charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[Badgalbriel]

11 hours ago, Mrnoniee said:

Your graph and posts are super interesting and knowledgeable.
I remember seeing your posts in HIH going Viral Thread.
I love that you're all about facts, logic and stats 
----
which some stans will be having a hard time understanding
cause they were expecting this song to blow up (which they've been waiting for since 2011)

Hmmmm funny how you appreciate facts logic and stats only 👀

[penguintim]

Looming forward to the day 10 awards/hot 100 reveal following my voluntary 48 hour break from posting on the forum. I was with you all in spirit

[Bends]

Any news for Miss G?

[Xavi]

The song is great! let's take a drink and celebrate!

Edited November 4 by Xavi

[Plasticdoll]

35 minutes ago, toy soldier. said:

The song is not a hit, anyone who expected it to smash was deluding themselves.

It has none of the charm or catchiness of Monsters and BTW single, or of album tracks for that matter.

 

I don't know what the hell she was thinking 

 

the 80/100 critical acclaim says different and most peoples reactions. 

the only people I see being negative is ATRL Stans. most negative people on the planet

[Shaner69]

I have abs after all missed appointments with..  Laughs

 

Dr Dick. 

 

Let's go! 

[Loca]

Guys the wheel joke became unfunny ages ago

[Riverbank]

1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

I fear today's update will be a decline 

It's a Sunday update. Numbers will obviously collapse harder than the report button after being abused all week here

 

[Assassin]

50 minutes ago, Plasticdoll said:

the 80/100 critical acclaim says different and most peoples reactions. 

the only people I see being negative is ATRL Stans. most negative people on the planet

then why is the GP not streaming?

[Shaner69]

It's  fairly stable with numbers 🤣

[PMM]

6 minutes ago, Assassin said:

then why is the GP not streaming?

they have other songs too. And Disease sounds nothing like what's on radio right now. Also. people are hating on MAGA and GP are laughing at this thread and at OGH 

[ontherocks]

15 minutes ago, PMM said:

 Also. people are hating on MAGA and GP are laughing at this thread and at OGH 

Whut?

[Assassin]

24 minutes ago, PMM said:

Also. people are hating on MAGA and GP are laughing at this thread and at OGH 

Girl, what??

[Plasticdoll]

37 minutes ago, Assassin said:

then why is the GP not streaming?

In the UK most of the songs are tik tok viral hits. Songs chart based of tik tok and viral these days. I think it's done pretty well in this music climate and better than most pop girlies. I'm happy it even got top 10 atp. I know ZERO of the artists in the top 10

Edited November 4 by Plasticdoll

[PMM]

9 minutes ago, Assassin said:

Girl, what??

 

19 minutes ago, ontherocks said:

Whut?

people who don't care about the song are laughing at OGH and their research 

[Youngbae]

2 minutes ago, PMM said:

 

people who don't care about the song are laughing at OGH and their research 

If you go back to the 1st page, you'll see many, many Gaga fans "caring" about this song's success. And if you go back even further, you'll see many, many Gaga fans "caring" about FAD's Oscar potential and boxscore which was supposed to hit 1B in no time. Funny how no one "cares" about charts as soon as things start bombing.

Edited November 4 by Youngbae

[Plasticdoll]

Just now, Youngbae said:

So the song is loved by critics AND GP, right? Then why is it bombing? Not trolling, just trying to understand your point of view.

Well everyone seems to love it apart from the obvious fan bases. Plus she has DWAS which has been a huge success! I don't get why people say it's because of Bruno because Bruno hasn't had a hit in years. They both just happened to work amazing together. It's more GP friendly and moms can listen to it. Disease is a risky song, it's a great song but it's not what is charting atm or what's popular. It's 3:50 and most songs don't even barely go past 2.30 anymore due to people's attention span. I'm just happy she's given OUR fan base everything we wanted and more to come! 

[PMM]

4 minutes ago, Youngbae said:

If you go back to the 1st page, you'll see many, many Gaga fans "caring" about this song's success. And if you go back even further, you'll see many, many Gaga fans "caring" about FAD's Oscar potential and boxscore which was supposed to hit 1B in no time. Funny how no one "cares" about charts as soon as things start bombing.

yes, at first. now that's it's bombing the only people carrying this thread are OGH and few Gaga ones, when the update is green 

[Phoenix95]

I'm scared for today. 

[Youngbae]

3 minutes ago, Plasticdoll said:

Well everyone seems to love it apart from the obvious fan bases. Plus she has DWAS which has been a huge success! I don't get why people say it's because of Bruno because Bruno hasn't had a hit in years. They both just happened to work amazing together. It's more GP friendly and moms can listen to it. Disease is a risky song, it's a great song but it's not what is charting atm or what's popular. It's 3:50 and most songs don't even barely go past 2.30 anymore due to people's attention span. I'm just happy she's given OUR fan base everything we wanted and more to come! 

It's basically a Kim Petras leftover produced by a guy responsible for generic Ava Max hits. How is it risky?

[Plasticdoll]

Just now, Youngbae said:

It's basically a Kim Petras leftover produced by a guy responsible for generic Ava Max hits. How is it risky?

lol it sounds nothing like Kim Petras. you even listened to Kim? I cba reasoning with a hater 

[Me Against The Hits]

The conservatives are back at it again.. It's too dark and edgy for the GP

 

OP: Add that to the wheel of excuses! 

 

[HardBambi]

6 minutes ago, Phoenix95 said:

I'm scared for today. 

I'm ready for another song, so curious about the direction of the next single, will it be dance or a mid tempo or even a power-balad? #nojazz

[Youngbae]

17 minutes ago, Plasticdoll said:

lol it sounds nothing like Kim Petras. you even listened to Kim? I cba reasoning with a hater 

How does that make me a hater? Go check PopJustice, many people that like her compare it to early Kim tracks.

[Jon Snow]

30 minutes ago, PMM said:

 

people who don't care about the song are laughing at OGH and their research 

because it's funny