poll Who's the better actress: Gaga or Ariana?

[bjorn]

Which pop star turned actress do you think is the better of them two?
Lady Gaga or Ariana Grande? 

 

discuss 
 

 

[DirtyPony87]

Gaga could do Glinda. Ariana wouldn't have been able to pull off ASIB.

[Blade Runner]

They're both better than whatever raggedy b*tch you stan. 

[ICLDXU4HS]

Steffalee by a landslide.

[GraceRandolph]

Gaga could do Glinda or Elphaba. Ariana wouldn't have been able to pull off Lee Quinzel. 

[dumbsparce]

Twirls & swirls are not acting 

[Loca]

Ariana's approach to acting is as plastic as it gets. Gaga managed to get some interesting moments here and there. 

[Zaram]

Well, this one backfired.

Back to the drawing board.

 

[Space Cowboy]

18 minutes ago, DirtyPony87 said:

Gaga could do Glinda. Ariana wouldn't have been able to pull off ASIB.

?? ASIB was not a particularly challenging role to execute, Ariana could have done it.

 

Gaga didn't even do that well, her acting felt weak and wooden during the emotional moments of the film. It was clear that she isn't a particularly strong actor.

[longjohn9898]

Gaga. Ariana was OK as Glinda but too robotic and lacked the spontaneity and annoying, off the cuff personality that Glinda really encompasses. Gaga has shown her acting prowess across film and TV in several roles and her accolades support her quality as an actress. 

[Colmillo]

I feel like I've only seen Ariana do comedy, and most of her characters are in the same vein, I would like to see her do something different, so I'm gonna go with Gaga.

[EnigmaticAndroid]

Not falling for this one Bjorn

 

[AxelFox]

Have not seen Joker but Ariana in Wicked was far better than anything I've seen lady ga ga in so far. 

[Johnny Jacobs]

2 hours ago, dumbsparce said:

Twirls & swirls are not acting 

Oscar acting award nominated swirls 

[Bhabylon]

Can't really judge based off of what we've seen from Ari. She's done mainly comedy work

[Kiss It Better]

idk gaga couldn't do cat valentine could she? 

[eclipsed]

Gaga is the clear winner but tbf we haven't seen if Ari can pull off a dramatic role yet. No current pop girl has been able to do what Gaga did with ASIB, HOG, JFAD

[raisetheroof]

Love Ariana to bits and consider myself a bigger fan of hers, but Gaga's got the better acting chops. This, however, only applies to drama as I think Ariana is miles better as a comedy actress; her comedic timing is great. Though, to be fair, I don't think Gaga's ever dipped her toe into comedy, so we can't really compare there. Then again, Ariana hasn't tackled serious drama either, so it's kind of a wash on that front.

 

On an aside - the one's trying to sell ASIB as this challenging role which only Gaga could've been able to execute …..  chile, she was great but she was literally playing herself

[Assassin]

3 hours ago, DirtyPony87 said:

Gaga could do Glinda. Ariana wouldn't have been able to pull off ASIB.

Gaga absolutely could NOT have pulled off Glinda. Be for real.

[Giorgoc]

3 hours ago, Space Cowboy said:

?? ASIB was not a particularly challenging role to execute, Ariana could have done it.

 

Gaga didn't even do that well, her acting felt weak and wooden during the emotional moments of the film. It was clear that she isn't a particularly strong actor.

True, as we all know weak, wooden actor always get nominated for Oscars.

[Onyxmage]

Neither are great but Ariana always does the same ditzy high pitched  voice type characters. 

Edited 8 hours ago by Onyxmage

[Onyxmage]

33 minutes ago, Assassin said:

Gaga absolutely could NOT have pulled off Glinda. Be for real.

Actually Gaga could and she would make her unique instead of copying Kristin Chenoweth's version. 

Edited 8 hours ago by Onyxmage

[Giorgoc]

33 minutes ago, raisetheroof said:

Love Ariana to bits and consider myself a bigger fan of hers, but Gaga's got the better acting chops. This, however, only applies to drama as I think Ariana is miles better as a comedy actress; her comedic timing is great. Though, to be fair, I don't think Gaga's ever dipped her toe into comedy, so we can't really compare there. Then again, Ariana hasn't tackled serious drama either, so it's kind of a wash on that front.

 

On an aside - the one's trying to sell ASIB as this challenging role which only Gaga could've been able to execute …..  chile, she was great but she was literally playing herself

I agree with everything in this post.

Ariana's a comedic genius, Gaga has shined so far in drama.

 

Also agree that her role in ASIB wasn't THAT challenging but she did great hence all the awards and nominations. IMO she really showed her chops in House of Gucci and later in JFAD. Sadly the movies were worse than the acting in them.

[sunbathinganimal]

[Space Cowboy]

1 hour ago, Giorgoc said:

True, as we all know weak, wooden actor always get nominated for Oscars.

Well yes, there are MANY examples of weak performances getting nominated for the oscars. Gaga was not the first or the last.