poll 143 vs Pink Friday 2, what album is better?

[lgaga1fan]

Two highly controversial releases from the past year and a half from two of the biggest hitmakers of the 2010's. 143 (or 1432 if you're feeling spicy) or Pink Friday 2 (and its 1000 deluxe versions). Which highly controversial album is better? 

 

Edited 20 hours ago by lgaga1fan

[Sheep]

PF2

[Gladiator]

I voted Pink Friday 2, although I am more likely to listen to 143.

Just now, Sheep said:

PF2

Pink Friday 2 (The Re-Heat) - Order Up Edition

[Alldeezy]

Pink Friday 2 had cowgirl so that one. 

[Human Fly]

Red Ruby sweetie… 

[PrettyHurts]

Is there a neither option 

they're both abysmal 

[AdamRiver96]

Both garbage

[D.Va]

PF2 has great songs (Red Ruby, Barbie Dangerous, Fallin 4 U, Cowgirl, ...) that are clouded by tragic songs which completely ruin the experience (the Billie sample, the Go Papa Go Papa mess, the Heart Of Glass sample). If you cut these songs, you end up with a nice project.

 

143 is almost unsalvageable on the other hand, it's too short and robotic.

[Harsh2256]

Pf2 had good songs but was too long with too many filler tracks. 143 only saving grace is IMHHM

[alexrex]

I'm good, thanks

[Popboi.]

In some cases, the right thing is to not vote

[itsnickcray]

Pink Friday 2 has some of her best work

[Musicmajor]

143 is more consistent. PF2 has a lot of filler and skips IMO. Although, there are definitely some stand outs like Pink Friday Girls.

[Phaunzie]

I love both, so both. Rolling the dice. Ok the dice landed on a even number, so 143.

[ScorpiosGroove]

trash vs garbage 

[dawnettakins]

Both are trash and belong in the trash bin. One of them (143+2) is already on its way having been picked up by the garbage truck!

[Sazare]

They're about the same honestly

 

PF2 is a little too Ava Max'd with its samples; seems a lil desperate to evoke kneestalgia to distract from the fact that the songs are otherwise too thin. "Everybody" strikes the right balance but otherwise it's super phoned-in to me.

[SmittenCake]

14 minutes ago, Sazare said:

They're about the same honestly

 

 

 gurlie no! PF2 is a masterpiece especially compared go 143 which can hardly be digested 

[Maroonx]

where is the "both are trash" or "neither" option... x

[Sazare]

1 hour ago, SmittenCake said:

 gurlie no! PF2 is a masterpiece especially compared go 143 which can hardly be digested 

143 is perfectly mid. It's not good but it's hardly any worse than any other Katy album

[SmittenCake]

51 minutes ago, Sazare said:

143 is perfectly mid. It's not good but it's hardly any worse than any other Katy album

One of the boys is a pure 10/10 smh