charts discussion Fortnight by Taylor Swift left global spotify, why?

[hungrymuffin]

3 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

Deserved Anti-hero's success. It continues to baffle me how the GP always gets it wrong with her...

 

this

 

OT: i was surprised its still charting, you can say its not a hit but its definitely not a flop

[Draper.]

It lasted way more than it deserves. Congrats to Taylor. 

[Calvin]

3 minutes ago, wish said:

A total of ZERO smashes from TTPD. Nobody expected this level of underperformance 

Yet sold 11 million so far. Anthology physicals yet to arrive. An album artist 

[Solaria]

Mediocre song from a mediocre album by a used to be great artist

[Solaria]

TTPD is the most cult album I've ever seen. So many streams yet none of these songs will be remembered by the general public (and no, the Swifties are not the GP. They were last year, certainly not this year). This album truly tanked in terms of crossover appeal. It's a cultural bomb compared to Midnights.

 

Taylor knows this though. TS12 will be her happy record. 

[wehavetostan]

7 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

Deserved Anti-hero's success. It continues to baffle me how the GP always gets it wrong with her...

 

Anti-Hero and Fortnight both deserve to be smashes in their own right! I can specifically hear Heaven calling in the last 45 seconds of Fortnight 

[Klein]

And that's Karma.mp3 for choosing Fortnight as the lead single instead of Guilty As Sin, Down Bad or My Boy (or Florida!!! in my perfect fantasy world). 

 

[State of Grace.]

Just now, wehavetostan said:

Anti-Hero and Fortnight both deserve to be smashes in their own right! I can specifically hear Heaven calling in the last 45 seconds of Fortnight 

Not even exaggerating when I tell you that's one of my fave moments in her discography! We need the 10 Mins version.

[hungrymuffin]

1 minute ago, Solaria said:

TTPD is the most cult album I've ever seen. So many streams yet none of these songs will be remembered by the general public (and no, the Swifties are not the GP. They were last year, certainly not this year). This album truly tanked in terms of crossover appeal. It's a cultural bomb compared to Midnights.

 

Taylor knows this though. TS12 will be her happy record. 

just because the songs may not be remembered by the GP doesnt mean the album wont be, speak now had no hits and still stands the test of time

[Loca]

Oh, it was BAD for her  And with a Post Malone feature 

[Loca]

42 minutes ago, WildHeart said:

And she returned to #1 on artists chart the same day. Even when she loses, she wins 

This is giving DWAS/Disease 

 

Oh, it was bad for Switfies too

[Loca]

15 minutes ago, wish said:

A total of ZERO smashes from TTPD. Nobody expected this level of underperformance 

Grammys underperformance next

[WildHeart]

2 minutes ago, Loca said:

This is giving DWAS/Disease 

 

Oh, it was bad for Switfies too

If only Post was as useful as Bruno when we needed it the most 

Edited November 1 by WildHeart

[Le Grande]

Flop trash.

[Solaria]

4 minutes ago, hungrymuffin said:

just because the songs may not be remembered by the GP doesnt mean the album wont be, speak now had no hits and still stands the test of time

Peak Now is a masterclass at young adult country pop. Ofcourse that album stood the test of the time. It has songs with good structure, with HOOKS, with a good balance of clever songwriting and pop sensibilities. The mushmash of thesauraus words and 'copy paste from my journal' songs of TTPD will never stand the test of time like Peak Now.

 

Swifties need to stop dickriding everything Taylor puts out. Objectively, TTPD is one of her messiest and unfinished albums. It's okay to admit that!

[Europe]

Honestly it did fine the real problem is that she didn't lift a finger for ICDIWABH or release some other single she felt passionate about. There was so much potential on the album.

[hungrymuffin]

11 minutes ago, Solaria said:

Peak Now is a masterclass at young adult country pop. Ofcourse that album stood the test of the time. It has songs with good structure, with HOOKS, with a good balance of clever songwriting and pop sensibilities. The mushmash of thesauraus words and 'copy paste from my journal' songs of TTPD will never stand the test of time like Peak Now.

 

Swifties need to stop dickriding everything Taylor puts out. Objectively, TTPD is one of her messiest and unfinished albums. It's okay to admit that!

you are getting ahead of yourself i didnt even mention anything about quality, just because you dont like it, it doesnt mean others dont (theres no objectivity in this)

anyway we will find out in a few years time, lover didnt do that well initially but look at where it is now

Edited November 1 by hungrymuffin

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

Because talent lost 

[UnusualBoy]

It's what she deserves for not pushing Down Bad as single.

[Smarticle]

The song is ****

 

[Starkboy]

It's crazy it lasted this long considering how mid both song and album are. Her power I guess

 

[ninetales]

Yet it holds the distinction of being the "most streamed song" in a single day on Spotify. What a tragic ending it got to face. 

[Digitalism]

Bad single choice tbh.

I'm sure DB or GAS would have donde better.

[Calvin]

53 minutes ago, Loca said:

Oh, it was BAD for her  And with a Post Malone feature 

 

52 minutes ago, Loca said:

This is giving DWAS/Disease 

 

Oh, it was bad for Switfies too

 

50 minutes ago, Loca said:

Grammys underperformance next

 

53 minutes ago, Loca said:

Oh, it was BAD for her  And with a Post Malone feature 

[unclefloprry]

The female BTS  the gp keep saying no to her music