base talk Madonna's best songs as rated on AOTY. Taste?

[VeniceBeach]

According to the AOTY community (albumoftheyear.org), these are Madonna's best songs. Did they serve taste and get it right?

1. Hung Up - 97
2. Frozen - 97
3. Like a Prayer - 96
4. Vogue - 96
5. Ray of Light - 96
6. Deeper and Deeper - 96
7. Sorry - 95
8. Drowned World / Substitute for Love - 94
9. Erotica - 94
10. Nothing Really Matters - 94
11. The Power of Good-Bye - 93
12. Take a Bow - 93
13. Swim - 93
14. La Isla Bonita - 93
15. Papa Don't Preach - 93
16. Human Nature - 93
17. Music - 93
18. Skin - 93
19. Sky Fits Heaven - 92
20. Bad Girl - 92

Full list (top 100): https://www.albumoftheyear.org/artist/2269-madonna/best-songs/

[Infatuation_Junkie]

Erotica in top 10 

[Wicked]

Madonna has an incredible singles catalog but that list is lacking in the album tracks department so no.

 

Justify My Love is top 5 Madonna, too. Lol.

[RideOrDie]

no forbidden love? invalid 

[PaloSanto]

it's pretty decent all things considered. Rain, Justify My Love, Nothing Fails, Don't Tell Me, Open Your Heart, are all missing tho

[pink lightning]

Jesus christ that truly is an immaculate list

And the fact that it's still missing at least 20 more complete gems

[Cruel Summer]

Nothing Really Matters is too low and What It Feels Like For a Girl should be there but it's a cute list 

[ICLDXU4HS]

Not 8 songs off OverRAYted of Light, ew.

[Venice B]

No Bedtime Story? No You'll See?

 

[unison stan]

solid list (even tho they're nearly all singles). hung up at #1 feels wrong tho

[RideOrDie]

7 minutes ago, ICLDXU4HS said:

Not 8 songs off OverRAYted of Light, ew.

repent

 

[ICLDXU4HS]

7 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

repent

 

Frozen is her #1 most overrayted song and The Power of Good-Bye in the 20 is especially unserious. Title track, maybe Drowned and a cute deep cut I can get behind.

 

[Draper.]

No Express Yourself? hm.

[RideOrDie]

7 minutes ago, ICLDXU4HS said:

Frozen is her #1 most overrayted song and The Power of Good-Bye in the 20 is especially unserious. Title track, maybe Drowned and a cute deep cut I can get behind.

 

to have and not to hold > the power of good-bye

 

 

[Roberto]

Hung Up #1 is just not that. Although an unpopular opinion, I missed Like A Virgin. 

[Mariano]

I agree with the top 3 tbh, but I would put Frozen at 1 or LaP. Hung Up would be #3 for me. 
 

 

[davidson]

Solid list but Into The Groove def should be in the TOP 20.

[MP3]

The entire Ray of Light album is almost there 

[Pikachoo]

Get Together is not #1, and neither Into The Groove nor Lucky Star are in the top 20 so NO.

[Magmar]

No Secret Garden? I disagree then.

[Illuminati]

I feel like seeing the lowest scores would be more interesting cause all of these are very easy to agree on

[tost1]

54 minutes ago, ICLDXU4HS said:

Not 8 songs off OverRAYted of Light, ew.

Babez, there should be 10 in the top 10

[Invisibility]

Sorry, Swim, Bad Girl, and specially Take a Bow don't really belong in a "best of" conversation

 

Glaring omissions are Justify My Love, Live to Tell and Into the Groove

[dzwiekolubny]

it's decent

[Suilen]

Deeper and Deeper in top 10