base talk Zach Campbells dissects BRAT era. Overrated and forced?

[Bussea]

 

Do you agree? He's a brat girlie despite only liking a couple songs

Edited 5 hours ago by Bussea

[ontherocks]

No. 

 

Bonus: I will never agree with this man 

[LoveInStereo]

Can't pretend to be interested in sincerely engaging with anything that comes out of this dude's mouth. 1 of the most irritating people on the internet

[Poker Face]

How can u be forced to love something? 

[Pheromosa]

Traditional listeners of music won't find this album to be exceptional  

I thought it was cute though 

[JO1s]

Well taste is subjective and well let's sujectively look at your output mr. campbell 

 

Oh... Anyways.

[toast]

He's got a point, per usual (but not always ). People dismissing his critiques in broad strokes need to pay attention to all of his points, per usual. For example, he makes the point that Eusexua's singles should have at least the same amount of hype, which is true.

 

Good album and great branding, but anyone acting like it's this groundbreaking club album would get laughed at by people actually tapped into the dance/techno scene. The hype is over the top, but that doesn't mean the music is bad.

Edited 5 hours ago by toast

[Katamari]

shes skinny omg 

[Escape]

Nah.

 

I used to love his older videos.

[Dante Silva]

Well I loved it. I feel it was to dance/ pop in 2024, what Donna Summer's "Bad Girls" album was in 1979.

[Bussea]

4 minutes ago, toast said:

He's got a point, per usual (but not always ). People dismissing his critiques in broad strokes need to pay attention to all of his points, per usual. For example, he makes the point that Eusexua's singles should have at least the same amount of hype, which is true.

 

Great album and branding, but anyone acting like it's this groundbreaking club album would get laughed at by people actually tapped into the dance/techno scene. The hype is over the top, but that doesn't mean the music is bad.

Someone who actually watched the video

[Breathe On Moi]

I love Charli so much, but even I can say that this album will do a disservice to her sound/future outputs. 
 

take that as you will 

[Ricanaire]

It's like when he lost weight he also lost everything likable about him. 

[Contessa]

It's her magnum opus. Tight, no filler, familiar yet experimental, earwormy.. Who cares what this twink thinks.

[Contessa]

Also, you can't claim to be a brat girly if you don't vibe with the majority of the album. It screams attention-seeking rather than true appreciation and essence of brat.

[Wicked]

Why does nobody talk about brats emotional depth and focus on the production aspects

 

Most of its critical acclaim is for the former,not it having forward thinking beats.

[dumbsparce]

Someone should make a thread about this one

 

 

I wanna see something 

 

 

OT: that's brave coming from a Beyonce stan. Charli finally scans more than cling film and suddenly she's overrated? If anything, it means that the gp finally clicked with her music.

[Bussea]

33 minutes ago, dumbsparce said:

Someone should make a thread about this one

Go ahead 

[Mtjjproducer]

I have been vocal about not liking brat. I tried giving it another chance last week. I don't HATE it anymore. I found some songs I actually liked. I do think it is kinda overrated but it's not as bad as I originally thought.

 

that being said I would rather listen to the instrumentals cause I find the production interesting. I don't like her vocals on this album though

 

i will admit was too harsh with my hatred of it all summer lol

[UnusualBoy]

Forced? Naa

Overrated? Hell yeah

[Onyxmage]

He would know about overrated and forced with his no talent ass. Anyone remember this?

 

 

[Bussea]

not him deleting the video sksksksks 

[James_Joint]

I wonder why he deleted it?  I thought his opinion was pretty fair and valid.  It's a great album, but it's because of its pop-cultural significance that it's being praised the way it is.  

[WEEKND]

2 hours ago, Katamari said:

shes skinny omg 

😂

 

Video is gone 

[Onyxmage]

16 minutes ago, James_Joint said:

I wonder why he deleted it?  I thought his opinion was pretty fair and valid.  It's a great album, but it's because of its pop-cultural significance that it's being praised the way it is.  

Thats not true at all. The album was critically acclaimed upon release. Even if nobody bought the album it would still be praised. Thats why it isnt overrated.