Hurem Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 hour ago, TayDuaStan said: The way it has more tracks above 100M than Charli xcx's entire discography 1 hour ago, TayDuaStan said: Quality is subjective. Consumption is not and according to certified data, it's clear what people like, cause TTPD is WAY ahead of Brat in every possible metric 20 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said: I see the xcx police has arrived. With how many there are, you would expect Charli to be the biggest music seller this year but then you wake up 2 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said: You know why they get so offended when we talk about charts… What is this random obsession with Charli? I can only assume its because Brat was a much bigger moment than TTPD and you somehow feel threatened by another woman's success 5 8
Blue Monday Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 minute ago, Janet said: Also more critically successful than any Taylor album insecure and insufferable .. like fan like fav i guess? Right like why are they so insistent on reminding us Taylor is bigger than Charli like we're not aware of that already or as if that has anything to do with quality 2 3
réveuse Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 hour ago, TayDuaStan said: The way it has more tracks above 100M than Charli xcx's entire discography 24 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said: I see the xcx police has arrived. With how many there are, you would expect Charli to be the biggest music seller this year but then you wake up YOU WERE LITERALLY THE ONE THAT BRUNG UP CHARLI IN THE FIRST PLACE- 💀😭 3 3
Princess Aurora Posted October 12 Posted October 12 (edited) Congrats on Taylor getting this other record Edited October 12 by Princess Aurora 1 1
byzantium Posted October 12 Posted October 12 35 minutes ago, Taemira said: You Swifties and Taylor are the worst misogynists in Pop culture ATRLers: "we need to take down Taylor and her fans so we can go back to attacking Chappell Roan and Lady Gaga." 3 1 5
Fromi Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 hour ago, TayDuaStan said: Quality is subjective. Consumption is not and according to certified data, it's clear what people like, cause TTPD is WAY ahead of Brat in every possible metric mmmmm Yummy McDonalds music 1 3
woohoo Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 hour ago, HonourableVomit said: "Quality is subjective" I kinda feel like 100s of millions of listeners verdicts > 20 sum prematurely balding white guys statistically but I like both and I'm not in this battle. Carry on🫡 1 10 1 1
Sweeftie13 Posted October 12 Posted October 12 2 minutes ago, Fromi said: mmmmm Yummy McDonalds music always mention McDonald's because that's probably the only place that would hire you 14
Fromi Posted October 12 Posted October 12 2 minutes ago, Sweeftie13 said: always mention McDonald's because that's probably the only place that would hire you Whatever you need to say to keep enjoying your slop. Most consumed != Best / Highest Quality. 2 5
makeme Posted October 12 Posted October 12 1 hour ago, TayDuaStan said: Quality is subjective. Consumption is not and according to certified data, it's clear what people like, cause TTPD is WAY ahead of Brat in every possible metric seems like you stan Taylor's numbers and not her mid tier music 3 3 1 4
Blue Monday Posted October 12 Posted October 12 17 minutes ago, Sweeftie13 said: always mention McDonald's because that's probably the only place that would hire you Attacking someone's employment status because you can't engage with the substance of the argument that they're making is a strong indicator that you've lost the plot 1 1 8
Taylena Posted October 12 Posted October 12 It's just another minor achievement for the biggest female artist of all times. 5
Kern Posted October 12 Posted October 12 46 minutes ago, Hurem said: What is this random obsession with Charli? I can only assume its because Brat was a much bigger moment than TTPD and you somehow feel threatened by another woman's success They got destroyed with dislikes in Brat remix thread for their horrible awful takes and they're pressed af 1 2
burninredhot Posted October 12 Posted October 12 I can't with charli stans calling brat the "biggest moment" this year but then getting mad at someone pointing out the album's subpar sales Every pop girl goes through the same insufferable behaviour, so maybe just calm down and stop throwing hands over any minor critique 2 11 1
LadyDiana Posted October 12 Posted October 12 I live in rural germany and our lical supermarket they played fortnight, I never even hear any of that brat girl songs 4 1
penguintim Posted October 12 Author Posted October 12 54 minutes ago, Janet said: insecure and insufferable .. like fan like fav i guess? Mind you, sn't Sympathy Is A Knife all about how Taylor makes Charli feel insecure? That said, I'm a Charli fan too and the user who prompted this nonsense is a Dua stan, I implore my fellow angels to pivot to dragging Radical Optimism's numbers instead and leave Taylor alone 7
velocity Posted October 12 Posted October 12 but daddy i love him deserved it. the way she lashes the deranged stans and they're boping along to it will never not be funny 3
By the Water Posted October 12 Posted October 12 The xboxers saying they don't care about numbers then bragging about a metacritic score 2 2 9
wastedpotential Posted October 12 Posted October 12 (edited) Brat had a big moment, but like... there's a degree of terminal onlineness required and the cultural permutation was not as deep as y'all would like to think And as for TTPD getting worse reviews, well yes of course, that was to be expected. Despite original intentions, these reviewers are fundamentally working to drive advertising revenue for their parent companies, and shitting on the biggest artist of the century drives exponentially more traffic than praising an album from an indie darling that'll finally go Platinum in the 2030s, lets please not be obtuse. Anyway snaps for IHIH, it's an excellent song about the emotional turmoil and insecurity in aging out of one's youth that deeply resonates with me, I hope some of y'all running in here to fight go give it a stream! Matthew or Mark or Luke or John, The Apostletross, and St. Peter next Edited October 12 by wastedpotential 6 1 2 1
Matchatea Posted October 12 Posted October 12 Why are we fighting over Brat and TTPD in this thread omg? The gay on gay violence…. 1
Klein Posted October 12 Posted October 12 I just wanted to say I'm surprised Morgan Wallen's not the one with this record considering how successful his albums have been but oh well... Let's settle for a good old fashioned ATRL nonsense about a subject that's already been beaten to death aka TTPD vs Brat. And I don't know who I'm supposed to support because I don't understand why Swifties are taking the bait and bringing up the numbers as if nobody knew that TTPD is infinitely more successful or the antis who are tired of reading these numbers but at the same time are constantly baiting Swifties by saying nobody but the fans listened to TTPD and then gaslighting them when they drag the underwhelming numbers of Brat. I guess this sums it all up: 4 1
Calvin Posted October 12 Posted October 12 2 hours ago, Janet said: Also more critically successful than any Taylor album insecure and insufferable .. like fan like fav i guess? Said nobody. 4 AOTYs are still the biggest acclaim an album or artist can get. Charli has glorious ZERO. 6 1
Recommended Posts