itshyolee Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Mariah clears EASILY. This song alone tops whatever the hell Madonna was releasing 7 2 2
naval23 Posted October 26 Posted October 26 It's surprising she has 3 UK #1s only, but they came through with stanning "Through the Rain"
Miss Show Business Posted October 26 Posted October 26 E=MC² vs Hard Candy Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel vs MDNA Me. I Am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse vs Rebel Heart (tied only because the RH era would have been nearly perfect without the leaks and Madonna ruining many of the tracks; those Avicii versions are tops) Caution vs Madame X Mariah wins for me but only by two entries. I think Hard Candy and Rebel Heart were the best of Madonna's post 2005 albums.
Letters From Adi Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Madge got complacent after COADF, the downgrade in quality from ROL-Music is clearly visible. 1
The7thStranger Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Hard Candy, E=MC2, and Caution are all perfectly fine records, IMO. MDNA and Rebel Heart could have been great but weren't finished properly, so their execution leaves a lot to be desired. Madame X is unlistenable. I don't like Memoirs and didn't even bother Elusive Chanteuse, so I can't judge tha tone. Mariah wins on albums; Madonna wins on tours for me.
Nightingale Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Mariah easily. I love Hard Candy. MDNA is ok and has some bangers. Rebel Heart is one of the worst albums I've heard. Madame X is not bad but it's not my personal preference I love E=MC2, Memoirs, Caution. MIAM has some hits and misses but overall not bad
blown away Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Mariah easily, she hasn't released anything that comes close to the atrocities that MDNA and Madame X are. Outside of MIAM she released quality albums only. Album by album: E=MC² Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel Rebel Heart Caution 1
JBJT2786 Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Mariah. E=MC² was a banger and I loved Caution. I liked Hard Candy but everything esle after ( especially Madame X) was bad minus a few songs.
EnigmaticAndroid Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Mariah. Madonna completely lost the plot after COADF.
HardBambi Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Rebel heart is better than anything mentioned here by Mimi and so is Hard Cake 1 2
ithinkheknowsoutsold Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Caution is better than anything mentioned here by Madge and so is Einstein 1
stevyy Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Albums per streams: Madonna 518,925,797 - Hard Candy 300,561,021 - Rebel Heart 233,117,691 - Madame X 165,161,103 - MDNA =1,217,765,612 Mariah: 642,688,212 - Memoirs 425,945,892 - E=MC² 194,047,349 - Me. I am Mariah 139,023,371 - Caution = 1,401,704,824 2 1
Charmed Life Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Sorry, but Madonna wins by a landslide in terms of diversity alone, but leave it to those holding a very bitter grudge to flock these kind of threads to vote for anyone she's pitted against. 2 1
HardBambi Posted October 26 Posted October 26 9 minutes ago, stevyy said: Albums per streams: Madonna 518,925,797 - Hard Candy 300,561,021 - Rebel Heart 233,117,691 - Madame X 165,161,103 - MDNA =1,217,765,612 Mariah: 642,688,212 - Memoirs 425,945,892 - E=MC² 194,047,349 - Me. I am Mariah 139,023,371 - Caution = 1,401,704,824 Same level of flop tbh (they actually all deserved so much more) 4
Kiss It Better Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Caution >>>>> Memoirs > MIAMTEC > Rebel Heart > Hard Candy > MDNA > EMC2 > Madame X
stevyy Posted October 26 Posted October 26 14 minutes ago, HardBambi said: Same level of flop tbh (they actually all deserved so much more) imagine, the streaming era girls, debut with one of their songs from their album already being at 500 million streams or so and then amass so many streams that their albums hit 1 billion in the first month. But we should not frown. Our girls' streams are better than the streaming era girls sales ever could be.
HardBambi Posted October 26 Posted October 26 1 hour ago, stevyy said: imagine, the streaming era girls, debut with one of their songs from their album already being at 500 million streams or so and then amass so many streams that their albums hit 1 billion in the first month. But we should not frown. Our girls' streams are better than the streaming era girls sales ever could be. Plus I guess Mariah and Madonna are doing the best out if the big divas (Celine, Whitney, Janet)
tost1 Posted October 26 Posted October 26 3 hours ago, stevyy said: Albums per streams: Madonna 518,925,797 - Hard Candy 300,561,021 - Rebel Heart 233,117,691 - Madame X 165,161,103 - MDNA =1,217,765,612 Mariah: 642,688,212 - Memoirs 425,945,892 - E=MC² 194,047,349 - Me. I am Mariah 139,023,371 - Caution = 1,401,704,824 Nobody asked
stevyy Posted October 26 Posted October 26 2 hours ago, HardBambi said: Plus I guess Mariah and Madonna are doing the best out if the big divas (Celine, Whitney, Janet) yes, by far. Estimation of Spotify totals for 2024 1,6 billion - Madonna 1,1 billion* - Mariah 900 million - Whitney 800 million - Céline 150 million - Janet *we know what is still to come. Madonna and Mariah may end 2024 with 2 billion on Spotify each. 2
ChooseyLover Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Out of these Madonna albums, I only enjoyed Hard Candy and Rebel Heart... Mariah got me hooked on with every single one.
HardBambi Posted October 26 Posted October 26 2 hours ago, stevyy said: yes, by far. Estimation of Spotify totals for 2024 1,6 billion - Madonna 1,1 billion* - Mariah 900 million - Whitney 800 million - Céline 150 million - Janet *we know what is still to come. Madonna and Mariah may end 2024 with 2 billion on Spotify each. Poor Janet OMG Great to see Madonna first she's had a good year And yes of course Mimi will smash with Xmas around the corner
Recommended Posts