charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[OmegaRidley]

8 minutes ago, UnusualBoy said:

Some of you are so mean

 

Yeah, I know monsters can be a pest at times but the lashings have been horrible all through this thread  

At least we don't get personal 

 

the number of times I've been insulted of dumb, washed up, illiterate, ugly and more by monsters just over silly pop feuds is actually more alarming lmao

[DESOBEISSANCE]

2 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

They can't even come up with drags anymore, they outsource to ChatGPT

Just waiting for tomorrow luv xx

[Slap]

I'll never forget where I was when Lady Gaga's single "Disease" led to a 3000 post thread on ATRL. I was waiting for a Metra train, the air charged with tension. As I scrolled through ATRL, it felt like I was witnessing an emotional battleground—fans were in a frenzy, and the drama unfolded like a war, it hit me like a Metra train. 

 

Gaga always said her ArtPop could be anything, and perhaps this chaotic moment is exactly that. It's a vivid reminder that life is art, and this discourse embodies her message. I could barely concentrate on the train schedule as the discussion escalated, pulling me deeper into the intensity. This experience will stick with me, much like other significant moments in my life like 911. It's incredible how a single song can transform an ordinary day into something unforgettable, showcasing the powerful role art plays in shaping our lives.

[HonourableVomit]

6 minutes ago, DESOBEISSANCE said:

Just waiting for tomorrow luv xx

you've only made 4 posts of your 31 total on this site outside of Disease threads, perhaps tomorrow you should leave your house instead?   

[katykater]

1 hour ago, Edu said:

it just boggles my mind how many people think you must blindly be a fan of someone otherwise you're a hater

That's why the 2011-2013 stan war was so destructive. The monsters were attacking each other for not stanning exactly the same way like a monolith. In 2 years time it was proven by first week album sales that the monster population has dropped by 75% or was divided by 4.

Edited October 30 by katykater

[Iceland]

 

If Lady Gaga has already deployed those strategies and the single is still underperforming, it may be time to rethink the approach entirely. Here are next-level tactics that could disrupt the narrative and flip the situation in her favor:

 

1. Create a Cultural Disruption

 

• Gaga could drop a surprise project (like Beyoncé's self-titled album in 2013) — an EP or short film expanding the song's story could reframe the conversation.

• Alternatively, "retire" the single in a dramatic way—then re-release it later as a remix, acoustic version, or live performance. The unpredictability could generate new interest and conversation.

 

2. Collaborate Across Unexpected Genres or Spaces

 

• It might be time to break genre boundaries again. Partnering with someone completely unexpected—like a regional or underground artist (e.g., a Latin trap star, indie folk singer, or experimental producer)—could tap into niche markets.

• Crossover into film or fashion: If the music isn't catching fire, Gaga could incorporate the song into a fashion line launch or a movie soundtrack to give it a second wind (e.g., remember Shallow's impact).

 

3. Pivot the Narrative Completely

 

• Instead of chasing a hit, own the flop. Gaga could lean into self-deprecating humor and create a viral campaign around "the biggest flop of the year". This kind of meta commentary might attract curiosity and transform the song into a cult hit.

• Lean into controversy: If the song or video isn't generating buzz, Gaga could release a polarizing statement or reframe it as misunderstood art. Gaga has always thrived in moments where she was underestimated or written off.

 

4. Go Guerrilla and Subversive

 

• Gaga could launch an underground campaign—play pop-up shows in random public places or drop hand-made flyers across major cities with cryptic messaging tied to the song's themes.

• A mysterious digital campaign (e.g., unbranded ads, eerie Instagram posts, or a hidden website) could generate buzz, leading people to rediscover the single.

 

5. Collaborative Art Projects or Installations

 

• Partner with contemporary artists or museums to turn the single into a performance art installation or immersive experience. Make the release more than a song—it becomes a physical, shareable event.

 

6. Exclusive Fan-Only Events or Drops

 

• Gaga could create exclusive content for superfans—like private virtual concerts or secret shows—available only to those who stream or engage with the single.

• Introduce limited-edition merch tied to the single. For instance, Gaga could design weird, collectible items that feel like art pieces (imagine something bizarre, like a perfume tied to the theme of the song).

 

7. Use AI and Technology for a Unique Experience

 

• Gaga could embrace AI-generated content, creating alternate versions of the single (like AI-generated remixes) or custom fan experiences where listeners get personalized songs or art based on their data.

 

8. Shock with a Controversial Performance or Appearance

 

• Perform something so outrageous that it demands public attention. Gaga has never shied away from controversy—she could use a provocative live performance at a high-profile event to reignite interest in the song.

• Disrupt traditional media: Take over an entire talk show, do an interview in character, or stage a wild public stunt that aligns with the song's themes.

 

9. Let the Single Go and Move on to the Next Era

 

• Sometimes the best move is to cut losses and move on to the next big project. Gaga could pivot to a new single or album—building on the themes of the previous one but with a fresh perspective.

• Reframe the failure: Publicly acknowledge that not every song will be a hit, but promise something groundbreaking in the next phase. Fans often admire honesty and vulnerability.

 

10. Turn the Moment into a Legacy Play

 

• If all else fails, Gaga can reframe the single as "ahead of its time" or an artistic statement that wasn't meant to be mainstream. Over time, some of her most polarizing work has been reappreciated (Artpop, for example).

 

Final Thoughts

 

Flopping in the charts doesn't have to define the success of the project—Gaga is an artist first, and sometimes it's more about making a cultural statement than achieving instant commercial success. She has the power to turn the flop into a cultural phenomenon, either by owning it, disrupting the conversation, or shifting gears entirely. In the end, Gaga's legacy isn't tied to just one single—it's about the larger narrative she creates.

[Heysexy]

Wrong wrong wrong everything is wrong nothing is right. Disease ft Tyler the creator would be weird but would help but solo gaga is a flop it seems

Edited October 30 by Heysexy

[VeniceBeach]

7 minutes ago, Iceland said:

• Instead of chasing a hit, own the flop.

[JO1s]

12 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

you've only made 4 posts of your 31 total on this site outside of Disease threads, perhaps tomorrow you should leave your house instead?   

Dragging someone for 31 posts while you have 13k posts on this site and telling them touch grass... like the call is coming from inside the house.

[HonourableVomit]

1 minute ago, JO1s said:

Dragging someone for 31 posts while you have 13k posts on this site and telling them touch grass... like the call is coming from inside the house.

Read again! I'm actually dragging them for their hyperfixation on this one topic!  

 

And my average of 2 posts per day since registration is actually less than yours (12.5)!

[Darkroth]

2 hours ago, ithinkheknowsoutsold said:

Greece the female Norway confirmed?

That is due to my promo and listens 

[Orsay]

This ******* thread

[JO1s]

6 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

Read again! I'm actually dragging them for their hyperfixation on this one topic!  

 

And my average of 2 posts per day since registration is actually less than yours (12.5)!

God forbid an OGH has hobbies

[Toxic.Latin]

what colour of dress should i get for tomorrow sixth day update awards?

 

 

 

 

[Acuminatus]

This thread is soooo funny, how is ATRL membership free? 

 

I still enjoy the song, but the lashings here are WILD. 

 

I liked the MV at first, her outfits and makeup are great, but there isn't too much replay ability for me because the MV doesn't go anywhere.

 

1 hour ago, starboy1 said:

US Apple Music: #115. (+6)

 

ohh? its NOT funny yo

 

Is the MV finally having an effect? 

Time for everyone to wear green tomorrow! 

Edited October 31 by Acuminatus

[brazil]

I liked the MV 

 

[DESOBEISSANCE]

 

38 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

you've only made 4 posts of your 31 total on this site outside of Disease threads, perhaps tomorrow you should leave your house instead?   

I don't know if you have an idea that phones evolved since 2008. Must be tiring to pretend that computers are still running Windows 7, Obama is the president and Lady Gaga is in the top of the world. If you heard about ChatGPT, you probably heard about 5G and other stuff

 

Edited October 31 by DESOBEISSANCE

[EndofASadMovie]

What happened to Kindness Punks

Mother Monster is watching you

[katykater]

9 minutes ago, Toxic.Latin said:

what colour of dress should i get for tomorrow sixth day update awards?

 

 

 

 

It looks like a stock in a descending trend:

 

[Toxic.Latin]

1 minute ago, katykater said:

It looks like a stock in a descending trend:

 

but liddos told me that she was a viral hit on X

 

[ROARyals]

30 mins little diseases! Let's go!!

 

 

[Alongoria13]

54 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said:

you've only made 4 posts of your 31 total on this site outside of Disease threads, perhaps tomorrow you should leave your house instead?   

Ever heard of remote working/mobile data xx

[CoolNebraskaGuy]

10 minutes ago, katykater said:

It looks like a stock in a descending trend:

 

Do one for I'm His, He's Mine ft. Doechii next!! 

[Triton]

1 hour ago, Weld_E said:

Oh we are talking facts?

 

Gaga is pushing 40 and is irrelevant to the GP generating no interest unless she collabs with a bigger artist. There is NO interest in her solo material as proven by the aysmal numbers this song is pulling. At her old age, she has been a part of one of the biggest bombs in box office history and is currently experiencing this embarrassing chart run for her solo lead single. She is a two album wonder with a slight resurgence thanks to a movie smashing 6 years ago.

 

And those are the facts sweetie

Drag it!

[Tistotal]

9 minutes ago, CoolNebraskaGuy said:

Do one for I'm His, He's Mine ft. Doechii next!! 

Wrong topic sis

 

Can't wait to wear green tomorrow!