Vespertine Posted October 19 Posted October 19 On 10/17/2024 at 2:21 PM, LegaMyth said: I don't like the whole "melody is songwriting thing." I'm not blaming her, but lyrics are completely different. Someone has to think of and write the lyrics. I think melodies should be part of vocal production. My opinion … creating a melody literally is songwriting though You realize there is a whole world of music without lyrics, right? Do you think instrumental music writes itself? 2
ericcartman Posted October 19 Posted October 19 On 10/17/2024 at 2:21 PM, LegaMyth said: I don't like the whole "melody is songwriting thing." I'm not blaming her, but lyrics are completely different. Someone has to think of and write the lyrics. I think melodies should be part of vocal production. My opinion Doesn't matter what you think, composing a melody is songwriting. Having said that, she didn't write the melody either. The "operatic bridge" is the same melody as the demo, she just vocalized "oooh oooh" over it. She deserves vocal production credit and I guess these days that equates to productions credits too.
mons†er Posted October 19 Posted October 19 Another day and another thread where people on ATRL do not understand how songwriting works.
Rv1709 Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) Wasn't there a rumor that she heard Already Gone and then told Ryan she wants a song like that? Edited October 22 by Rv1709
Mamamo Posted October 22 Posted October 22 On 10/16/2024 at 3:23 PM, Bloo said: It's in Verse 2. Not her adding the second again.. I-
Robyn. Posted October 23 Posted October 23 To be honest, he's right about the fact that it sounds better with the word "again"
Recommended Posts