PYT Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) Will she still stubbornly stick with her pop-rock/punk sound or move on to a new sound for OR3? What kind of sound would you want her to explore? Imagine her doing pure pop like Ari... Edited October 22 by PYT 2 2
Gelato Posted October 22 Posted October 22 i hope not, GUTS is an incredible album. it's not a 91 on metacritic for no reason 8
PYT Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 10 minutes ago, Gelato said: i hope not, GUTS is an incredible album. it's not a 91 on metacritic for no reason I prefer SOUR >>> I know I'm in the minority! 1
thatsmydemi Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) Not really. All she should do is distance from the angry teen pop/punk-rock sound and transition into a more sophisticated and mature rock/alt sound. The collapse if she served something as good as this. Edited October 22 by thatsmydemi 1
JoJo Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) She should stick with rock even though the genre isn't GP friendly since it helps her stand out from the rest of the pop girls. But she should also move on from her current pop punk sound and explore other subgenres of rock. A folk rock or a new wave album would be great. Edited October 22 by JoJo 1
Venice B Posted October 22 Posted October 22 GUTS is so ******* good I wouldn't mind if she kept the same sound
NumbSoul Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Hopefully! I loved GUTS, but she needs to switch it up. Doesn't need to be some huge switch, but definitely something fresh and new for her. GUTS and SOUR felt a little too similar.
aesthetic bih Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Guts > Sour Sure, Sour has Deja Vu but Guts is just overall a more enjoyable album 1
Megan Pete Posted October 22 Posted October 22 We don't need her doing dated Max Martin'd pop, there's already 200 girls who serve that. She should move on from poprock though if she doesn't want to tank
Solaria Posted October 22 Posted October 22 I'm 100 % convinced that So American is a teaser of the new album in terms of sound. I think it's gonna be much more upbeat. Possibly new wave inspired. 1
PoisonPill Posted October 22 Posted October 22 45 minutes ago, thatsmydemi said: Not really. All she should do is distance from the angry teen pop/punk-rock sound and transition into a more sophisticated and mature rock/alt sound. The collapse if she served something as good as this. This. Pop-rock is a good fit for her, but the bratty teen aesthetic is wearing very thin and she needs to move on if she wants longevity as an adult artist.
Parachutes Posted October 22 Posted October 22 34 minutes ago, JoJo said: She should stick with rock even though the genre isn't GP friendly since it helps her stand out from the rest of the pop girls. But she should also move on from her current pop punk sound and explore other subgenres of rock. A folk rock or a new wave album would be great. 16 minutes ago, XIAN said: more deja vu, less brutal Yeah would love for her to lean into a more psychedelic or shoegaze sound (or new wave or jangle pop; somewhere under that umbrella). She kinda dabbled with it on pretty isn't pretty as well and I think it'd be a natural progression that still keeps things distinctive Also sometime in the future I think a more folk-oriented release could be cool as well. Songs like stranger, girl i've always been, even her Stick Season cover show that it suits her really well (but it'd maybe be less commercially palatable) 2
vuelve88 Posted October 22 Posted October 22 I hope so. I lost all interest when she just extended the theme from Sour. It didn't feel like growth or an improvement, and Guts didn't have any of the replay value that the first album had.
Joey307 Posted October 22 Posted October 22 GUTS is good but definitely a SOUR pt 2. Even the album cover looks like it could be from the same shot as SOUR was. Same sound, same topics. If it ain't broke, don't fix it, but considering that SOUR was much bigger than GUTS maybe a change is warranted.
XIAN Posted October 22 Posted October 22 5 minutes ago, Parachutes said: Yeah would love for her to lean into a more psychedelic or shoegaze sound (or new wave or jangle pop; somewhere under that umbrella). She kinda dabbled with it on pretty isn't pretty as well and I think it'd be a natural progression that still keeps things distinctive Also sometime in the future I think a more folk-oriented release could be cool as well. Songs like stranger, girl i've always been, even her Stick Season cover show that it suits her really well (but it'd maybe be less commercially palatable) i love shoegaze 1
GloryDays Posted October 22 Posted October 22 She has to go back to her deja vu bag and try others genres of rock
Breathe On Moi Posted October 22 Posted October 22 she needs some rap features her pop that pumpum era
SpaceOddity Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Next album should be more alternative rock and new wave than teen angst pop punk, think Paramore's last two records (yeah, I know, the irony lol).
AvadaKedavra Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) Sour was her Fearless Guts was her Speak Now (Showing growth-skills as a songwriter) (Both highly influenced by pop rock) The next one should be her Red. Experimentation with different genres but without goin too overly manufactured. Synthpop/Folk/Rock/Ballads..... But please show something different visual wise. Its interesting when pop singers have a style change Edited October 22 by AvadaKedavra 2
Recommended Posts