VeniceBeach Posted October 26 Posted October 26 3 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: Didnt you and other liddos do the same with Woman's World? Katy deserved all the lashings because she released a tedious song produced by a rapist, while Gaga is miles ahead artistically and she's not going back to the rapist in a desperate attempt to get a hit. She's putting out something fresh, acclaimed and exciting and I know it hurts you to see how much more quality is there compared to your washed up fave. How's the album and her collab with the very famous sample is doing btw? 11 3
DawnAnti Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Katyf@ds are so brave in this thread like imagine stanning someone like katy and speaking numbers 4
Klein Posted October 26 Posted October 26 I finally had the time to listen to the song on the train back home... this is SO GOOD DAAAAAMN Makes me super excited for the album, she really understood the assignment. This is eons better than anything she released after Born This Way (Venus excluded). Absolutely love it. 2
Phoenix95 Posted October 26 Posted October 26 It's growing on me but why is it flopping? It's the lead single…
Europe Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Report the trolls and move on They are more excited for the numbers than we are
Spark Posted October 26 Posted October 26 5 minutes ago, DonnaSpring said: Madonna has not been a legacy act since 2005, Hard Candy was a major MPG album and MDNA moreso with superbowl and pushing Gimmie all your luvin even 2015 Madonna promoted rebel heart like crazy You're right about Hard Candy, 4 Minutes was massive. I'm not coming for Madonna, she's the queen of pop but she was definitely a legacy act by MDNA (and that's ok!). Headlining the Super Bowl and/or promoting an album like crazy doesn't mean you're not a legacy act. By 2012, people were going to Madonna's concerts to hear the old material rather than the tours namesake and that's ok. 1
redsbae Posted October 26 Posted October 26 To put things into perspective… when Beyonce was 16 years into her career she released "self titled". Madonna 16 years into her career gave us "ray of light" gaga is 16 years into her career and isn't making the impact or "art" I think we expected. I'm underwhelmed . I guess I just expected more 13
Pop Posted October 26 Posted October 26 1 minute ago, Phoenix95 said: It's growing on me but why is it flopping? It's the lead single… Too many years of doing side projects such as movies, jazz, random covers and HAC ballads resulted in her core fanbase slowly diminishing. By trying to become the jack of all trades, she became the master of none. 3
Spark Posted October 26 Posted October 26 (edited) 5 minutes ago, redsbae said: The general public doesn't even know the song exists. Just wait for the Spotify and Apple Music numbers. Without a major collab or payola, Gaga really isn't able to deliver a "smash" …How does this respond to anything I said in my post though? I don't think the song will be a smash, but I don't think it means she should just not release music anymore. Edited October 26 by Spark
jijie101 Posted October 26 Posted October 26 24 minutes ago, katara said: Lack of "with Bruno Mars" in the title HOUDINI peaked outside 100 on US AM, I don't think a Dua stan should come for anyone in terms of AM numbers
redsbae Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, Spark said: You're right about Hard Candy, 4 Minutes was massive. I'm not coming for Madonna, she's the queen of pop but she was definitely a legacy act by MDNA (and that's ok!). Headlining the Super Bowl and/or promoting an album like crazy doesn't mean you're not a legacy act. By 2012, people were going to Madonna's concerts to hear the old material rather than the tours namesake and that's ok. Comparing Madonna and Gaga is hilarious. Madonna made "ray of light" 16 years into her career and released "music" in her 40s. She was still reinventing herself and a major force. Gaga isn't giving that AT ALL 1 5
Mirkomonster Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, redsbae said: To put things into perspective… when Beyonce was 16 years into her career she released "self titled". Madonna 16 years into her career gave us "ray of light" gaga is 16 years into her career and isn't making the impact or "art" I think we expected. I'm underwhelmed . I guess I just expected more Nobody cares
Mariano Posted October 26 Posted October 26 24 minutes ago, katara said: Lack of "with Bruno Mars" in the title damn why is it always the stans of washed up hasbeens... and no I'm not talking abotu Dua Lipa. Your fav was already on her way OUT when Gaga debuted, it's not Gaga's fault her career is over and she is a talentless JOKE. When will y'all get over the fact that Gaga's peak happeend at the same time as y'all favs last hurrah? And when will y'all understand that it wasn't Gaga's fault and your favs were still gonna be OUT in a few years anyway..!? 1 1
redsbae Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, Mirkomonster said: Nobody cares About Gaga's music? Unfortunately I have to agree with you on this 10
Europe Posted October 26 Posted October 26 6 minutes ago, redsbae said: The general public doesn't even know the song exists. Just wait for the Spotify and Apple Music numbers. Without a major collab or payola, Gaga really isn't able to deliver a "smash" 22 minutes ago, redsbae said: Gaga's team wasn't expecting this rollout. Joker 2 was supposed to be at about 600 million grossing by now, the Bruno mars collab smashing, and critics praising her performance in the film. Unfortunately the film flopped and set her back… way back. Here are my predictions album- 170k first week and eventually gold (with a lot of payola and strings pulled). Sorry Gaga. just think it's best to be a legacy act at this point. 16 minutes ago, redsbae said: But when the material isn't well received, innovative, fresh, or fun… maybe so? 15 minutes ago, redsbae said: As a legacy act she sure can! 13 minutes ago, redsbae said: Makes sense. Gaga is still a talent but I feel she's lost her passion for pop and dance music. Her efforts feel lost. Where she used to create the trends, it seems she's trying desperately to find her place. 10 minutes ago, redsbae said: It's just my opinion. The song will underperform. The second single will be a collab with popular artist (to give her a boost as her solo efforts fail) and the album will … well you'll see. Being delusional doesn't change what's inevitable. Here is the attention you want. Now GTFO 1 1
Yonceage Posted October 26 Posted October 26 5 minutes ago, Phoenix95 said: It's growing on me but why is it flopping? It's the lead single… The numbers aren't out. Wdym it's flopping?
Mirkomonster Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, redsbae said: About Gaga's music? Unfortunately I have to agree with you on this considering She has the biggest Song from 8 weeks, i have to disagree
Spark Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, redsbae said: Comparing Madonna and Gaga is hilarious. Madonna made "ray of light" 16 years into her career and released "music" in her 40s. She was still reinventing herself and a major force. Gaga isn't giving that AT ALL I'm not comparing Gaga and Madonna. Reading comprehension skills? I'm saying that just because you reach "legacy act" status doesn't mean you have to stop producing music. Madonna still does, Mariah does, Katy does, Britney did etc etc. This is all a moot point anyways considering Gaga is currently sitting in the Top 5 of Billboard as I type this.
redsbae Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, Europe said: Here is the attention you want. Now GTFO You seem to Stan me more than Gaga. I'm flattered. Please stream the song! I'm hoping for a top #10 debut before free fall 4
Mariano Posted October 26 Posted October 26 18 minutes ago, redsbae said: As a legacy act she sure can! So you're saying your fav is NEITHER relevant today NOR a legacy act? DAMN
redsbae Posted October 26 Posted October 26 Just now, Mirkomonster said: considering She has the biggest Song from 8 weeks, i have to disagree Thanks to Bruno and payola lol. If her solo song doesn't mirror this success then it's obvious why the song is "smashing" . Bruno also has another "hit" collab out as well but Gaga isn't doing well on her own. He carried that song. 8
Human Fly Posted October 26 Posted October 26 9 minutes ago, perfectillusion204 said: I actually think they are hoping DWAS will hit #1 next week because the vinyl has shipped and everyone will receive it this upcoming week. I think video is gonna come on Fri. Nov 1 at this point, to not interfere with DWAS. Then why they released this song now and ruined it for fans if they werent going to do anything for this one? I cant even tell or explain how disappointed i am about this rollout. Absolutely crickets 🦗 Releasing music video or anything wont have any effect after first week, this is not 2011. We're entering never ending religious holiday starting from november first. Thank you godga yet another lead single ruined. 1
Recommended Posts