MusicLoverDude Posted October 12 Posted October 12 No. She went viral with a more accessible version of ARTPOP. She'll fade back into the indie pop scene within a year or two. 1 1
Cain Posted October 12 Posted October 12 2 minutes ago, MusicLoverDude said: No. She went viral with a more accessible version of ARTPOP. She'll fade back into the indie pop scene within a year or two. ย I've never seen anyone describe Brat more incorrect than this 7 1 6
Contessa Posted October 12 Posted October 12 9 minutes ago, MusicLoverDude said: No. She went viral with a more accessible version of ARTPOP. She'll fade back into the indie pop scene within a year or two. Glad to see you're still as delusional as ever. ย OT: yesย 1 1
MusicLoverDude Posted October 12 Posted October 12 6 minutes ago, Cain said: ย I've never seen anyone describe Brat more incorrect than this Both albums are very overproduced. Charli is just...again...the more accessible version 1
MusicLoverDude Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 minute ago, Contessa said: Glad to see you're still as delusional as ever. ย OT: yesย A member who only joined two years ago is saying "glad to see you're still as delusional as ever" when we: ย 1. Never interacted before 2. Coming in here to call me delusional over Charli XCX of all people 1 1
Cain Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 minute ago, MusicLoverDude said: Both albums are very overproduced. Charli is just...again...the more accessible version 1) there's nothing inaccessible about ARTPOP, it's standard dancepop 2) Brat is eons better and actually less accessible ย there's not a single song on AP that comes close to ITAIATT 1
PerfectCure Posted October 12 Posted October 12 Yes for people whose favourite app is Twitter No for everyone else 2 1 1
Relampago. Posted October 12 Posted October 12 No, and she even acknowledged this in her recent interview.ย ย She does her best work when she's not pandering to the mainstream anyways though. Crash and Sucker were cute albums but when you compare them to her other workโฆ there's a clear quality difference. ย And that's not to say Charli's more niche music is inherently superior to "mainstream" pop, it's just that she doesn't excel at it like she does with her more out there music. You can make mainstream music and still produce excellent quality if it's what you're good at (Future Nostalgia, The Fame Monster, Fever, COADF, SOSโฆ) 2
Relampago. Posted October 12 Posted October 12 7 minutes ago, MusicLoverDude said: Both albums are very overproduced. Charli is just...again...the more accessible version The biggest hits from Brat are 360 and Apple, both of which are prettyโฆ simple and clean production-wise? Guess is a bit "overproduced" with the breakdown, but not too much outside of that.ย ย I wouldn't even call Guess overproduced though, it's just a dance track. 1
itshyolee Posted October 12 Posted October 12 She had a cute moment this summer and now y'all wanna try to label her as a MPG?ย
RideOrDie Posted October 12 Posted October 12 33 minutes ago, Cain said: 1) there's nothing inaccessible about ARTPOP, it's standard dancepop 2) Brat is eons better and actually less accessible ย there's not a single song on AP that comes close to ITAIATT ik you are an OGH and all that but saying artpop is accessible and a standard dancepop album is... this artpop/brat comparison is silly but brat is way more accessible than artpop...ย you need to be serious pls ย
Cain Posted October 12 Posted October 12 (edited) 2 minutes ago, RideOrDie said: ik you are an OGH and all that but saying artpop is accessible and a standard dancepop album is... this artpop/brat comparison is silly but brat is way more accessible than artpop...ย you need to be serious pls ย What are you talking about ย ARTPOP has some clunky lyrics but it's an album made by Zedd in 2012 ffs ย Nothing in the production is 'out there' or anythingย ย Even BTW is less accessible than AP Edited October 12 by Cain 1
Contessa Posted October 12 Posted October 12 46 minutes ago, MusicLoverDude said: A member who only joined two years ago is saying "glad to see you're still as delusional as ever" when we: ย 1. Never interacted before 2. Coming in here to call me delusional over Charli XCX of all people 1. Let's just sayโฆ your reputation precedes youย ย 2. One can be delusional about anything, and since this is a thread ABOUT Charli, I can call you out on your delusions comparing artpop to brat. Hope that helps!
Doctor Dick Posted October 12 Posted October 12 (edited) No. She can't score a solo hit without Billie or Ariana and this entire remix album debuted big because other acts were on it. Until she can prove she has drawing power without any other artist then she cannot become a MPG who is able to smash all by herself.ย Edited October 12 by Doctor Dick 2
Recommended Posts