charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[Soup in Teapot]

US Liddos are so useless as always.
 

Glad the international fans do their jobs.

[Ger]

Really good debut, I mean, y'all need to be real for once, it's Lady Gaga in 2024.

[KOMH]

9 minutes ago, hawx23 said:

No actually #12 Global = global

The stupidity in here 

Worse debut than Stupid Love in 2024 = BOMB

 

The stupidity in here

[Delirious]

11 minutes ago, ineedboxinggloves said:

So illogical 

 

11 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said:

It's not Gaga's fault no one wanted that other song in their playlists 

What happened to Gaga's 100m+ monthly listeners?

 

Also disease got a decent placement on the TTH and every other playlist meanwhile WW served OUT or got a shitty position.

[wastedpotential]

The best solo debut for an Italian Girl from New York™ in 2024. I guess the Liddos can enjoy that one 

 

[Robyn.]

2 hours ago, Dear Reader said:

Debuting with double Dr Luke's Woman's World numbers. I thought they were on the same boat, what happened?

And why would a song that bombed be the standard?

you're just dragging it

[wastedpotential]

4 minutes ago, KOMH said:

It had a better debut in the US than in 91.837% of the territories where it charted, excluding those where it missed the top 200 entirely. It charted in 49 countries out of 76 and missed the top 200 in 27.  It only did slightly better in Brazil and the UK.

 

#8 Brazil — 822 119
#9 United Kingdom — 309 864
#14 Latvia — 3 837
#15 Estonia — 3 089

Not them demanding to see the 3000 streams a piece from the Baltic countries as if that makes it better

 

Oh GlobalGa 

Edited October 26 by wastedpotential

[45seconds]

18 minutes ago, Assassin said:

you only say that because Gaga hasn't had any in more than a decade.
Yet ATRL dragged Bey for only being able to score #1 by jumping on remixes before Break My Soul and Texas Hold 'em

Specifically Lady GaGa fans too. Pointing to "Telephone" as her last hit that GaGa gave her. How the tables have turned lmfao. 

[FrederickGa]

2 minutes ago, KOMH said:

It had a better debut in the US than in 91.837% of the territories where it charted, excluding those where it missed the top 200 entirely. It charted in 49 countries out of 76 and missed the top 200 in 27.  It only did slightly better in Brazil and the UK.

 

#8 Brazil — 822 119
#9 United Kingdom — 309 864
#14 Latvia — 3 837
#15 Estonia — 3 089

Then include evrything hun.. that just proves that Gaga's numbers are distributed not concentrated cause 4.4M is still boatmating with 4.5M not 2.2M

 

[WildHeart]

55 minutes ago, Devin said:

 

i shoulda known yall ass up in here starting trouble.

 

44 minutes ago, Devin said:

ot: fortnight is trash that came & went. 

Oh liddo hive

[frankvert]

Just now, Assassin said:

I already mentioned that Bey has terrible Spotify streams.
So what exactly am I supposed to "give up"?

Beyonce still has bigger tour gross, recent solo #1s and bigger album debut numbers than Gaga. 

Tour gross —> Gaga isphysically incapable of performing as many tour dates as Beyoncé. OGHs using it against her so vehemently is practically ableist at this point. TCB averages prove she could go toe to toe with Bey if she could. Also, Bey had a 10 year head start on her lifetime tour gross. 
 

Solo #1s —> completely irrelevant  

 

Album debut #s —> I'll give you that Bey's PR team has done a better job at establishing Bey as an "album artist" than Gaga has. 

[BrokenMachine]

1 minute ago, Delirious said:

 

What happened to Gaga's 100m+ monthly listeners?

 

Also disease got a decent placement on the TTH and every other playlist meanwhile WW served OUT or got a shitty position.

Happy Mistake got dragged to hell and back for having more playlisting than WW and still being a flop. A song can get decent playlisting but if no one wants to listen to it, it won't get good numbers anyways 

[Kimi]

okay numbers? 

6 minutes ago, Assassin said:

I already mentioned that Bey has terrible Spotify streams.
So what exactly am I supposed to "give up"?

Beyonce still has bigger tour gross, recent solo #1s and bigger album debut numbers than Gaga. 

number one peaks but no longevity lol a key factor of being a hit. give it up. arutw is a bigger hit than BMS and Texas

[Rotunda]

1 minute ago, frankvert said:

Tour gross —> Gaga isphysically incapable of performing as many tour dates as Beyoncé. OGHs using it against her so vehemently is practically ableist at this point. TCB averages prove she could go toe to toe with Bey if she could. Also, Bey had a 10 year head start on her lifetime tour gross. 
 

Solo #1s —> completely irrelevant  

 

Album debut #s —> I'll give you that Bey's PR team has done a better job at establishing Bey as an "album artist" than Gaga has. 

Someone add ableism to the wheel 

[FrederickGa]

3 minutes ago, Robyn. said:

And why would a song that bombed be the standard?

you're just dragging it

Probably because OGHs pushed the Katy=Gaga narrative

[CherryBay]

 

 

[frankvert]

Just now, Rotunda said:

Someone add ableism to the wheel 

You can put it next to racism on Beyoncé's wheel

[BrokenMachine]

5 minutes ago, Delirious said:

What happened to Gaga's 100m+ monthly listeners?

Btw this lame drag is useless. Are you really expecting for her to pull 100M streams in ONE day based in MONTHLY numbers? Billie also has +100M monthly listeners and yet you don't see her with a song above 10M daily streams

[Shinkirou]

The monthly listeners drag are partly joking I know, but they also show why I don't like that metric. Because why are y'all comparing the amount of listeners that she reached in a month to the amount of listeners she reached in a day?

[suburbannature]

I'm actively cackling at the Liddo wheel of excuses playing out in real time in this thread meanwhile it's a lower debut than Stupid Love.

[FrederickGa]

4 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

Not them demanding to see the 3000 streams a piece from the Baltic countries as if that makes it better

 

Oh GlobalGa 

Yeah, we celbrate small countries.. we just dont depent on USA you know 

I mean, combine all those countries and we have 1.1M US & 4.4M WW

 

GLOBAL 

[CherryBay]

So Gaga has 100mln+ listeners on Spotify 

Come out after her Big movie and recent soundtrack and album 

Paris hype and singing to her fans somewhere 

 

and this is it? 
 

 

Katy's songs had harder less listeners playlisting , huge hate wagon and lack of promo and also song wasn't taken seriously 

[Starshine]

2 hours ago, frankvert said:

Tour gross —> TCB averages prove she could go toe to toe with Bey if she could.
 

Chromatica Ball: $5.62m average

Renaissance Tour: $10.3m average

 

 

[ineedboxinggloves]

8 minutes ago, KOMH said:

Worse debut than Stupid Love in 2024 = BOMB

 

The stupidity in here

By your logic DWAS is a bomb because it debuted less than SL? 
 

The stupidity in here

[FrederickGa]

10 minutes ago, Soup in Teapot said:

US Liddos are so useless as always.
 

Glad the international fans do their jobs.

They pulled thru during MR/Joanne Era tho.. gotta give em that