charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[narid]

1 minute ago, Hot Volcano said:

the topic was the biggest bomb of the year and that was Katy as much as some of you would love it to be Gaga. That user pointing that out doesn't mean they are comparing Katy to Gaga

 

 

Your point would be valid if that liddo wasn't comparing her to Katy in every other post of theirs in this thread and any other chance they have on this site. 

 

Point being, if it isn't the biggest bomb of the year because Katy is number 1, then she is definitely number 2.

 

Something boatmates something something! 

[Doctor Dick]

7 minutes ago, narid said:

Point being, if it isn't the biggest bomb of the year because Katy is number 1, then she is definitely number 2.

What on eeeeearth  She's not even second, Narid.

 

Selena Gomez's Love On: 50-157-OUT

Jennifer Lopez's Can't Get Enough: OUT-OUT

Justin Timberlake's Selfish: 92-OUT

Lady Gaga's Disease: 12-23-38-51-63-41-41-34-48-55-49-55-66-65-82

 

No matter how HARD (and you try HARD) you guys try to spin this into a bomb it's not. Doing way better than many other flops this year and it debuted at #12. TWELVE. Much more hype for a Gaga song as well. If anything this just shows how the song didn't connect, not the artist. It would be a problem if SHE couldn't debut high and tanked. But SHE and HER NAME can and THE SONG is what people said NO to. 

Edited November 9 by Doctor Dick

[MESSIAH13]

6 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

What on eeeeearth  She's not even second, Narid.

 

Selena Gomez's Love On: 50-157-OUT

Jennifer Lopez's Can't Get Enough: OUT-OUT

Justin Timberlake's Selfish: 92-OUT

Lady Gaga's Disease: 12-23-38-51-63-41-41-34-48-55-49-55-66-65-82

 

No matter how HARD (and you try HARD) you guys try to spin this into a bomb it's not. Doing way better than many other flops this year and it debuted at #12. TWELVE. Much more hype for a Gaga song as well. If anything this just shows how the song didn't connect, not the artist. It would be a problem if SHE couldn't debut high and tanked. But SHE and HER NAME can and THE SONG is what people said NO to. 

None of those songs you mentioned got the playlist support that gaga's song got. It's not a fair comparison 

[Doctor Dick]

8 minutes ago, MESSIAH13 said:

None of those songs you mentioned got the playlist support that gaga's song got. It's not a fair comparison 

Not the excuses They didn't because of their first popularity rating in the first update. And not to mention none of them had massive playlist reach in their first day and only won did 4M+ and #12. 

[Ramcoro]

41 minutes ago, narid said:

Your point would be valid if that liddo wasn't comparing her to Katy in every other post of theirs in this thread and any other chance they have on this site. 

 

Point being, if it isn't the biggest bomb of the year because Katy is number 1, then she is definitely number 2.

 

Something boatmates something something! 

At this point it's like a 5'1" person calling a 5'0" person short. Like lol we are all fighting to be 2nd to last? It's not 2010 or 2013 anymore for either of them.

[kimberly]

47 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

What on eeeeearth  She's not even second, Narid.

 

Selena Gomez's Love On: 50-157-OUT

Jennifer Lopez's Can't Get Enough: OUT-OUT

Justin Timberlake's Selfish: 92-OUT

Lady Gaga's Disease: 12-23-38-51-63-41-41-34-48-55-49-55-66-65-82

do you think performing better than has beens Jennifer Lopez and Justin Timberlake in 2024 is a brag? for an alleged Main Pop Girl?

 

JLo, who last touched the Hot 100 in 2018 with her #80 smash hit "Dinero" ft. Cardi B?

 

[Hot Volcano]

4 hours ago, Hot Volcano said:

Haters downvoting my UK update post

 

Here's something else to downvote

 

UK Amazon Music

#30 (+5) Disease

 

UK Amazon Music

#23 (+7) Disease

[bliaz]

If the Monsters are so sure of the success of Gaga vs Katy, why do they insist on fighting with those who say otherwise? Here the worst of all is that they have to compare Gaga to Katy. Why not Beyoncé, Taylor? Someone who is at the level that the Monsters pretend? 

[katykater]

 

After a red Friday comes the weekend drop.

[Hot Volcano]

30 minutes ago, bliaz said:

If the Monsters are so sure of the success of Gaga vs Katy, why do they insist on fighting with those who say otherwise? Here the worst of all is that they have to compare Gaga to Katy. Why not Beyoncé, Taylor? Someone who is at the level that the Monsters pretend? 

Bey and Taylor are clearly above Gaga and there is simply nobody else left but Katy. 

[bliaz]

9 minutes ago, Hot Volcano said:

Bey and Taylor are clearly above Gaga and there is simply nobody else left but Katy. 

 

[Miss Anthropocene]

1 hour ago, MESSIAH13 said:

None of those songs you mentioned got the playlist support that gaga's song got. It's not a fair comparison 

Because they didn't deserve the playlist support, atleast disease has some stability compared to those songs 

[katykater]

25 minutes ago, Hot Volcano said:

Bey and Taylor are clearly above Gaga and there is simply nobody else left but Katy. 

So we are looking at a gravity well?

 

[Jon Snow]

48 minutes ago, katykater said:

 

After a red Friday comes the weekend drop.

not the chart expanding  she completely broke them 

[Doctor Dick]

1 hour ago, bliaz said:

If the Monsters are so sure of the success of Gaga vs Katy, why do they insist on fighting with those who say otherwise? Here the worst of all is that they have to compare Gaga to Katy. Why not Beyoncé, Taylor? Someone who is at the level that the Monsters pretend? 

Beyoncé, Gaga and Taylor can all debut lead singles to 4M+. So yes, you're absolutely right! They can also all three do stadiums. Katy can't any of that, so thank you bliaz. 

[Jon Snow]

1 hour ago, bliaz said:

If the Monsters are so sure of the success of Gaga vs Katy, why do they insist on fighting with those who say otherwise? Here the worst of all is that they have to compare Gaga to Katy. Why not Beyoncé, Taylor? Someone who is at the level that the Monsters pretend? 

they tried 

 

[Doctor Dick]

Just now, Jon Snow said:

not the chart expanding  she completely broke them 

Huh? Songs above 1.6M all chart in the Top 100. If anything the chart broke the OGHs home-made graph. 

[Jon Snow]

1 minute ago, Doctor Dick said:

Huh? Songs above 1.6M all chart in the Top 100. If anything the chart broke the OGHs home-made graph. 

that's the only chart that was broken, so... connect the dots 

 

4 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

Beyoncé, Gaga and Taylor can all debut lead singles to 4M+. So yes, you're absolutely right! They can also all three do stadiums. Katy can't any of that, so thank you bliaz. 

delete this before they see it

[bliaz]

27 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

Beyoncé, Gaga and Taylor can all debut lead singles to 4M+. So yes, you're absolutely right! They can also all three do stadiums. Katy can't any of that, so thank you bliaz. 

So, Dr. Dick, are you telling me that Gaga is on the same level as Beyoncé and Taylor? Then why do you keep fighting when they compare her to Katy? Isn't it better to let the truth speak for itself? So, thank you, Doctor Dick

 

Edited November 10 by bliaz

[Doctor Dick]

8 minutes ago, bliaz said:

So, Dr. Dick, are you telling me that Gaga is on the same level as Beyoncé and Taylor? Then why do you keep fighting when they compare her to Katy? Isn't it better to let the truth speak for itself? So, thank you, Doctor Dick

 

So if we fight against something we aren't right? The whole reason we fight is to ensure the truth prevails whether it be political issues or this. 

 

[Mrnoniee]

10 hours ago, sickboy said:

Playlist reach:

 

11/09 - 119,944,730 (+0.08%)

11/08 - 119,845,824 (+8.67%)

11/07 - 110,289,228 (+0.62%)

11/06 - 109,612,308 (-10.37%)

11/05 - 122,293,491 (+16.82%)

11/04 - 104,684,492 (-16.08%)

11/03 - 124,740,326 (+0.28%)

11/02 - 124,395,620 (+0.74%)

11/01 - 123,484,705 (-6.18%)

10/31 - 131,615,928 (+27.66%)

10/30 - 103,098,534 (-1.78%)

10/29 - 104,970,193 (-15.77%)

10/28 - 124,618,007 (+3.61%)

10/27 - 120,275,907 (-4.26%)

10/26 - 125,633,142 (+31.49%)

10/25 - 95,548,859

 

For research purposes only 

This includes TTH?

Imagine some of the girls, who have underperformed,
having the $$$, PUSH and machinery she's have.
---
Can we have her Radio Numbers too? for research purpose, ofcourse.
Cause the radio deal was MASSIVE too.

[bliaz]

27 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

So if we fight against something we aren't right? The whole reason we fight is to ensure the truth prevails whether it be political issues or this. 

 

Then the answer is no. Gaga is not at the level of Beyoncé or Taylor and that's why you guys feel successful and fulfilled by comparing her to someone like Katy

 

[Doctor Dick]

2 minutes ago, bliaz said:

Then the answer is no. Gaga is not at the level of Beyoncé or Taylor and that's why you guys feel successful and fulfilled by comparing her to someone like Katy

 

The argument is messy. If I accuse you of being a killer and you fight back to prove you're not it means you are?  Gaga has the #1 song, can sell out stadiums, is talented and has a devoted fanbase. She good. 

 

[bliaz]

1 minute ago, Doctor Dick said:

The argument is messy. If I accuse you of being a killer and you fight back to prove you're not it means you are?  Gaga has the #1 song, can sell out stadiums, is talented and has a devoted fanbase. She good. 

 

Not you comparing a bombing artist to a killer 

But keep up your fight against the evil Katy Kats who want to make believe that Disease is a flop! 

 

 

[PYT]

2 hours ago, kimberly said:

do you think performing better than has beens Jennifer Lopez and Justin Timberlake in 2024 is a brag? for an alleged Main Pop Girl?

 

JLo, who last touched the Hot 100 in 2018 with her #80 smash hit "Dinero" ft. Cardi B?

 

That Doctor Liddo honestly lost it lol comparing Gaga to JLO and JT who both debuted in the 90s… Why not compare A-list Gaga to her actual A-list peers like Adele, Bieber, Ariana, even Bruno himself 

 

Not Selena when she's not even focusing on music these days and not musically inclined 💀

Edited November 10 by PYT