base talk Worst reviewed albums of 2024 - (based on Metacritic)

[Rev8]

 

Surprised?

Who deserved? Who didn't?

Who should be there?

[synk]

I don't think i would put another album on this list, for me it's ok 

[NEX]

TTPD is my favourite among the worst reviewed albums this year. Don't like any in the top 10 

[Uncatena]

I feel like green scores shouldn't be here but that Glass Animals album was indeed ass so 

Edited 9 hours ago by Uncatena

[sciencemagic]

Katy Perry snatched another #1! Maybe I owe ATRL users @halcyonday and @KatyPrismSpirit an apology 

[Poxy]

It's crazy how far Julian Casablancas has been falling in the past few years... he may have gotten a Grammy, but that record wasn't all that acclaimed. Plus, the divorce and dating a random 19 year old groupie, saying the music he makes with The Strokes isn't who he truly is but the panned messed from The Voidz is... then putting AI slop on the cover 

[teedhooks]

I thought The Voidz album was actually enjoyable and the reception was unfairly marred by the controversy over the use of AI to create the cover art 

 

I mean it's a conversation worth having but I found it odd how much criticism they faced and how strongly it affected the response compared to others who have done the same

[Saint James]

i knew what to expect coming in here but it still made me laugh

[GAGAxMONSTER]

Only 8 albums were rated 60 or below? Such generousity.

 

OT: Happy to not see Gaga. She survived the year 

[B-Luke]

I read Sia as N/A

[nostalgic]

Sia deserved for that album cover alone  aesthetically hideous, borderline humiliating

[Scandalous]

how are there only 2 albums below a 50 for the entire year?  

[tost1]

Only 8 panned albums in the whole year? 

[Into The Void]

Justin Timberlake deserved at least 65 that was a good album

[OrbitNumber1]

1 hour ago, Scandalous said:

how are there only 2 albums below a 50 for the entire year?  

Music critics are very nice nowadays since panning an album means the fandom will harass you, so even if you despise an album you give it a cute 6.

[SupremeGoddess]

3 hours ago, sciencemagic said:

Katy Perry snatched another #1! Maybe I owe ATRL users @halcyonday and @KatyPrismSpirit an apology 

16 years after debuting and still scoring number ones  miss perry proved me wrong 

Edited 5 hours ago by SupremeGoddess

[prézli]

But ATRL told me JT released the best male album this year.

[Tm4074]

Damn not a good year with the critics for 2000s era artists 

[BlahBlahBlah]

JLO's wasn't as bad as it was made out to be imo. 

[EnigmaticAndroid]

Katy Perry 

 

The Panned Jester of Pop 

[Rep2000]

4 hours ago, OrbitNumber1 said:

Music critics are very nice nowadays since panning an album means the fandom will harass you, so even if you despise an album you give it a cute 6.

So what would that say about that red panned album then? 

[Radical Pessimism]

Katy being that low for a "huge" pop star is embarrassing! 

[Vixen Eyes]

I honestly did not expect Katy to snatch top spot here 💀