base talk Confessions on a dancefloor vs Aphrodite

[DiabeticGrandpa]

Our fav hags and their best albums. 
 

 

which one is the best ? Madonna's or Kylie's?

[Alongoria13]

Madonna is much better. I think that album goes flat after Future Lovers but it never goes as low as Aphrodite does several times

[fememeist]

 

31 minutes ago, DiabeticGrandpa said:

their best albums

 

31 minutes ago, DiabeticGrandpa said:

Kylie's

[nostalgic]

Confessions is at least plausible as Madge's best album but Kylie has several better than Aphrodite, let's be serious for a moment. Anyhoo...Godfessions.

[LadyDiana]

All the lovers was cute, but sis

[iamanearthling]

Is this a real question? 

[pxxxtrick]

Aphrodite is nowhere near Kylie's best album. 

[808dream]

Love All The Lovers (and Put Your Hands Up), but Confessions is such a solid and perfect project that is unrivaled. 

Stuart Price and Madonna created magic. 

[Mephisto]

Aphrodite is not Kylie's best (it's one of the best tho), but it's better than Confessions, which is very overrated tbh. 

[P.O.P]

Madonna doing Kylie vs. Kylie doing Kylie

 

I have to go with Kylie 

[Princess Aurora]

Confessions on a Dancefloor 

[AxelFox]

Aphrodite is not among Kylie's best work. There's some good stuff on it but the vocal processing on a lot of songs is bothersome, and the tracklist is pretty bad.

 

I've re-arranged it in my iTunes and it makes for a better listen but still, Confessions is a much stronger record. 

 

A controversial side note though, the Aphrodite tour > Confessions tour. 

Edited October 11 by AxelFox

[ChooseyLover]

Aphrodite is painfully overrated to the point it's being compared to COADF.

Edited October 11 by ChooseyLover

[The7thStranger]

Both are great, but Confessions is stronger from start to finish.

[Iminmysluttyera]

Confessions !!

[JoeAg]

never been a big fan of Confessions, so this goes to Aphrodite for me 

[Oktober Knight]

Confessions is better but I really do love Aphrodite