charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[Smarticle]

I see a huge OGH circlejerk when it's not even that bad of a debut ? 

[HASHTAGPOW]

Well I -

 

[Movimento Perpétuo]

12 minutes ago, KOMH said:

Germany:

#52 (new) Disease - 162,972

 

France:

#70 (new) Disease - 130,838

 

Netherlands:

#57 (new) Disease - 66,330

 

Austria:

#53 (new) Disease - 14,856

 

Belgium:

#49 (new) Disease - 24,717

 

New Zealand

#78 (new) Disease - 12,697

 

Australia:

#52 (new) Disease - 96,134

 

Canada:

#17 (new) Disease - 137,321

 

Mexico:

N/A in the top 200

 

Indonesia:

N/A in the top 200

 

Philippines:

N/A in the top 200

 

Global card REVOKED.

Damn. Basically Brazil and UK carried the numbers

[Gelato]

No music video

No TTH residency

No promo

No performances

No talk show appearances

No revealing interviews

No magazine/newspaper profiles

No paid for social media engagement

Audience satiation with SMASH HIT DWAS

Before radio impact date

Alternative avant garde electrocrash not for the charts composition

Mere weeks after Todd Phillips' sabotage act

 

Oh lady GODGA

[Colmillo]

3 minutes ago, brazil said:

2024 to liddos: keep expectations low so you won't be disappointed 

 

Literally most liddos were expecting 4-4.5M

 

 

[State of Grace.]

Is that on par with DWAS? That's not bad. US numbers are terrible however. These numbers are expected because they match its performance on Apple Music tbh. 

 

She should be doing 5M-6M though. Sure, Stupid Love was riding the ASIB hype but it also leaked 6 weeks early and Spotify users have grown a lot since 2020. I'm not sure if Harlequin actually killed some of the hype or something.

 

Release Notorious Being for that 20M debut

Edited October 26 by State of Grace.

[Doctor Dick]

44 minutes ago, Starshine said:

Well

 

Well what? 
 

Texas Hold 'Em: 4.2M 

Disease: 4.4M

 

[Assassin]

1 minute ago, FrederickGa said:

By a hairline

 

Now if she debuted with like 49% of DWAS numbers then it wouldve been an unarguably #ThankYouBruno situation 

2 minutes ago, Windy Day said:

by ~100k. the one that bruno brought to the debut numbers since stupid love also did over 4M

 

But what happened to all those monthly Spotify listeners?
 

[bliaz]

16 minutes ago, Assassin said:

 

GagaDaily right now

 

 

[OrgVisual]

2 minutes ago, Windy Day said:

mind you beyoncé's last lead single debuted with LESS than disease even though she got superbowl promo

THE was a SURPRISE RELEASE on midnight Sunday / Monday and it boasted excellent AM numbers (#2 on the charts) while Disease still can't reach top 50

 

Even Jolene - Beyonce's album track debuted with more streams than Disease lmao

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

4 minutes ago, perfect blue said:

with double the playlisting

 

not Katy Perry being the bar for liddos now 

 

Do you really want to talk about the promo for both songs cuz....

[Iuke]

5 minutes ago, OrgVisual said:

It's not bad if the Liddos didn't paint Gaga as big of an artist on the same level as Taylor, Ariana, Rihanna, Beyonce etc.

i feel like she is as big culturally. debut numbers are useless as they only show you how big the diehard fans are

[Toxic.Latin]

1 minute ago, Gelato said:

No music video

No TTH residency

No promo

No performances

No talk show appearances

No revealing interviews

No magazine/newspaper profiles

No paid for social media engagement

Audience satiation with SMASH HIT DWAS

Before radio impact date

Alternative avant garde electrocrash not for the charts composition

Mere weeks after Todd Phillips' sabotage act

 

Oh lady GODGA

Can you add a $200 Million movie with a WW millionaire marketing campaign? 

[Goofy]

I'm shook even though I expected it. I told yall she cut her own hype short with that Harleyquinn nonsense

[TedMiracle]

LaFlop

[FrederickGa]

4 minutes ago, By the Water said:

Ga Ga sold her album for 99 cents and bundled it with jockstraps 

 

Just because that didn't stop her from tanking doesn't mean it didn't come from a place of chart greediness

Yeah but she's like 1% Chart Greedy compared to Taylor's 99% Chart Greedy

[Solaria]

I really honestly think that overexposure might have something to do with it. Not overexposure from Gaga´s side, but moreso from the pop landscape as a whole. There have been SO many good releases this year, and we have Bruno, Sabrina, Chappell, Charli and now the BP Solo´s all hogging up the airwaves. It´s a much more competitive field than February 2020 when she only had Blinding Lights and DSN to compete with.

[Navyofbadgals]

Even worse is this not even having 2M views on YT so far either  I'd really love to know what the thought process is of not releasing the MV, or at least announcing when you're releasing it. 
With Christmas songs coming up sooner rather than later, an artist of her caliber is far better off focusing on a big debut now

Edited October 26 by Navyofbadgals

[Uncatena]

I mean it's not an ideal "GAG, A SMASHA!!" scenario but painting this as a giant flop is straight up delusional imo. its a bit underwhelming, but I hope she has promo line up or maybe like... a tweet even lmao. the music video needs to come very soon though. 

 

also, this might be the little medonster in my talking but this era already feels more like fan service than anything. 

Edited October 26 by Uncatena

[Starshine]

Just now, Doctor Dick said:

Well what? 
 

Texas Hold 'Em: 4.2M 

Disease: 4.4M

 

1m in the US and poor Apple Music performance is not looking cute for a Hot 100 debut.

 

[Assassin]

2 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

Well what? 
 

Texas Hold 'Em: 4.2M 

Disease: 4.4M

 

USA:
Disease: 1.1M
Texas Hold' Em: 2.37M

[FrederickGa]

Bigger than SL numbers wise but worse chart performance wise considering Spotify's growth

 

Now let's aim for better stability 

[Blue Monday]

7 minutes ago, Windy Day said:

mind you beyoncé's last lead single debuted with LESS than disease even though she got superbowl promo

1. On a Sunday night/Monday and then proceeded to grow over the next few days (let's hope for y'alls sake that Disease can do the same)

2. So you admit, Beyoncé is the bar? Interesting because Gaga fans have been trying to insist that the opposite is true

Edited October 26 by Blue Monday

[Rotunda]

22 minutes ago, FrederickGa said:

The Beyonce SNEAK when CC BOMBED harder than Artpop chartwise and No.1 song Texas Hold Em is already at Telephone daily Spotify Streams level..

 

But gotta give to Beyonce for having a loyal fanbase and great Media Propaganda Machine

You needing to dig back to 2011 to find an album to compare a 2024 album's numbers to is a drag in and of itself. 

[Gelato]

2 minutes ago, Toxic.Latin said:

Can you add a $200 Million movie with a WW millionaire marketing campaign? 

Quote

Mere weeks after Todd Phillips' sabotage act

.