charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[Galaxy]

9 minutes ago, Price of Fame said:

30 pages already when we won't know if this is a flop or not until we see the holds the new couple of days

When it ends up having more pages than the 143 MC thread

 

[Sexyzinger]

[nadiamendell]

37 minutes ago, Assassin said:

we don't celebrate Halloween here.

No wonder you are so miserable. 

[Into The Void]

44 minutes ago, Burn said:

Did I say "4,537,700 > 4,452,496" or "#4 > #12"?

 

The point is Beyoncé had the 4th most popular song on release, despite being a surprise Sunday night release (and the fact she dropped two singles meaning the hive were splitting their streams across Texas and 16C. Gaga has the 12th most popular song of the day despite weeks of teasing and a Friday release, when all her fans had to do was stream the ONE song.  85k difference or not, why are there 11 songs more popular than Gaga's hyped comeback?

So basically if Gaga released this in March and it got 4.4m streams it would have been #4 

[Draper.]

9 minutes ago, Into The Void said:

That's not bad for a pop song tbh

When it's jazz because it's jazz, when it's pop because it's pop. The wheel is wheeling. 

 

[Into The Void]

Just now, Draper. said:

When it's jazz because it's jazz, when it's pop because it's pop. The wheel is wheeling. 

 

It's true a majority of pop songs flop on AM except a few lol

[Bloodflowers.]

The song is too experimental and dark for casuals, but it will be a slow burn hit that needs a bit of time for average Joe and Jane to grasp!

[Burn]

4 minutes ago, Into The Void said:

So basically if Gaga released this in March and it got 4.4m streams it would have been #4 

 

[Acuminatus]

I mean that's pretty decent, and since the song is good and we know her older work is becoming popular again, I expect it to rise. Especially when she finally releases the MV so more people are aware of the song. And you know the MV is going to serve! 
 

The mess here in this thread is fun though!

Edited October 26 by Acuminatus

[Red Velvet]

The 100million listeners are still sleeping 

[Draper.]

28 minutes ago, Great808 said:

The fact that there is no MV on release day truly goes to show commercial success clearly isn't an intention

That's a funny one cause you were perched on every Break My Soul thread calling it a bomb despite it going #1 for multiple weeks. Another one for the wheel!

 

 

[justlore]

[Mick]

31 minutes ago, Great808 said:

The fact that there is no MV on release day truly goes to show commercial success clearly isn't an intention yet she still pulled 4M+  honestly congrats. It's about time the older MPG's from around her gen and her's more specifically start focusing on good music instead of commercial success. Maybe if Katy had followed that path she wouldn't have cleared herself into oblivion. 

GOOD MUSIC 🤣

[mael]

Thank you Lady GaGa. 
 

Looking forward to the song's trajectory for the next week..

[Mick]

2 minutes ago, Draper. said:

That's a funny one cause you were perched on every Break My Soul thread calling it a bomb despite it going #1 for multiple weeks. Another one for the wheel!

 

 

🤣😉

[Lightbringer007]

great debut for someone whos over a decade in the game!

 

the mv is gonna serve

[Cloudy]

Oh the constant humbling never ends

 

[thinking]

3 minutes ago, Draper. said:

That's a funny one cause you were perched on every Break My Soul thread calling it a bomb despite it going #1 for multiple weeks. Another one for the wheel!

 

 

[Into The Void]

Why are OGHs struggling to cope so hard that Gaga did well 

 

If this was any other pop girl she would be getting praise for doing 4.5m streams. 

 

[Burn]

5 minutes ago, Lightbringer007 said:

great debut for someone whos over

 

agreed.

[Riverbank]

3 hours ago, frankvert said:

Tour gross —> Gaga isphysically incapable of performing as many tour dates as Beyoncé. OGHs using it against her so vehemently is practically ableist at this point. TCB averages prove she could go toe to toe with Bey if she could. Also, Bey had a 10 year head start on her lifetime tour gross. 

The way I'm still not over this fhdjkskjfjkdsks

[Lightbringer007]

2 minutes ago, Burn said:

agreed.

oh thats not-

[Doogle]

11 minutes ago, Draper. said:

That's a funny one cause you were perched on every Break My Soul thread calling it a bomb despite it going #1 for multiple weeks. Another one for the wheel!

 

 

You couldn't make this up sjdjdkdhd

 

I knew Renaissance era would come back to bite. It already did with their prejudging before the album but the karma keeps coming 

[HeavyMetalAura]

the fact that lady gaga and Beyonce are both sitting in their mansions counting their millions while y'all fa- I mean gay people argue over which of them is more successful  

[BrokenMachine]

43 minutes ago, Great808 said:

The fact that there is no MV on release day truly goes to show commercial success clearly isn't an intention