charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, rebeltwat said:

As much as I love seeing the girlies smash, you guys are doing yourselves such a disservice by caring this much about commercial success  the song and video are obviously a return to form for her and she's killing it. The rest shouldn't matter.

Let's not act as if charts is not what people care about the most on this site 

 

This song/video being a "return to form" to her is also highly questionnable. Otherwise it wouldn't bomb this hard.

Edited October 30 by Enrique523

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, YasIconic said:

this thread 

 

all y'all closeted monsters need a visit to the BTW bus to check on ur mental health 

 

 

 

 

By this logic i guess all the liddos that ran in Katy's 143 thread are closeted Katycats?

[Shaner69]

2 minutes ago, DESOBEISSANCE said:

I wonder how much of her 100 million listeners is listening to the song

 

Can't believe people forgot she's the most listened female artist on Spotify

 

Monthly listeners doesn't mean anything. I know it sounds wierd but it actuality doesn't. It's only because a song played she's on from a playlist. It doesn't mean they are streaming her music. 

[Edu]

i'm sorry but the video is objectively bad

most liddos are pretending to like it bc otherwise they would have to accept defeat

[znake]

8 minutes ago, Enrique523 said:

By this logic i guess all the liddos that ran in Katy's 143 thread are closeted Katycats?

they are so hypocrite     closeted Katycats !   

 

Disis video is terrible,  i prefer stupid love 

[Edu]

it's just sad how she went from this

to this really

 

[BrokenMachine]

11 minutes ago, DESOBEISSANCE said:

I wonder how much of her 100 million listeners is listening to the song

 

Can't believe people forgot she's the most listened female artist on Spotify

 

Let's pretend a different stream comes from a different person. 2M daily streams * 30 days = 60M people. Everything's fine. Nothing to worry about

 

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

1 hour ago, gettsleazy said:

Wasn't Woman's World doing like, 500k by day 6? Why are Kats acting brave when this is a pretty solid debut

1.2 million actually, and that one fell by just 23,000 streams on day 5. Disease fell by 10X that amount. I'm not even a Kat but this is just too funny.

 

 

[Edu]

1 minute ago, ithinkheknowsoutsold said:

the way she probably thought she was serving by making that face

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

Thinking how at the start of this week we were all wondering if this could go top 15 on the Hot 100, and then it went from there to top 20 to top 30 to top 40 and now to top 50. Radio is her only saving grace now.

Edited October 30 by ithinkheknowsoutsold

[rickycabello123]

logically 50% of her monthly listeners now are from die with a smile audience, lets just focus spread the disease at tiktok & reels

[L.B GAGA]

The video is actually good. I'm now interested im the album as a whole, to know how it works together, i also wonder what inspires the era.

Is it  the movie or just her own struggles? 

 

The video is a good sign She better execute the era well to completion,nice story, no meltdowns but a fierce strong professional gaga regardless of the charts. And it will age well like Joanne. 

Edited October 30 by L.B GAGA

[Glam]

1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Liddos using Gaga's ATRL pages as a defense...just when i thought Liddos have finally reached rock bottom

 

someone please update the wheel of excuses 

Don't you stan Katy Perry though?

 

OT: Gaga her experimental song and video don't need the approval of the GP.

[Andraslop]

1 hour ago, Weld_E said:

Not some lidusionals claiming her team released this knowing it won't be a hit because it sounds 'different' 

 

It seems the plan was quite the opposite. They banked on Joker 2 being a hit,  with her "unhinged" and "psychotic" Harley winning praise. Disease was set to smoothly bridge from a blockbuster film into her dark pop revival, carrying over the themes of madness and asylum they assumed would captivate audiences.

 

They never anticipated her to serve OUT-FLOP-BOMB.

The MV was filmed 3 weeks ago, literally AFTER the JFAD bomb. So didn't banked on Joker 2 being a hit.

[Breathe On Moi]

"don't need the approval of the GP" …..slap it on the wheel! 
 

[YasIconic]

29 minutes ago, Enrique523 said:

By this logic i guess all the liddos that ran in Katy's 143 thread are closeted Katycats?

Katy Perry recruited her ex friend's rapist to record a faux feminist anthem and has been queerbaiting during this whole era. Hope that helps

[Katamari]

3 hours ago, Breathe On Moi said:

baby you're spiraling 

 

🌀

 

that weeknd voodoo at it again

 

[Toxic.Latin]

2 minutes ago, Breathe On Moi said:

"don't need the approval of the GP" …..slap it on the wheel! 
 

the video is a MESS

[znake]

Just now, YasIconic said:

Katy Perry recruited her ex friend's rapist to record a faux feminist anthem and has been queerbaiting during this whole era. Hope that helps

  the excuses pretending to like it , suffer in silence!

[L.B GAGA]

2 minutes ago, Toxic.Latin said:

the video is a MESS

No actually its good, well executed. Good dancing and shock factor, Its perfection. Stupid love was her worst. 

[Liafen]

1 hour ago, BrokenMachine said:

The top 4 posters having +60 posts, and they're not even her fans 

Humiliating 

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

Someone add 'Katy worked with a rapist' to the excuses wheel.

[Toxic.Latin]

Just now, L.B GAGA said:

No actually its good, well executed. Good dancing and shock factor, Its perfection. Stupid love was her worst. 

im sorry but no. maybe it would have worked in her BTW days, now those are the same old ass gimmicks.

[Sadie Saxton]

25 minutes ago, ithinkheknowsoutsold said:

Thinking how at the start of this week we were all wondering if this could go top 15 on the Hot 100, and then it went from there to top 20 to top 30 to top 40 and now to top 50. Radio is her only saving grace now.

The ultimate kii would be a #63 debut

 

[L.B GAGA]

12 minutes ago, Toxic.Latin said:

im sorry but no. maybe it would have worked in her BTW days, now those are the same old ass gimmicks.

Nope its not an old gimmick, we have to stop being too critical of Gaga. 

Gaga is simply dark and cutsy(BTW, AHS Gaga) when she wants, cutsy during her Jazz eras, The Fame(eh eh nothing else i can say), Joanne era and DWAS. 

Let us give her flowers, when she deserves it, the song is def not radio friendly, way better than stupid love but the video elevates it, also its Gaga executing her work well than the iphone stupid love mess. 

Trust me ive seen worse from Gaga 

 

Edited October 30 by L.B GAGA