of your fav or what is going on?   

 

 

Edited 16 hours ago by Mariano

[Shaner69]

1 hour ago, ChooseyLover said:

Beyoncé > Lady Gaga > Ariana

Beyonce and Araina have excellent voices. Don't pull that. 

[ChooseyLover]

33 minutes ago, Shaner69 said:

Beyonce and Araina have excellent voices. Don't pull that. 

I never said they didn't. But on the other hand you're implying Gaga doesn't.

[Lovett]

1 hour ago, landof0oo said:

I'm sure cowboy carter is undeniable proof of her global pop status today. 😂

 

Anyway, enjoy her bagpipe sounding belts. 

Convenient that you ignore her smash global hits and how hard Renaissance smashed and instead focus on her country album, which is credited for the massive country rise in several countries around the world and drastically improving visibility and opportunities for black artists in the genre.

 

But hey, keep pretending like you have anything to drag her incredible popularity and unmatched talent. Next time, sign back into your main account. Dupes are boring.

[Arthoe]

Bey, Gaga = Ari. 

 

Bey is the most developped vocalist out of all three.

 

For Gaga I think she can actually expand a bit up with the right training, I think she actually even could get a whistle register. Also Gaga's belts can become a bit shrill if she's above E#5, she can do it right but at the top of her range she is like only 70% consistent. Ariana's voice is really solid in the upper middle and upper parts of her register, but her lower register is a bit lacking and always a bit airy. I've rarely heard Ariana belt below C5 so like... I'm curious as to how far down she can support herself belting. 

 

Gaga has a REALLY impressive lower register, she can drop into the second octave at EASE and she has such a dark and rich tone in her lower register, while Ariana is known for her vocal acrobatics in the sixth and seventh octave and her belts around E5 to G#5 are basically unbeatable. 

Edited 15 hours ago by Arthoe

[ScorpiosGroove]

bey first, gaga last, as usual 

[landof0oo]

29 minutes ago, Lovett said:

Convenient that you ignore her smash global hits and how hard Renaissance smashed and instead focus on her country album, which is credited for the massive country rise in several countries around the world and drastically improving visibility and opportunities for black artists in the genre.

 

But hey, keep pretending like you have anything to drag her incredible popularity and unmatched talent. Next time, sign back into your main account. Dupes are boring.

lmfao that's a lot of pressed, empty words. 

 

Keep your replies coming! Your desperation is very entertaining.

 

Like I said, enjoy her bagpipe vocals, echo machines and fans 

 

 

[Erreur2 La Nature]

I voted for the third option which is : Beyoncé > Ariana > Lady Gaga.

 

Beyoncé is definitely first without any doubt, she's a good singer with impeccable technique eventhough she doesn't necessarily conveys emotions to me.

 

Then I would put Ariana because she is a great singer and consistent.

 

Lady Gaga goes last. She's undeniably a great singer too but her voice has changed so much since her debut, sometimes it sounds very irritating.

[gustavothehuman]

Bey > Ari > Gaga is objectively the correct answer.

[Kristie Kuwa]

All I know is:

 

Bey can sing any of Arianas or Gagas songs, but none of them could do a mix of Already - Virgos Groove - Formation.

Beyonces versatility is unmatched and peerless.

[Lovett]

59 minutes ago, landof0oo said:

lmfao that's a lot of pressed, empty words. 

 

Keep your replies coming! Your desperation is very entertaining.

 

Like I said, enjoy her bagpipe vocals, echo machines and fans 

Ahh, the usual reply when you can't disprove any of it. Thought as much.

[ABeyBraith]

Bey > Ari > Gaga. All are better than the vast majority of singers in the industry. 

[ariananext]

4 hours ago, Mariano said:

Putting Ariana above Gaga is like admitting u lack any sort of musicality and u think high note = better vocalist   Most stans are so out of touch. Gaga is leagues above Ari as a vocalist and her voice is much stronger. Ariana's voice is kinda thin and weak. She is still amazing, but nowhere near Gaga or Bey. 

 

 

You're trying to gaslight people here. Ariana is objectively the superior vocalist, she may be second to Beyoncé but she has no other rivals among pop girls. Ariana's voice is more pleasant, sounds healthier, effortless. Her low vocals were amazing in the Save Your Tears performance, just because she excels and is mostly praised for her high notes it doesn't mean you can downplay her range.

[Revolution]

Ari > Bey > Selena > Gaga

[Starshine]

Dupes in 2025 

[Mariano]

45 minutes ago, ariananext said:

You're trying to gaslight people here. Ariana is objectively the superior vocalist, she may be second to Beyoncé but she has no other rivals among pop girls. Ariana's voice is more pleasant, sounds healthier, effortless. Her low vocals were amazing in the Save Your Tears performance, just because she excels and is mostly praised for her high notes it doesn't mean you can downplay her range.

Ariana is not even close to Gaga, as I previously said. "Ariana's voice is more pleasant" uhm to whom? I know people irl who cannot stand Ariana's voice   Anyway that's where u lost the argument, cuz even if that subjective think was true in an objective way, it still doesn't make Ariana the better vocalist  

[Mariano]

32 minutes ago, Revolution said:

Ari > Bey > Selena > Gaga

Awhh and what about your fav?  it's always the same ones with the hasbeen'd favs.. 

[Welovetrouble]

5 hours ago, Mariano said:

Putting Ariana above Gaga is like admitting u lack any sort of musicality and u think high note = better vocalist   Most stans are so out of touch. Gaga is leagues above Ari as a vocalist and her voice is much stronger. Ariana's voice is kinda thin and weak. She is still amazing, but nowhere near Gaga or Bey. 

 

 

They think good singing is all about hitting high notes lol

[vuelve88]

26 minutes ago, Mariano said:

I know people irl who cannot stand Ariana's voice

 

Mariano and the people 

[DarkGa]

9 hours ago, Xtina23 said:

I have to agree!!

If I woke up to a lip synced half time show on Christmas Day, I would have unstanned then and there. Though, I guess they're used to it

[Mariano]

33 minutes ago, vuelve88 said:

 

Mariano and the people 

? Why is it such a hard thing to believe? I literally know people who can't stand voices like Ariana's especially during her 'yuh' era. I'm sure others know people who don't like her voice too. And it's funny cuz the only reason I mentioned that is cuz the other user was being subjective. Like I know ATRL-ers will be shocked, but the "Gaga has unpleasant voice" is not a thing outside of atrl and some of your favs who y'all think have very pleasant voices are often found to be annoying by people outside of this stan bubble. 

 

[UnderratedVocalist]

Beyonce >> Ariana = Gaga

[JO1s]

10 minutes ago, Mariano said:

? Why is it such a hard thing to believe? I literally know people who can't stand voices like Ariana's especially during her 'yuh' era. I'm sure others know people who don't like her voice too. And it's funny cuz the only reason I mentioned that is cuz the other user was being subjective. Like I know ATRL-ers will be shocked, but the "Gaga has unpleasant voice" is not a thing outside of atrl and some of your favs who y'all think have very pleasant voices are often found to be annoying by people outside of this stan bubble. 

 

Girl you're talking all about tone when ranking vocal's objectively is based off technique. Disliking someone's tone is completely subjective but how well they support their notes, their supported vocal range, breath control strain Ect are all objective.