charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[Beamon]

3 minutes ago, Charmed Life said:

If that's "winning", I'd hate to see what "Losing" is.

ask the katyrats camping this thread 

[Truth Teller]

It's inevitably getting bumped down on TTH tomorrow, but I wonder how much... My guess is #9-#11

[OrgVisual]

31 minutes ago, atemyheartinc said:

There are people who are entitled to talk about chart performances, and others who aren't.

All Katy's singles from 143 definitely performed worse than Disease on the charts, so I'm still trying to figure out how they can be so bold as to criticize others.

 

It's 2024 and Liddos still think "Katy is a flop" is a drag to KatyKats  

 

Let me set this clear

 

Katy's a fad and so is Gaga

WW was a BOMB and so is Disease

[atemyheartinc]

5 minutes ago, OrgVisual said:

It's 2024 and Liddos still think "Katy is a flop" is a drag to KatyKats  

 

Let me set this clear

 

Katy's a fad and so is Gaga

WW was a BOMB and so is Disease

If you think they're on the same level, I don't know what to tell you.
I guess whatever helps you sleep at night.

 

Spoiler

Billboard's Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century: No. 5 — Lady Gaga

With her explosive emergence in the late '00s, Gaga raised the bar for all facets of pop superstardom, while her continued evolution has kept her vital into the 2020s.

 

Edited November 7 by atemyheartinc

[Comedor]

Stop! It's already dead! GIF

[smartalek22]

8 minutes ago, atemyheartinc said:

If you think they're on the same level, I don't know what to tell you.
I guess whatever helps you sleep at night.

 

  Hide contents

Billboard's Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century: No. 5 — Lady Gaga

With her explosive emergence in the late '00s, Gaga raised the bar for all facets of pop superstardom, while her continued evolution has kept her vital into the 2020s.

 

If someone says "both Houdini and Disease flopped" it doesn't mean they said those two songs are "on the same level" 

 

It would simply mean both flopped and it would be true 

 

Someone getting so defensive and triggered over such a statement should explore why they are so desperate to point out "but they are not the same level!" 

[Kool_Aid_King]

DEAD in the US. Wow. She needs to get the piano back.

[atemyheartinc]

3 minutes ago, smartalek22 said:

If someone says "both Houdini and Disease flopped" it doesn't mean they said those two songs are "on the same level" 

 

It would simply mean both flopped and it would be true 

 

Someone getting so defensive and triggered over such a statement should explore why they are so desperate to point out "but they are not the same level!" 

I was talking about Katy and Gaga being 'on the same level.'
Now you can explore why you have trouble reading.

 

[Movimento Perpétuo]

It seems the US only cares about her soccer mom ballads

[Robburro]

1 hour ago, atemyheartinc said:

There are people who are entitled to talk about chart performances, and others who aren't.

All Katy's singles from 143 definitely performed worse than Disease on the charts, so I'm still trying to figure out how they can be so bold as to criticize others.

 

the same way monsters are bold to talk about Cowboy Carter or Fortnight

 

[Namiskine]

1 hour ago, Alongoria13 said:

Sheesh  is this the hardest bomb on TTH or is it Small Talk?

Now c'mon, it's not even the hardest TTH bomb of the last 4 weeks. It's obviously going way down there tonight with the update

 

OT: Flopping with quality, but deserved numbers given the rollout. Let's hope we'll have a proper era in 2025 

[Trash]

2 hours ago, perfectillusion204 said:

Y'all, the USA had a lot bigger things to worry about yesterday than streaming Disease… no offense lol. Not the type of song most people wanted to listen to yesterday. 

Make this shorter, it'll be hard to read on the wheel of excuses

 

[reymiu]

1 hour ago, Truth Teller said:

It's inevitably getting bumped down on TTH tomorrow, but I wonder how much... My guess is #9-#11

#43 obv

 

#1-#43 on Spotify TTH

[smartalek22]

3 minutes ago, reymiu said:

#43 obv

 

#1-#43 on Spotify TTH

we want #143 on US Spotify 200 then

[Toxic.Latin]

maybe the first position of the TTH is not helping since spotify banners are green and kinda bigger than the first names there and maybe the GP is not seeing disease there, cause the pic of lady gaga is in grey and the contrast is not helping. maybe the placement is the problem. 

[FlyOnTheWall]

4 hours ago, Nefertiti0 said:

Day 13
#66(-11) Global — 1,884,842(-198,705)
#156(-52) US — 365,401(-61,962)
#47(-7) UK — 132,744(-16,451)
#193(-49) Norway — 10,168(-1,310)
#137(-25) Brazil — 207,424(-19,521)
#31(-4) Ukraine — 11,033(-472)
#44(-7) Estonia — 1,767(-126)
#47(-14 )Lithuania — 3,456(-500)
#50(-7) Latvia — 2,322(-172)
#60(-5) Netherlands — 48,094(-2,529)
#65(-14) Bulgaria — 3,007(-398)
#72(-10) Ireland — 13,370(-958)
#73(-19) Singapore — 13,220(-2,481)
#80(-10) Hungary — 8,749(-664)
#84(-11) Finland — 13,267(-1,382)
#86(-13) Portugal — 13,847(-745)
#87(-11) Canada — 64,271(-3,836)
#104(-16) Poland — 43,691(-5,078)
#107(-37) Belgium — 14,772(-933)
#107(-21) Hong Kong — 6,921(-1,069)
#111(-22) Sweden — 22,930(-2,179)
#112(-23) Switzerland — 10,495(-786)
#115(-29) Slovakia — 3,801(-434)
#125(-38) Taiwan — 16,085(-2,662)
#133(-26) United Arab Emirates — 3,308(-355)
#135(-31) Australia — 61,508(-5,740)
#147(-29) Austria — 7,372(-931)
#154(-34) Czech Republic — 10,222(-900)
#170(-31) Greece — 10,557(-1,048)
#188(-36) Germany — 67,897(-7,103)
#196(-49) New Zealand — 9,177(-898)
#199(-49) Romania — 5,606(-850)
OUT France     
OUT Iceland            
OUT Malaysia            
OUT Saudi Arabia            

All things like playlisting, airplay etc. considered this might really be the biggest bomb of the year, I-

[znake]

Rise  disissssssssssss !!  this is just only the beginning

 

[TedMiracle]

R.I.P.

[NoAngelus]

4 hours ago, Nefertiti0 said:

Day 13
#66(-11) Global — 1,884,842(-198,705)
#156(-52) US — 365,401(-61,962)
#47(-7) UK — 132,744(-16,451)
#193(-49) Norway — 10,168(-1,310)
#137(-25) Brazil — 207,424(-19,521)
#31(-4) Ukraine — 11,033(-472)
#44(-7) Estonia — 1,767(-126)
#47(-14 )Lithuania — 3,456(-500)
#50(-7) Latvia — 2,322(-172)
#60(-5) Netherlands — 48,094(-2,529)
#65(-14) Bulgaria — 3,007(-398)
#72(-10) Ireland — 13,370(-958)
#73(-19) Singapore — 13,220(-2,481)
#80(-10) Hungary — 8,749(-664)
#84(-11) Finland — 13,267(-1,382)
#86(-13) Portugal — 13,847(-745)
#87(-11) Canada — 64,271(-3,836)
#104(-16) Poland — 43,691(-5,078)
#107(-37) Belgium — 14,772(-933)
#107(-21) Hong Kong — 6,921(-1,069)
#111(-22) Sweden — 22,930(-2,179)
#112(-23) Switzerland — 10,495(-786)
#115(-29) Slovakia — 3,801(-434)
#125(-38) Taiwan — 16,085(-2,662)
#133(-26) United Arab Emirates — 3,308(-355)
#135(-31) Australia — 61,508(-5,740)
#147(-29) Austria — 7,372(-931)
#154(-34) Czech Republic — 10,222(-900)
#170(-31) Greece — 10,557(-1,048)
#188(-36) Germany — 67,897(-7,103)
#196(-49) New Zealand — 9,177(-898)
#199(-49) Romania — 5,606(-850)
OUT France     
OUT Iceland            
OUT Malaysia            
OUT Saudi Arabia            

Make Gaga Green Again 

[sickboy]

 

[MatiRod]

I do think DWAS, Harlequin and Joker 2 killed any pent up anticipation for new Gaga material. And especially Harlequin being so underwhelming. If this had come out without any of that and video and CDs out the first week, it would've debuted in the Top 15 and we wouldn't be having these discussions.

 

Dont count her out until the album drops. She still has a loyal fanbase.

[Welovetrouble]

26 minutes ago, sickboy said:

 

Which atrler wrote this? Lol. Reveal yourself.

Edited November 7 by Welovetrouble

[Comedor]

This flop has more to do with the song being terrible than Gaga herself. She had great exposure between JFAD and DWAS, it was a perfect storm/illusion, but Deceit is a bad song and nobody is really enjoying it. She blew it.

[Bookmark99]

It doesn't sound like anything that would smash in the U.S. Look at the charts right now. Women are listening to that Gracie Adams ****. 

 

If she wants a solo hit then she needs to hop on the country trend or do another cheesy karaoke type ballad. If this is actually the music she wants to make then good for her. But it won't be a hit based on the current music climate.

[Draper.]

2 hours ago, smartalek22 said:

we want #143 on US Spotify 200 then

She already fell below that and she's not going up.